Berkeley, Kant and appearance
George Berkeley
For things we perceive, to be is to be perceived: take away seeing, touching and the rest, and nothing is found behind them. The world does not vanish when we look away. God's mind holds it.
Immanuel Kant
Space and time are the forms in which anything can appear to us, and concepts such as cause order what appears. We know only appearances. What things are in themselves we cannot know, and the “I think” that goes with all our perceptions is not itself an object we can know.
“How should he know Him by whom he knows all this?”
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.5.15, tr. Max Müller (1884)
Where they meet
All three refuse to treat the world as stuff that exists by itself. All three point to a knower that cannot be found among the things known: Berkeley's mind, Kant's “I think”, the Upanishads' Self. And all three leave the world standing. Johnson's stone stays hard.
Where they part
Berkeley keeps many minds and one infinite mind; Kant leaves what is behind appearance unknown. Advaita says nothing stands behind; the “in itself” is the awareness to which everything appears.
What most readings miss
Kant's unknowable and the Upanishads' unknowable sound the same and are not. For Kant, we cannot reach it. For the Upanishads, it cannot be reached because it is what you are.
Three kinds of appearance
George Berkeley
To be is to be perceived
Things exist as ideas in a mind; the stone is real, and it is perceived.
Immanuel Kant
Things in themselves
We know things as they appear through our forms; what they are in themselves we cannot reach.
Advaita
The pot and the clay
The world is real as appearance and never on its own; it depends on the whole.
The site's reading: the knower is never among the things known; it cannot be reached because it is what you are.
You cannot know the knower. You can be it.
Next on your path
Sources
- George Berkeley, Principles of Human Knowledge (1710), part 1, section 3, public domain, paraphrased.
- Immanuel Kant, Kritik der reinen Vernunft (1781; 2nd edition 1787), paraphrased.
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.5.15, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East 15 (1884), public domain.
- Boswell, Life of Johnson (1791), 6 August 1763, for the stone.