What is real?
How the paths answer
Advaita (the Gita and the Upanishads)
Real, in the strict sense, means what never stops being: being itself. The world is there, and it is dependent: real as appearance and never on its own, as a pot is real as a pot and never apart from clay.
“There is no existence for that which is unreal; there is no non-existence for that which is real.”
Bhagavad Gita 2.16, tr. K. T. Telang (1882)
Buddhism
Everything made of parts comes and goes, and nothing in it stands on its own. To see that all made things pass is the start of freedom from grasping them.
“‘All created things perish,’ he who knows and sees this becomes passive in pain; this is the way to purity.”
Dhammapada 277, tr. Max Müller (1881)
Taoism (Laozi)
The Tao is what is most real, and it cannot be put into words. Every name catches a part and misses the whole.
“The Tao that can be trodden is not the enduring and unchanging Tao.”
Tao Te Ching, chapter 1, tr. James Legge (1891)
Greek philosophy (Heraclitus)
Everything flows, yet the flowing keeps one order, which Heraclitus calls the Word (Logos). The water is never the same; the river remains.
“You cannot step twice into the same rivers; for fresh waters are ever flowing in upon you.”
Heraclitus, fragments 41 and 42, tr. John Burnet, Early Greek Philosophy
Spinoza
There is one substance, which Spinoza calls God or Nature. Every thing is a way in which that one substance shows itself.
“Whatsoever is, is in God, and without God nothing can be, or be conceived.”
Spinoza, Ethics, Part I, Proposition 15, tr. R. H. M. Elwes (1883)
Sufism (Rumi)
In Rumi's story, people touch an elephant in a dark room and each calls the part he touched the whole. The senses hold only a part; the real needs a fuller light.
“The eye of outward sense is as the palm of a hand, / The whole of the object is not grasped in the palm.”
Rumi, Masnavi, Book III, Story 5, tr. E. H. Whinfield (1898)
Where they meet
The not-two reading (Advaita's, offered as a reading). None of these paths says the world is nothing. Each says it does not stand on its own: it flows (Heraclitus), it is made of parts (the Buddha), it is a way of one substance (Spinoza), it is grasped only in part (Rumi), it cannot be named (Laozi). Advaita says it in one word: dependent. What it depends on is being, which you have never stepped out of. The Buddha stops at “nothing stands on its own” and does not name a ground; Advaita names it, and that is where they part.
What is real?
Advaita
Pot and clay
Being never stops being; the world is real as appearance and never on its own.
Heraclitus
The river
Everything flows, and one Word (Logos) runs through the flowing.
Spinoza
Substance and modes
One substance, God or Nature; every thing is a way it shows itself.
Sufism (Rumi)
The elephant in the dark
The senses hold a part; the real needs a fuller light.
The site's reading: none of these paths says the world is nothing; each says it does not stand on its own, and what it stands on is being.
The world is real. It is just never on its own.
Next on your path
Sources
- The Bhagavadgita, tr. Kashinath Trimbak Telang, Sacred Books of the East vol. 8 (Oxford, 1882), 2.16. Public domain.
- The Dhammapada, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 10 (Oxford, 1881), verse 277. Public domain.
- The Tao Teh King, tr. James Legge, Sacred Books of the East vol. 39 (Oxford, 1891), chapter 1. Public domain.
- Heraclitus, fragments 41 and 42, in John Burnet, Early Greek Philosophy (1892; 2nd ed. 1908). Public domain.
- Spinoza, Ethics, tr. R. H. M. Elwes, in The Chief Works of Benedict de Spinoza, vol. 2 (London: George Bell, 1883), Part I, Prop. 15. Public domain.
- Masnavi i Ma'navi, abridged and tr. E. H. Whinfield (1898), Book III, Story 5, “The Elephant in a Dark Room”. Public domain.