notdual.
Where the paths meet

Spinoza and Shankara

A lens-grinder in seventeenth-century Holland, expelled from his community, worked out in geometric proofs a view close to what an Indian teacher had taught from the Upanishads: there is only one reality, and everything is a way it shows itself.

Spinoza

There is one substance, which Spinoza calls God or Nature, with infinite attributes, of which we know two, thought and extension; every thing, every body and every idea, is a mode of it. A mode is a way substance is. Freedom is understanding why things are as they are, and the highest happiness is the intellectual love of God.

Shankara

There is one reality: the whole (Brahman). It is being and awareness, and the world is dependent on it, real as appearance and never on its own, as a pot is real as a pot and never apart from clay. Freedom is knowledge of the Self as the whole.

“My dear, as by one clod of clay all that is made of clay is known, the difference being only a name, arising from speech, but the truth being that all is clay”

Chandogya Upanishad 6.1.4, tr. Max Müller (1879)

Where they meet

There is no second reality, both say. Spinoza's modes are not separate things added to substance; Shankara's pots are not separate things added to clay. Both deny that the world sits outside the one, and both deny that the one is just the sum of things in the world: substance comes first, as clay comes before its shapes. And both find freedom in understanding, and none in escape: seeing things as they are frees us from the passions that come from seeing them wrongly.

Where they part

For Spinoza, extension (matter) is as real as thought, and modes follow from substance by necessity. For Shankara, awareness is the whole, and the world is appearance, dependent on it.

What most readings miss

Both are often called pantheists, as if they said that everything is God, or that the world is the whole. Neither says that. Spinoza says that whatever is, is in God; not that a stone is God. Shankara says the pot is clay; not that clay is a pot. In each case the many depend on the one, and the one does not depend on the many. That one-way dependence is the heart of both systems, and the place where they meet most closely.

One reality, many ways

Spinoza

Substance and its modes

Whatever is, is in God; every thing is a way the one substance is expressed.

Shankara

Clay and pots

The pot is real as a pot and never apart from clay; the world is dependent on the whole.

Chandogya Upanishad

One lump of clay

By one lump of clay all that is made of clay is known.

The site's reading: the many depend on the one, and the one depends on nothing; Advaita adds that the one is awareness.

The many depend on the one. The one depends on nothing.

Next on your path

Sources

  • Spinoza, Ethics (published 1677), tr. R. H. M. Elwes, in The Chief Works of Benedict de Spinoza, vol. 2 (London: George Bell, 1883): Part I, Definitions 3 to 6, Props. 14 and 15; Part V, Props. 32 to 36 (the intellectual love of God). Paraphrased apart from the quoted Prop. 15 elsewhere on the site. “God or Nature” (Deus sive Natura): Part IV, Preface.
  • Spinoza was expelled (cherem) from the Amsterdam Portuguese-Jewish community in 1656 and earned his living grinding lenses.
  • Chandogya Upanishad 6.1.4, in The Upanishads, Part I, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 1 (Oxford, 1879). Public domain.