notdual.
Where the paths meet

Plotinus and Shankara

Sunlight fills a room. Does the light come out of the sun and travel, or was the room always in the light? Plotinus and Shankara give different answers, and arrive at nearly the same place.

Plotinus

The One is beyond being and thought. Needing nothing, it overflows, and everything flows from its fullness as light from the sun: first Intellect, then Soul, then the world, each a little further from the source, and the source loses nothing. The soul's task is to turn back and rise, until in rare moments it is alone with the One and there are not two.

Shankara

Brahman, the whole, is being and awareness. It is full: nothing is outside it, and the world is appearance, dependent on the whole, real as appearance and never on its own, as a pot is never apart from clay. Nothing has gone out from the whole, so nothing needs to climb back; what ends is only the mistake about who you are.

“When he shines, everything shines after him; by his light all this is lighted.”

Katha Upanishad 2.5.15, tr. Max Müller (1884)

Where they meet

Both start from fullness. The One and the whole lack nothing, act out of no need, and lose nothing by the world's existence. Both say the highest is beyond every description; both reach it by setting descriptions aside. Both find it at the depth of the self: Plotinus' soul, turning inward, finds the One; Shankara's Self is the whole. And both say that in the final knowing no subject meets an object: it is not two.

Where they part

For Plotinus the world actually flows out from the One in stages, and the soul must make a real return. For Shankara nothing ever went out: the stages are appearance, and the return is recognition, with nobody travelling.

What most readings miss

Plotinus is read as a mystic of rare ecstasies. Shankara, as a cool logician. But Plotinus also says the One is present everywhere and never absent, which all but meets Shankara; and Shankara also allows that the mind must be made clear by practice before knowledge can arise, which comes near to Plotinus' ascent. The difference that remains is real but narrow: whether the many came out of the one, or were only ever the one appearing.

The One and the whole

Plotinus

The overflowing spring

The One, full and seeking nothing, overflows; everything flows from it and longs to return.

Shankara

Rope and snake

Nothing comes out of the whole; the many appear on it, as a snake on a rope.

Katha Upanishad

Everything shines after it

Everything shines after that light; by its light all this is lit.

The site's reading: the climb and the waking arrive at the same light; it never left the room.

The light never left the sun. Plotinus climbs; Shankara wakes.

Next on your path

Sources

  • Plotinus, Enneads, esp. 5.1, 5.2, 6.9, tr. Stephen MacKenna (1917 to 1930): paraphrased. The One present everywhere: e.g. Enneads 6.9.4 and 6.9.7 (paraphrase).
  • Katha Upanishad 2.5.15, in The Upanishads, Part II, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 15 (Oxford, 1884). Public domain.
  • Clarity of mind before knowledge: Shankara's commentaries on the Gita and Brahma Sutra 1.1.1 (the fourfold qualifications).