Aurobindo and Shankara
Sri Aurobindo
One reality is: being, awareness and fullness. It has come down into matter and is climbing back up through life and mind toward a fuller consciousness; the world is the whole's own unfolding, not a mistake, and the aim is to transform life on earth, not only to be free of it. He criticised Shankara's teaching for making the world less than real.
Shankara
One reality: the whole, without a second. The world is appearance, real as appearance and never on its own, and freedom is knowledge, which ends the mistake about who you are. The world goes on appearing to the knower, who lives the same life without confinement.
“That from whence these beings are born, that by which, when born, they live, that into which they enter at their death, try to know that. That is Brahman.”
Taittiriya Upanishad 3.1, tr. Müller, 1884
Where they meet
Both begin from the same Upanishads and the same one reality. Both call it being, awareness and fullness. Both reject a world that stands apart from the whole. Both say the person is the whole appearing through a frame. And both say the work is done in this life, here, among other people, and not after it.
Where they part
Aurobindo holds that the unfolding is real at the highest level and still going on, toward a change in human nature. Shankara holds that the whole does not change, and that nothing needs to happen to it for anyone to be free.
What most readings miss
Readers often take Shankara to ask people to leave the world, and Aurobindo to correct him. Advaita teaches (in the Vivekachudamani and Vidyaranya) that knowledge ends the covering, not the projecting: the world goes on, and the knower lives in it. The real gap between them is about the whole: is it changing, or is it changeless? It is a smaller gap. And a more fundamental one.
The world: becoming or appearance
Sri Aurobindo
The descent
The whole involves itself in matter and evolves back; the world is its becoming.
Shankara
Covering and projecting
Knowledge ends the covering; the world goes on appearing to the knower.
Taittiriya Upanishad
That from which beings are born
That from which beings are born, by which they live, into which they return.
The site's reading: already full, the whole has nowhere to go; the knower lives the same life without confinement.
Same whole. Is it becoming, or already full?
Next on your path
Sources
- Sri Aurobindo, The Life Divine (1939 to 1940), paraphrased.
- Taittiriya Upanishad 3.1, tr. Müller, SBE 15 (1884).
- F. Max Müller, The Upanishads, Sacred Books of the East vols. 1 (1879) and 15 (1884). Public domain.
- Covering and projecting: Vivekachudamani 113 to 115 and later Advaita, paraphrased.