Plato's cave and appearance
Plato
In the Republic, prisoners chained in a cave take the shadows on the wall for the only things there are; one is freed, turned toward the fire, and led up into the sunlight, where he sees real things and, last, the sun that makes them visible. The shadows were not nothing. They were shadows of something, and taken for more than they were.
Advaita
The world is appearance (Maya), real as appearance and never on its own: a rope at dusk is taken for a snake, and the mistake is in what it is taken to be. Knowledge leaves the world standing. It removes only the mistake, and what was always there, being and awareness, is recognised.
“To them, I said, the truth would be literally nothing but the shadows of the images.”
Plato, Republic VII, 515c, tr. Jowett
Where they meet
Both stories blame mistaking, not seeing. The prisoner sees real shadows; the walker sees a real rope. Both say the turn is painful at first: Plato's freed man is dazzled, and Advaita's reader resists hearing that he is not the body. Both name a source that makes everything visible and is not one of the things seen, the Good like the sun, the Self as the light. And both send the one who has seen back into ordinary life: the philosopher returns to the cave, and the one free while living goes on with the same work.
Where they part
Plato's world has levels, from shadows to things to forms to the Good, and real knowledge climbs them. Advaita has no ladder at the top: the sun was in the cave all along, and what you are is the light, not a climber toward it.
What most readings miss
Readers often take the cave to mean that the world is fake and the philosopher escapes it. Plato says the freed man must go back down and help, though the others may mock him. Readers take Advaita the same way. It is the same mistake. In both, seeing changes the claim about the world, and the work in it stays.
Two stories of mistaking
Plato
The cave
Prisoners take shadows for the whole of what is; the freed one turns and climbs to the sun.
Advaita
The rope and the snake
At dusk a rope is taken for a snake; the snake was never there, the rope always was.
Plato
Going back down
The one who has seen the sun returns to the cave to help, though he may be mocked.
The site's reading: the shadows and the snake are real as appearance and never on their own; the turn is to what they depend on.
The shadows were real. Turn round.
Next on your path
Sources
- Plato, Republic 514a to 520a, tr. Jowett; the quoted sentence is 515c.
- Benjamin Jowett, The Dialogues of Plato (Oxford, 1871; 3rd ed. 1892). Public domain.
- The rope and snake: Shankara, commentary on Brahma Sutra 1.1.4, and Gaudapada, Mandukya Karika 2.17 to 18; paraphrased.