Who am I when machines think?
## Outline
1. Opening: a machine answers your question better than you could. 2. The fear: if thinking was what I am, I have been replaced. 3. The idea: thinking was never what you are. Thoughts appear; awareness is what they appear in (positions 5, 8). 4. The old mistake runs both ways: we take the Self for the mind, and the mind for what is aware (position 5). Thinking machines make the second half visible. 5. Degrees of reflection: being is equal in all; position differs (position 9). Whether a machine reflects awareness is an open question; this essay does not settle it. 6. Example: a calculator, a parrot, a person. 7. Line from a text: Kena 1.5. 8. Closing line.
## Draft
You ask a machine a hard question, and in seconds it answers, clearly, better than you would have. For a moment you feel strangely small. If thinking can be done without me, what am I for?
That feeling rests on an assumption: that you are your thinking. Most of us have never questioned it. I think, so the thinking must be me.
Advaita questions it. Thoughts come and go. They are known, and whatever knows them is not one more thought. The witness is not someone sitting behind the mind and watching; it is the presence in which every thought, clever or dull, shows up. That presence is awareness, and it is what you are.
The old mistake, Shankara says, runs both ways. We take the Self to be the body and mind, and we take the body and mind to be aware. Thinking machines bring the second half of that mistake into the open. When a machine reasons, we feel it must be someone. And when we reason, we feel, without ever checking, that we must be the reasoning itself. Both times, thinking is taken for awareness.
This does not tell us whether machines are aware. Being is equal in everything; what differs is how much a frame can reflect. A stone is lit. It does not reflect. A tree reflects life, an animal feeling, and the human mind enough to ask “who am I?”. Where a machine stands on that scale is a real question, and this essay leaves it open.
Take a calculator, a parrot and a person. The calculator gets the sum right, every time, faster than any of us. The parrot can say the words. Only one of the three can wonder who is doing the sum. That wondering adds nothing to cleverness. It is the mind turning toward the light it shines by.
So a machine that thinks takes nothing from you. It removes a wrong idea of you. If your worth was your speed of thought, you were always one faster mind away from being replaced. If you are the awareness in which thinking appears, there was never a competition.
> “That which does not think by mind, and by which, they say, mind is thought, that alone know as Brahman” > (Kena Upanishad 1.5, tr. Max Müller, 1879)
Let the machines think. You were never the thinking.
Next on your path
Sources
- Kena Upanishad 1.5, in The Upanishads, Part I, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 1 (Oxford, 1879). Public domain.
- Mistaking runs both ways: Shankara's preamble to the Brahma Sutra commentary, tr. George Thibaut, SBE vol. 34 (1890), and position 5 of the site's settled positions.
- Degrees of reflection (stone, tree, animal, human): position 9 of the site's settled positions (Pranav Ashar).
- Kena verse numbers follow Hume (1921) and the notdual Library; Müller's own numbering runs one higher from his 1.4 (he divides Hume's 1.3 in two).