notdual.
Where the paths meet

Nagarjuna and Gaudapada

Two Indian thinkers, centuries apart, went looking for the moment when anything begins, and could not find it. Scholars still argue about how much the later one learned from the earlier.

Nagarjuna (Buddhist Madhyamaka)

Nothing has its own being. Everything, from a chair to time to the self, makes sense only in dependence on other things; that lack of own-being is emptiness, which is no thing behind things and is itself empty. In truth, nothing arises and nothing ceases.

Gaudapada (Advaita)

Nothing is ever born. Waking, like dream, is appearance in awareness: a firebrand whirled in the dark seems to draw circles, though only the burning point is there, and awareness itself was never produced and never changes. From the highest standpoint there is no one bound and no one freed.

na nirodho na cotpattir na baddho na ca sādhakaḥ / na mumukṣur na vai mukta ity eṣā paramārthatā. Plain rendering: There is no ending and no beginning, no one bound and no one striving, no one wanting freedom and no one freed. This is the highest truth.

Mandukya Karika 2.32; Sanskrit with a plain rendering made for notdual.org (draft)

Where they meet

Both deny that things actually arise. Nagarjuna opens his Root Verses by praising the Buddha for teaching what neither ceases nor arises; Gaudapada makes no-birth (ajati) his last word. Both use two levels of truth: the everyday, where things arise and act, and the highest, where they do not. Both use dream and magic to show how something can appear vividly without standing on its own. And both say the highest truth leaves nothing to gain.

Where they part

Nagarjuna names no ground: emptiness is itself empty, and to make it a substance would be one more view to drop. Gaudapada says the unborn is awareness, the Self, which depends on nothing.

What most readings miss

Gaudapada uses Buddhist words freely and, in his fourth chapter, engages Buddhist arguments at length; some scholars have called him half a Buddhist, others say he turned his opponents' tools to Upanishadic ends. For a reader, the more useful point is simpler. Both arguments work by showing that you cannot find the moment of birth. Try it with a thought. Where was it just before it came? The difference is what each says is left when the search fails. For Nagarjuna, nothing that could be held. For Gaudapada, the one who was searching.

No birth

Nagarjuna

Neither ceasing nor arising

Things arise in dependence, so nothing has its own being; this is emptiness.

Gaudapada

Ajati, no-birth

Nothing is ever born; there is no dissolution and no one bound or freed.

The Buddha

Dependent arising

This being, that becomes; this not being, that does not become.

The site's reading: both find no beginning anywhere; Gaudapada adds that what cannot be born is the one looking.

Look for the moment anything was born. Notice who is looking.

Next on your path

Sources

  • Nagarjuna, Mulamadhyamakakarika, dedicatory verses (the Buddha praised for teaching dependent arising, without ceasing or arising) and 24.18; paraphrased.
  • Gaudapada, Mandukya Karika 2.32 (Sanskrit with a rendering made for the site, draft); the firebrand (alatachakra) in chapter 4; no-birth (ajativada) throughout chapters 3 and 4.
  • The question of Buddhist influence on Gaudapada is a long scholarly debate (for example Vidhushekhara Bhattacharya, The Agamashastra of Gaudapada, 1943); summarised, not decided.