notdual.

Where the paths meet

Two traditions, one question, side by side.

A pencil figure at a table with two faint outlines of himself, all inside one large ochre circle.

Advaita and Krishnamurti: the observer and the witness

You tell yourself to calm down. Now there are two of you. Which one is real?

A pencil hand resting open, palm up, beneath a rose circle inside a larger indigo ring.

Advaita and Nisargadatta: “I am” and the Self

Before you know your name or your mood, you already know one thing: that you are.

A watercolour of a spiral stairway with small robed figures climbing into a great golden sun.

Aurobindo and Shankara

Two Indian philosophers, twelve centuries apart, agree there is only the whole. Then they part.

A painted portrait of George Berkeley in black clerical dress and cap, seated and pointing.

Berkeley, Kant and appearance

Samuel Johnson kicked a stone to refute Berkeley. The stone did not settle it.

An oil painting of worn books, some lying open, heaped on a wooden table beside a violin.

Bradley and Shankara

An Oxford don in 1893 reasoned his way to a word an Indian teacher had used: appearance.

A Japanese woodblock print of men sawing a huge timber propped on a trestle, with Mount Fuji in the distance.

Chop wood, carry water

You hoped knowing who you are would change everything. The dishes are still in the sink.

An open pencil notebook with a single question mark on a terracotta ground under a moss-green arc.

Daya Krishna's questions to Advaita

In Jaipur a philosopher kept asking Advaita what it had stopped asking itself.

A woodcut from Descartes of a head, with lines running from an arrow into the two eyes and back to a small gland inside the brain.

Dennett and the witness

Dennett spent fifty years proving no little man watches inside your head. The Upanishads agree.

A painting of Shankara seated under trees by a lotus pond, teaching four disciples in ochre robes.

Eckhart and Shankara

A friar in Cologne and a teacher in India both drew a line above God as we picture him.

A pencil oil lamp whose flame rises into a rose circle, set against a moss-green arc.

Hallaj and the Upanishads

Two sentences, almost the same: “I am the Real” and “I am Brahman”. One man was killed for his.

A pen drawing of the view from one's own eye: a nose edge, a moustache, legs stretched out and a room beyond, with no head in sight.

Harding and the witness

Point at the wall. Then point back at your own face. What do you find there?

A fine pencil grid with small moss, rose and indigo beads at its crossings, inside a wide ochre circle.

Indra's net and the whole

A net of jewels across the sky. Look into one and you see all the others.

A pencil oil lamp and its flame reflected in a bowl of water, inside a rose circle edged with indigo triangles.

Kashmir Shaivism and Advaita

Two schools agree that awareness is all there is. They disagree about whether it plays.

A Tibetan painted scroll of Nagarjuna seated on a lotus in orange robes, serpent hoods behind his head, smaller figures around him.

Nagarjuna and Gaudapada

Look for the exact moment anything began. Two Indian thinkers did, and could not find it.

An ink painting on faded silk of an old man riding an ox, with red seals in the margins.

No outward mark: why the knower looks like everyone else

The sage in the Tao Te Ching wears coarse cloth and carries a jewel inside.

An engraving of Plato's cave: prisoners crowd in the dark, watching shadows cast by figures carried behind a wall, while a few look toward the light.

Plato's cave and appearance

Prisoners watch shadows on a wall. A traveller jumps back from a rope at dusk.

A painting of Shankara seated under trees by a lotus pond, teaching four disciples in ochre robes.

Plotinus and Shankara

Sunlight fills a room. Did it travel in, or was the room always in the light?

A single pencil line drawing of a woman walking with a small flame in one hand and a water jar in the other.

Rabia and the love that leaves no lover

A woman in Basra asked to be shut out of paradise if paradise was why she prayed.

A watercolour of temples and many flights of stone steps leading down to a wide, calm river, with small crowds bathing at the water's edge.

Ramakrishna and many paths

A temple priest at Dakshineswar tried path after path and said he arrived at the same place.

A Persian miniature of Rumi meeting Shams of Tabriz on the road, a crowd of turbaned men and a rider around them.

Rumi and the Upanishads

Everyone knows the ache of missing someone. Rumi built a whole path on it.

A pencil drawing of an old man with wild white hair reading by lamplight, before an indigo circle with an ochre ring.

Schopenhauer and the Upanishads

A German philosopher kept a Latin Upanishad close for forty years and called it the consolation of his life.

A pencil cat sits beside a closed wooden box inside an indigo circle, among soft watercolour shapes.

Schrödinger and the Upanishads

In 1943 a Nobel physicist ended a book about living cells by quoting the Upanishads.

A pair of open pencil hands holding nothing, against a rose circle and a narrow indigo arc.

Simone Weil and the I-claim

A philosopher who worked a factory line said the only thing we own is the power to say I.

A marble bust of Socrates, bearded and snub-nosed, with his name carved in Greek beneath.

Socrates and the Upanishads

Socrates asked two generals what courage is until they gave up. In Videha, Gargi pressed a sage too far.

An oil portrait of a young man with long dark curls, a white collar and a black coat.

Spinoza and Shankara

A lens-grinder in Holland proved by geometry what a teacher in India had heard in the Upanishads.

An ink painting on faded silk of an old man riding an ox, with red seals in the margins.

The Tao and Brahman

The Tao Te Ching opens by saying its own subject cannot be named.

A pencil paper tape marked with small squares running over a simple wheel, before an indigo circle with an ochre point.

Turing's machine and the witness

In 1950 Alan Turing asked whether a machine can think. The Kena asked what thinking appears to.

A hanging scroll in bold ink of Bodhidharma's bearded, wide-eyed face, with a line of calligraphy above.

Zen and Advaita

A Zen teacher holds up one finger. An Advaita teacher recites a verse. Same direction.