Advaita and Nisargadatta: “I am” and the Self
Advaita
The Self is being and awareness (sat and chit), full and without a second, and “I am” points to it. No one can doubt being. The person, with its name and history, is awareness appearing through one body-mind; the I-claim takes that frame to be what it is.
Nisargadatta Maharaj
Hold to the sense “I am” and add nothing, neither “I am this” nor “I am that”, and it shows itself as something that came with the body and will go with it. Stay with it. What you actually are is prior even to “I am”: the Absolute, which does not know itself as anything.
“Verily in the beginning this was Brahman, that Brahman knew (its) Self only, saying, ‘I am Brahman.’”
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 1.4.10, tr. Max Müller (1884)
Where they meet
Both begin with the same thing. It is no belief: it is the bare sense of being every reader has right now. Both say that everything added to it, “I am a man, I am tired, I am a failure”, is the person, not you. Both teach that you do not become the Self; you stop taking yourself to be what you are not. And both point beyond the knowing mind to what the mind appears in: Nisargadatta's Absolute and Advaita's whole are described in the same way, without qualities, without a second, not an object.
Where they part
Nisargadatta treats the sense “I am” itself as temporary, to be gone beyond. Advaita treats being (sat) as one of the names of the whole, never to be gone beyond.
What most readings miss
The difference is mostly a difference of level, not of view. The “I am” Nisargadatta tells us to transcend is the sense of being as it appears in the mind, tied to the body: what Advaita calls reflected awareness (chidabhasa) and the I-sense. That does come and go. Advaita agrees. Being itself, which Advaita calls sat, does not, and Nisargadatta's Absolute plays exactly that role. Read this way, he and Shankara are using one word, “being”, at two levels.
“I am” and the Self
Nisargadatta Maharaj
Holding on to “I am”
Stay with the bare sense of being until it shows what lies before it.
Advaita
Reflected light (chidabhasa)
The “I am” in the mind is awareness reflected; the Self is the light it reflects.
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad
“I am Brahman”
Whoever knows “I am Brahman” becomes all this.
The site's reading: the “I am” is the nearest door; walk through it and nothing is added: being, awareness, the whole.
Start with “I am”. Add nothing. See what is before it.
Next on your path
Sources
- Nisargadatta Maharaj, I Am That, ed. Maurice Frydman (1973): paraphrased; in copyright.
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 1.4.10, in The Upanishads, Part II, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 15 (Oxford, 1884). Public domain.
- Reflected awareness (chidabhasa) and the person: notdual Vocabulary sheet; positions 4 and 6.