Advaita and Krishnamurti: the observer and the witness
Advaita
What you are is awareness, the presence in which the mind and all its states appear; in relation to the mind it is called the witness (sakshi), and its presence is the knowing. It is not a someone watching. The person who claims “I am angry, I must change” is the I-claim, which falls when what you are is recognised.
J. Krishnamurti
The mind is its contents, the known. When I watch my anger and try to control it, the watcher is just more thought, split off and calling itself “me”; in his phrase, “the observer is the observed”. When this is seen, without choosing, the conflict between the watcher and the watched ends, and there is only attention.
“How, O beloved, should he know the Knower?”
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.5.15, tr. Max Müller (1884)
Where they meet
On the observer, they agree completely. The one who stands back from anger and judges it, who promises to improve, who keeps score, is thought dressed up as a neutral watcher: what Advaita calls the I-claim. Both say that effort made by this observer only feeds it, and both say that freedom is found in seeing, now, and never as a later result of its effort. Both, too, are wary of methods that keep the observer busy. Krishnamurti's seeing without choosing and Advaita's recognition describe the same turn: the false centre is seen as false, and drops.
Where they part
Krishnamurti does not name what remains, and he refused scriptures, teachers and systems. Advaita names it, awareness, the witness, and teaches it through the Upanishads, heard and reflected on.
What most readings miss
Many readers take Advaita's witness to be the same observer Krishnamurti dissolves: a subtler watcher sitting behind the mind. It is not. The witness does nothing, chooses nothing and is not a someone. Thoughts, including the observer, shine in its presence. That is where the regress stops: there is no watcher of the witness, because it is not a watcher. Seen this way, when the observer goes, Advaita and Krishnamurti are describing the same quiet, one by saying nothing about it, the other by calling it what you are.
The observer and the witness
Krishnamurti
The observer is the observed
The one who watches anger and tries to change it is thought itself, divided from its own content.
Advaita
The witness (sakshi)
Mental states shine in a presence that does nothing and chooses nothing; that presence is the knowing.
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad
The knower of knowing
How could one know the knower? The question shows that the knower is never an object.
The site's reading: both drop the observer as thought posing as a watcher; what remains is awareness, which was never a someone.
The observer is thought. What knows the observer is not one more observer.
Next on your path
Sources
- J. Krishnamurti, Freedom from the Known (1969) and The First and Last Freedom (1954): paraphrased; the one quoted phrase is “the observer is the observed”. In copyright.
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.5.15, in The Upanishads, Part II, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 15 (Oxford, 1884). Public domain.
- The witness as presence, not watcher: position 8 of the site's settled positions, and the notdual Vocabulary sheet (Attention and awareness).