notdual.
Where the paths meet

Daya Krishna's questions to Advaita

A philosopher in Jaipur kept asking the Indian traditions questions they had not asked themselves. Some of his sharpest were for Advaita.

Daya Krishna

Daya Krishna asked why a self-shining Self should need a teaching at all, what exactly knowledge removes if the Self is never actually covered, and how not-knowing can belong to anyone if there is only one reality. He questioned the common claim that all Indian philosophy aims at liberation, and asked why so much of it was written as commentary. He wanted the traditions alive.

Advaita

Advaita says the Self is self-shining and never lost: what is missing is recognition, because the mind takes the Self for the body-mind, and this not-knowing is beginningless, cannot be explained, and is openly admitted as the price of the view. The teaching does not produce the Self. It removes a mistake, as a mirror shows a face it did not make.

“Sir, what is that through which, if it is known, everything else becomes known?”

Mundaka Upanishad 1.1.3, tr. Müller, 1884

Where they meet

Both treat questioning as the life of philosophy: the Upanishads are made of questions, and Daya Krishna's questions follow their example. Both agree that Advaita's not-knowing is its hardest point. Both distrust tradition that only repeats itself. A reader who has followed this site can take each of his questions and see where the plain words hold and where they strain.

Where they part

Daya Krishna left his questions open on purpose, and doubted any final answer. Advaita holds that one question, who am I, has an answer that ends the asking.

What most readings miss

His questions are often read as attacks. He spent years arranging face-to-face debates between pandits and modern philosophers so that the tradition could answer in its own voice. That is respect of the most demanding kind.

A tradition questioned

Daya Krishna

The questioner at the door

Ask a tradition the questions it has not asked itself.

Advaita

Inexplicable not-knowing

Not-knowing is beginningless and cannot be explained as real or unreal; Advaita says so openly.

Mundaka Upanishad

Shaunaka's question

What is it that, when known, all this becomes known?

The site's reading: Advaita pays with an inexplicable not-knowing it admits; on the site's reading that is the smaller price, a judgment and not a verdict.

A tradition that cannot be questioned has stopped thinking.

Next on your path

Sources

  • Daya Krishna, Indian Philosophy: A Counter Perspective (1991) and Samvada (1991), both in copyright, paraphrased. The questions are summarised from his writings in the site's words.
  • Mundaka Upanishad 1.1.3, tr. Müller, SBE 15 (1884).
  • F. Max Müller, The Upanishads, Sacred Books of the East vols. 1 (1879) and 15 (1884). Public domain.