Socrates and the Upanishads
Socrates
Socrates took the Delphic motto, “know yourself”, as his life's work, asking people what they meant by justice, courage or piety, examining their answers and showing them, and himself, that they did not know. Knowing that he did not know was his only wisdom. An unexamined life, he said, is not worth living.
The Upanishads
The Upanishads are dialogues too: a father and son, a boy and Death, a sage and his wife, a king's court. Questions are pressed until every answer about the world turns back on the one asking, and “not this, not this” sets aside every answer until only the knower is left. The Self is never an object.
“I must first know myself, as the Delphian inscription says.”
Plato, Phaedrus 230a, tr. Jowett
Where they meet
Both make the question the teaching. Both find that the answers people hold are borrowed, and that examining them clears the ground. Both put self-knowledge first, before knowledge of the stars or the gods. And both end with a kind of not-knowing that is not ignorance: Socrates' knowing that he does not know, the Kena's “It is not understood by those who understand it”.
Where they part
Socrates' examination stays with the soul's virtue and how to live; he does not say the one who knows is the whole. The Upanishads carry the question until the knower is recognised as being itself.
What most readings miss
Socrates is remembered as a man of arguments, but at his trial he spoke of an inner voice and of a calm in the face of death that arguments did not give him. The Upanishads are remembered as mystical, but they are full of arguments, and their sages win debates. Their reputations keep them apart.
The question as teaching
Socrates
The gadfly
Examine every borrowed answer; the unexamined life is not worth living.
Gargi
On what is it woven?
She asks what the world is woven on, and keeps asking, layer after layer.
Yajnavalkya
Do not ask too far
Some questions cannot be answered with an object; the one asking is the answer.
The site's reading: both clear the ground with questions; the Upanishads end where the question turns back on the questioner.
Ask the question until it asks you.
Next on your path
Sources
- Plato, Phaedrus 230a and Apology 21a to 23b and 38a, tr. Jowett.
- Benjamin Jowett, The Dialogues of Plato (Oxford, 1871; 3rd ed. 1892). Public domain.
- Kena Upanishad 2.3, paraphrased; Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 2.3.6, 3.6 and 3.8, paraphrased.
- F. Max Müller, The Upanishads, Sacred Books of the East vols. 1 (1879) and 15 (1884). Public domain.