Turing's machine and the witness
Alan Turing
Turing replaced “can machines think?” with a game: if a machine can converse so well that a judge cannot reliably tell it from a person, we should say it thinks. To the objection that it would not actually feel anything, he answered that we cannot know another person's feelings either; we judge from what they do.
Advaita
The mind is inert on its own. It seems aware because awareness shines in it, as a mirror seems bright in the sun, and thoughts are objects that appear in the witness, which is never one of them. So whether thought can be produced is a different question from what knows the thought.
“That which does not think by mind, and by which, they say, mind is thought, that alone know as Brahman.”
Kena Upanishad 1.5, tr. Müller, 1879
Where they meet
Both separate thinking from whatever else we mean by a mind. Turing said that thinking, judged by behaviour, could belong to a machine. Advaita agrees that thinking is an activity of an instrument, and that instruments can be built. Neither settles it by intuition or pride. Language models today pass something close to Turing's test, and on this site's reading their success shows something true about thought.
Where they part
Turing set aside the question of awareness as one we cannot test. Advaita says awareness is the one thing that cannot be set aside, because every test appears to it.
What most readings miss
Turing's test is often called a test for consciousness. He did not claim that. He proposed it because he thought consciousness could not be tested, and left that question open. The Upanishads open with that question.
Thinking and the witness
Alan Turing
The imitation game
If a machine's answers cannot be told from a person's, call it thinking.
Advaita
The instrument
Thinking is the work of an instrument; instruments can be built.
Kena Upanishad
That by which mind thinks
What the mind cannot think, but by which the mind is thought: know that.
The site's reading: thinking may belong to machines; awareness is what any thinking appears to, and it is no one's machine.
The machine answered. What knew the answer?
Next on your path
Sources
- A. M. Turing, “Computing Machinery and Intelligence”, Mind 59 (1950), sections 1 and 6, paraphrased.
- Kena Upanishad 1.5, tr. Müller, SBE 1 (1879).
- F. Max Müller, The Upanishads, Sacred Books of the East vols. 1 (1879) and 15 (1884). Public domain.
- Whether language models pass the test is a matter of current debate; the sentence here is a summary, not a claim about any one study.
- Kena verse numbers follow Hume (1921) and the notdual Library; Müller's own numbering runs one higher from his 1.4 (he divides Hume's 1.3 in two).