Schrödinger and the Upanishads
Erwin Schrödinger
Science builds its picture of the world by leaving the knower out, and so can never find the knower inside it. Each of us says “I”, yet experience is never met with in the plural; the many minds, he argued, are one mind, appearing many times, and he found this said most clearly in the Upanishads. His summary: Atman equals Brahman.
The Upanishads
The Self in you is the whole. The one who sees through your eyes is the one who sees through all eyes; there is no second seer. The many are names and forms, dependent on the one, as pots are on clay.
“There is no other seer but he, there is no other hearer but he, there is no other perceiver but he, there is no other knower but he.”
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.7.23, tr. Max Müller (1884)
Where they meet
Both say the knower cannot be found among the things known: the Upanishads call it the seer who is never seen, and Schrödinger notes that the mind which makes the scientific picture never appears in it. Both deny there are many knowers. And both arrive there by careful reasoning, not by a reported vision: a debate at a king's court in one case, a physicist's thinking about what physics leaves out in the other.
Where they part
Schrödinger speaks of one mind or one consciousness, offers it as a considered view, and does not give a way to live it. The Upanishads say what the one is, being and awareness, full, and give a way to know it as oneself.
What most readings miss
Readers sometimes take Schrödinger's view as quantum physics proving the Upanishads. He claimed nothing of the kind. His point runs the other way: physics, by its method, cannot reach the knower, so the question of the knower has to be met elsewhere, and he found the clearest answer in old Indian texts. The meeting is between two careful looks at one fact: whatever you know, you are not one of the things known.
The missing knower
Schrödinger
The picture without the painter
The mind builds the scientific world-picture and leaves itself out of it.
The Upanishads
The unseen seer
He is the unseen seer, the unheard hearer; there is no other seer.
Schrödinger
Only one mind
The plurality of minds is only apparent; in truth there is one.
The site's reading: physics, by its method, cannot reach the knower; the Upanishads begin there.
Physics leaves out the knower. The Upanishads begin there.
Next on your path
Sources
- Erwin Schrödinger, What Is Life? (Cambridge University Press, 1944), from lectures at Trinity College Dublin in February 1943; epilogue “On Determinism and Free Will” (ATMAN = BRAHMAN). In copyright; paraphrased.
- Erwin Schrödinger, Mind and Matter (1958), chapter 4, on the plurality of minds; in copyright; paraphrased.
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.7.23 (Yajnavalkya at the court of King Janaka), in The Upanishads, Part II, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 15 (Oxford, 1884). Public domain.