Who am I?
How the paths answer
Advaita (the Upanishads)
You are not what you see but the seeing itself: the Self, which is awareness and being, the same in all. Body and mind are real as appearances in it, and never apart from it.
“Thou couldst not see the (true) seer of sight, thou couldst not hear the (true) hearer of hearing … This is thy Self, who is within all.”
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.4.2, tr. Max Müller (1884)
Buddhism
The Buddha looks at each thing we call “me”: body, feeling, perception, mental formations and the mind's knowing of things. Each one changes, so none can be held as “mine” or “my self”. Seeing this, clinging falls away.
“The body (Rûpa), O Bhikkhus, is not the self.”
Vinaya, Mahavagga 1.6.38, tr. T. W. Rhys Davids and Hermann Oldenberg (1881)
Taoism (Zhuangzi)
Zhuangzi dreams he is a butterfly, wakes, and cannot say which one is dreaming. We draw the line between “me” and everything else; the Tao runs on both sides of it.
“Now I do not know whether I was then a man dreaming I was a butterfly, or whether I am now a butterfly dreaming I am a man.”
Zhuangzi, chapter 2, tr. Herbert Giles (1889)
Sufism (Rumi)
For Rumi the self we defend is a veil. Only the Beloved is fully real; the lover is what hides him, and love burns the veil away.
“The Beloved is all in all, the lover only veils Him”
Rumi, Masnavi, Book I, Prologue, tr. E. H. Whinfield (1898)
Christian mystics
Paul says the life he lives is no longer his own. Meister Eckhart goes further: in the ground of the soul there is something untouched by time, where God and the soul are one.
“I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me”
Galatians 2:20, King James Version (1611)
Greek philosophy (Heraclitus)
Heraclitus said he searched himself, and found no edge to the search. However far you go inward, there is more.
“You will not find the boundaries of soul by travelling in any direction, so deep is the measure of it.”
Heraclitus, fragment 71, tr. John Burnet, Early Greek Philosophy
Where they meet
The not-two reading (Advaita's, offered as a reading, not a verdict). Each answer takes something away. The Buddha removes everything we cling to as “me”. Zhuangzi blurs the line. Rumi and Paul set the small self aside. Heraclitus finds no floor. Read through Advaita, what is left when all of that is removed is not nothing: it is the awareness to which the removing was plain. The Buddha would not call that awareness a self, and that difference is real. But every path here agrees that the “me” you defend each day is not the last word on who you are.
Who am I?
Advaita
The seer, never the seen
You are the seeing: awareness and being, the same in all.
Buddhism
The five heaps
Body, feeling, perception, formations, knowing: none of them is a lasting self.
Taoism (Zhuangzi)
The butterfly dream
We draw the line between me and the rest; the Tao runs through both.
Sufism (Rumi)
The veil
The self we defend is a veil that love burns away.
The site's reading: each answer takes something away; what cannot be taken away is the one reading this.
You are not what you can point to. You are what sees the pointing.
Next on your path
Sources
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.4.2, in The Upanishads, Part II, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 15 (Oxford, 1884). Public domain.
- Vinaya Texts, Part I, Mahavagga 1.6.38, tr. T. W. Rhys Davids and Hermann Oldenberg, Sacred Books of the East vol. 13 (Oxford, 1881). Public domain.
- Chuang Tzŭ: Mystic, Moralist, and Social Reformer, tr. Herbert A. Giles (London: Bernard Quaritch, 1889), chapter 2. Public domain.
- Masnavi i Ma'navi, abridged and tr. E. H. Whinfield (London: Kegan Paul, 1898), Book I. Public domain.
- Galatians 2:20, King James Version (1611). Public domain (Crown rights apply in the UK only to printing).
- Meister Eckhart on the ground of the soul: paraphrase; see Meister Eckhart, tr. C. de B. Evans from Pfeiffer's edition (London: Watkins, 1924).
- Heraclitus, fragment 71, in John Burnet, Early Greek Philosophy (1892; 2nd ed. 1908). Public domain.