Eckhart and Shankara
Meister Eckhart
Beyond God as Creator and Father is the Godhead, silent, without qualities, a desert where nothing is distinguished; in the ground of the soul is something uncreated, and there God's ground and the soul's ground are one ground. The way there is detachment. It lets go of every image and every “mine”, until God is born in the soul.
Shankara
The whole (Brahman) is without qualities, being and awareness itself, described only by “not this, not this”; the whole seen as the order and intelligence of everything is Ishvara, and ruling belongs there, not to the whole as such. The Self is the whole. Knowledge removes the mistake that hides this.
“That Self is to be described by No, no! He is incomprehensible, for he cannot be comprehended”
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.5.15, tr. Max Müller (1884)
Where they meet
Both draw the same line. Eckhart separates God, who is God in relation to creatures, from the Godhead, which is beyond all relation. Shankara separates the order (Ishvara), which rules in relation to a world, from the whole, which is beyond all ruling. Both reach the highest by negation, by stripping away images rather than adding them. And both find it not far off but at the root of the one who is looking: the ground of the soul, the Self.
Where they part
Eckhart speaks within Christian faith, of the Trinity, grace and the birth of the Son in the soul. Shankara has no creator-person at the top and treats the world as appearance, not as creation.
What most readings miss
Readers often treat Eckhart's boldest lines as poetry and Shankara's as metaphysics. They are both being exact. When Eckhart says, in effect, that God becomes God only when there are creatures, he is making the same point Shankara makes about the order (Ishvara): ruling belongs to it and depends on appearance, while the whole is beyond it. The Church found this hard: some of Eckhart's statements were condemned in 1329, shortly after his death.
God, Godhead, the whole
Meister Eckhart
The Godhead
Beyond God in relation to creatures is the Godhead, quiet ground without any relation.
Shankara
The order and the whole
Ruling belongs to the order, in relation to a world; the whole is beyond ruling.
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad
Not this, not this
The highest is reached by setting every description aside.
The site's reading: beyond every picture of the highest is what is doing the picturing; Eckhart calls it the ground of the soul, Shankara the Self.
Beyond every picture of the highest is what is doing the picturing.
Next on your path
Sources
- Meister Eckhart, sermons and treatises, tr. C. de B. Evans from Pfeiffer's edition (London: Watkins, 1924): paraphrased (the Godhead and God; the ground; detachment; the sermon on the poor in spirit, where God is said to be God only in relation to creatures).
- Papal bull In agro dominico, 27 March 1329, condemning 28 propositions attributed to Eckhart, who had died by then (probably 1328).
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.5.15, in The Upanishads, Part II, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 15 (Oxford, 1884). Public domain.
- Further reading: Rudolf Otto, Mysticism East and West (German 1926; English 1932; in copyright), the classic comparison of Eckhart and Shankara.