notdual.
Where the paths meet

Bradley and Shankara

An Oxford don in 1893 and an Indian teacher twelve centuries earlier both concluded that what we meet is appearance, and only the whole is real.

F. H. Bradley

In Appearance and Reality (1893) Bradley took apart every ordinary idea, things and qualities, relations, space, time, the self, and found each contradicts itself. So each is appearance. What is real is the Absolute, a single experience that includes everything, in which every appearance has its place and its contradictions are resolved.

Shankara

The world is appearance (Maya), real as appearance and never on its own: dependent, like a pot that is never apart from clay. What is real in the full sense is the whole, being and awareness without a second, and every distinction belongs to appearance. None divides the whole.

“Hence, now, there is the teaching ‘Not thus! not so!’”

Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 2.3.6, tr. Hume, 1921

Where they meet

Both work by negation. Bradley's dialectic sets aside every idea that cannot stand on its own; Shankara's “not this, not this” sets aside every object. Both refuse to call appearances nothing: Bradley says they are real in degree, Shankara that they are real as appearance. Both name one reality, all-inclusive, with nothing outside it. Bradley's word, appearance, is the same word this site uses for Maya.

Where they part

Bradley's Absolute includes all appearances as its own content, transformed; it is a whole of experience. Shankara's whole is awareness itself, in which appearances arise, and they add nothing to it.

What most readings miss

Bradley is read as a dry logician. He wrote that the Absolute is felt, and that in feeling, before thought splits subject from object, we have a hint of it. That is close to the Upanishads' starting point.

Appearance and the whole

F. H. Bradley

Appearance and Reality

Every idea that cannot stand on its own is appearance; the Absolute alone is real.

Shankara

Not this, not this

Every object is set aside; what is left is the whole, never an object.

Bradley

Feeling before thought

In feeling, before subject and object split, there is a hint of the whole.

The site's reading: appearances are real as appearance and never on their own; the whole that remains is awareness.

Every idea fell. The whole did not.

Next on your path

Sources

  • F. H. Bradley, Appearance and Reality (1893), books 1 and 2, paraphrased. Public domain.
  • Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 2.3.6, tr. Hume 1921.
  • Robert Ernest Hume, The Thirteen Principal Upanishads (Oxford, 1921). Public domain.
  • Shankara, Brahma Sutra Bhashya, introduction and 2.1.14 (the clay and its forms), paraphrased.