Harding and the witness
Douglas Harding
Harding asked people to take their own experience at face value: point at the wall, the floor, your feet, then back at where others see your face. From here there is no face, only an open capacity in which the finger, the room and the world appear. It takes a moment, and no belief.
Advaita
The witness (sakshi) is awareness in relation to the mind, the presence in which every thought, sight and feeling appears; it is not a someone watching, and never one of the things seen. It is what you are. Set aside everything seen and it is recognised.
“He is the unseen Seer, the unheard Hearer, the unthought Thinker, the ununderstood Understander.”
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.7.23, tr. Hume, 1921
Where they meet
Both point to the same place: the one looking, which is never in the view. Both say it is featureless. And full of the world. Both say it is available now, without study, to anyone willing to look. And both refuse to make it a special experience: Harding's experiments take seconds, and Advaita says the witness was present all along.
Where they part
Harding trusted the experiment and its repetition, and kept away from scripture. Advaita holds that the seeing needs the teaching's understanding, so that it holds when the experiment is over and the old claim returns.
What most readings miss
People try Harding's pointing, see the space, and say: so what? The Upanishads would say: exactly. The witness is so plain that it is overlooked, and the work is to let the plain seeing change who you take yourself to be.
The headless view
Douglas Harding
Having no head
Where others see your face, you find a clear space full of the world.
Ernst Mach
The view from the left eye
A drawing of what one eye sees: nose, moustache, room, and no head.
The Upanishads
The unseen seer
The seer is never seen; there is no other seer.
The site's reading: the one looking is never in the view; Advaita calls it the witness, and it is not a someone.
Point back. Nothing there, and everything.
Next on your path
Sources
- Douglas Harding, On Having No Head (1961; in copyright), paraphrased.
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.7.23, tr. Hume 1921.
- Robert Ernest Hume, The Thirteen Principal Upanishads (Oxford, 1921). Public domain.