The Science of Being
A physicist spends years measuring particles and then, one evening, wonders: what is it, in me, that knows any of this? That moment has come to more scientists than you might expect.
This page follows seven of them, from the seventeenth century to the twentieth. We present each as a scientist or thinker first, in their own terms. None of them was an Advaitin.
Order. Isaac Newton found one set of laws ruling the apple and the moon, and saw in that order the work of an intelligent being. Gottfried Leibniz, his rival, pictured every simple substance as a living mirror of the whole universe.
Seeing. Goethe, poet and naturalist, insisted that science must include the one who sees: the eye is made for light because it is akin to light.
Mind. William James, the psychologist, studied mystical experience with an open mind and concluded that ordinary waking experience is only one kind among many.
Physics. Erwin Schrödinger, a founder of quantum mechanics, read the Upanishads and wrote that the many minds are in fact one. David Bohm proposed an “implicate order”, an unbroken wholeness from which separate things unfold, and spent years in dialogue with Krishnamurti. J. Robert Oppenheimer read the Bhagavad Gita in Sanskrit, and at the first atomic test it was the Gita he remembered.
As our reading: science finds order everywhere it looks, which Advaita calls the order (Ishvara), the intelligence of the whole. What it cannot put under the microscope is awareness itself, because awareness is doing the looking.
> “It is the ear of the ear, the mind of the mind” > (Kena Upanishad 1.2, tr. Max Müller, 1879)
The instrument can measure everything except the one reading it.
The Science of Being
Newton
The sensorium
Order everywhere, from a source physics does not reach.
Schrödinger
The missing knower
The mind builds the picture and leaves itself out.
William James
The stream
Thought flows; the question is what knows the stream.
Bohm
Wholeness
The whole is undivided; parts are abstractions from it.
The site's reading: science studies objects with great care; the knower is not among them, and that is where the Upanishads begin.
Next on your path
Sources
- Kena Upanishad 1.2, in The Upanishads, Part I, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 1 (Oxford, 1879). Public domain.
- Details and sources are on each thinker page.
- Kena verse numbers follow Hume (1921) and the notdual Library; Müller's own numbering runs one higher from his 1.4 (he divides Hume's 1.3 in two).