Zhuangzi

In the words of Pranav Ashar
How we renderChapter 1: Free and Easy Wandering
逍遙遊
北冥有魚,其名爲鯤。鯤之大,不知其幾千里也,化而爲鳥,其名爲鵬。鵬之背,不知其幾千里也,怒而飛,其翼若垂天之雲。是鳥也,海運,則將徙於南冥。南冥者,天池也。齊諧者,志怪者也。諧之言曰:「鵬之徙於南冥也,水擊三千里,摶扶搖而上者九萬里,去以六月息者也。」野馬也,塵埃也,生物之以息相吹也。天之蒼蒼,其正色邪?其遠而无所至極邪?其視下也,亦若是則已矣。且夫水之積也不厚,則負大舟也无力。覆杯水於坳堂之上,則芥爲之舟,置杯焉則膠,水淺而舟大也。風之積也不厚,則其負大翼也无力,故九萬里,則風斯在下矣,而後乃今,培風背,負青天,而莫之夭閼者,而後乃今將圖南。
běi míng yǒu yú, qí míng wéi kūn. kūn zhī dà, bù zhī qí jǐ qiān lǐ yě, huà ér wéi niǎo, qí míng wéi péng. péng zhī bèi, bù zhī qí jǐ qiān lǐ yě, nù ér fēi, qí yì ruò chuí tiān zhī yún. shì niǎo yě, hǎi yùn, zé jiāng xǐ yú nán míng. nán míng zhě, tiān chí yě. qí xié zhě, zhì guài zhě yě. xié zhī yán yuē: “péng zhī xǐ yú nán míng yě, shuǐ jī sān qiān lǐ, tuán fú yáo ér shàng zhě jiǔ wàn lǐ, qù yǐ liù yuè xī zhě yě.” yě mǎ yě, chén āi yě, shēng wù zhī yǐ xī xiāng chuī yě. tiān zhī cāng cāng, qí zhèng sè yé? qí yuǎn ér wú suǒ zhì jí yé? qí shì xià yě, yì ruò shì zé yǐ yǐ. qiě fú shuǐ zhī jī yě bù hòu, zé fù dà zhōu yě wú lì. fù bēi shuǐ yú ào táng zhī shàng, zé jiè wéi zhī zhōu, zhì bēi yān zé jiāo, shuǐ qiǎn ér zhōu dà yě. fēng zhī jī yě bù hòu, zé qí fù dà yì yě wú lì, gù jiǔ wàn lǐ, zé fēng sī zài xià yǐ, ér hòu nǎi jīn, péi fēng bèi, fù qīng tiān, ér mò zhī yāo è zhě, ér hòu nǎi jīn jiāng tú nán.
In the there is a fish called Kun. No one knows how many thousand li long the Kun is. It changes into a bird called Peng. No one knows how many thousand li wide the Peng's back is. When it and flies, its wings are like clouds hanging from the sky. When the sea heaves, this bird sets out for the dark southern sea, the Pool of . The Tales of Qi Xie, a book of wonders, says: 'When the Peng flies to the southern sea, it beats the water for three thousand li, rides a whirlwind ninety thousand li up, and goes off on the wind of the sixth month.' Heat-haze, dust, . The blue of the sky: is that its true colour, or is it only that it goes on without end? Looking down from up there, the Peng would see just this. If water is not deep enough, it has no strength to carry a big boat. Pour a cup of water into a hollow in the floor and a mustard seed will float as a boat; set the cup in it and it sticks, because the water is shallow and the boat is big. If the wind is not deep enough, it has no strength to carry great wings. So the Peng needs ninety thousand li of wind beneath it. Only then, riding on the wind, with the blue sky on its back and nothing to block it, can it set its course south.
Note //
The opening image of the book: something huge changes into something else and travels far, carried by what has depth enough to carry it. Kun also means fish roe; the vast begins from the tiny. Giles calls the creatures Leviathan and Rukh.
蜩與鷽鳩笑之曰:「我決起而飛,槍榆枋,時則不至,而控於地而已矣,奚以之九萬里而南爲?」適莽蒼者,三湌而反,腹猶果然;適百里者,宿舂糧;適千里者,三月聚糧。之二蟲,又何知?小知不及大知,小年不及大年。奚以知其然也?朝菌不知晦朔,蟪蛄不知春秋。此小年也。楚之南有冥靈者,以五百歲爲春,五百歲爲秋;上古有大椿者,以八千歲爲春,八千歲爲秋。而彭祖乃今以久特聞,衆人匹之,不亦悲乎!
tiáo yǔ xué jiū xiào zhī yuē: “wǒ jué qǐ ér fēi, qiāng yú fāng, shí zé bù zhì, ér kòng yú dì ér yǐ yǐ, xī yǐ zhī jiǔ wàn lǐ ér nán wéi?” shì mǎng cāng zhě, sān cān ér fǎn, fù yóu guǒ rán; shì bǎi lǐ zhě, sù chōng liáng; shì qiān lǐ zhě, sān yuè jù liáng. zhī èr chóng, yòu hé zhī? xiǎo zhì bù jí dà zhì, xiǎo nián bù jí dà nián. xī yǐ zhī qí rán yě? cháo jūn bù zhī huì shuò, huì gū bù zhī chūn qiū. cǐ xiǎo nián yě. chǔ zhī nán yǒu míng líng zhě, yǐ wǔ bǎi suì wéi chūn, wǔ bǎi suì wéi qiū; shàng gǔ yǒu dà chūn zhě, yǐ bā qiān suì wéi chūn, bā qiān suì wéi qiū. ér péng zǔ nǎi jīn yǐ jiǔ tè wén, zhòng rén pǐ zhī, bù yì bēi hū!
A cicada and a little dove laughed at it: 'When we take off with all our might, we reach an elm or a sandalwood tree; sometimes we don't even make it and just drop to the ground. Why go up ninety thousand li to head south?' If you go out to the green fields nearby, you take three meals and come back with your belly still full. If you go a hundred li, you pound grain the night before. If you go a thousand li, you gather grain for three months. What do these two little creatures know? Small knowing does not reach great knowing; a short life does not reach a long one. How do we know it is so? The morning mushroom does not know the turn of the month; the summer cicada does not know spring and autumn. These are short lives. South of Chu there is a tree called Dark Spirit, for which five hundred years is a spring and five hundred years an autumn. In high antiquity there was a great Chun tree, for which eight thousand years was a spring and eight thousand years an autumn. And yet Peng Zu is famous today for living long, and everyone wants to match him. Isn't that sad?
Note //
Neither the small birds nor the great bird are blamed for their size; the trouble is the small measuring the great by their own span. Giles has a tortoise where the Chinese has the tree Dark Spirit (冥靈); commentators differ.
湯之問棘也是已。窮髮之北,有冥海者,天池也。有魚焉,其廣數千里,未有知其脩者,其名爲鯤。有鳥焉,其名爲鵬,背若太山,翼若垂天之雲,摶扶搖羊角而上者九萬里,絕雲氣,負青天,然後圖南,且適南冥也。斥鴳笑之曰:「彼且奚適也?我騰躍而上,不過數仞而下,翺翔蓬蒿之間,此亦飛之至也。而彼且奚適也?」此小大之辯也。故夫知效一官,行比一鄉,德合一君,而徵一國者,其自視也,亦若此矣,而宋榮子猶然笑之。且舉世而譽之,而不加勸,舉世而非之,而不加沮,定乎內外之分,辯乎榮辱之境,斯已矣。彼其於世,未數數然也,雖然,猶有未樹也。夫列子御風而行,泠然善也,旬有五日而後反。彼於致福者,未數數然也。此雖免乎行,猶有所待者也。若夫乘天地之正,而御六氣之辯,以遊无窮者,彼且惡乎待哉?故曰:「至人无己,神人无功,聖人无名。」
tāng zhī wèn jí yě shì yǐ. qióng fà zhī běi, yǒu míng hǎi zhě, tiān chí yě. yǒu yú yān, qí guǎng shù qiān lǐ, wèi yǒu zhī qí xiū zhě, qí míng wéi kūn. yǒu niǎo yān, qí míng wéi péng, bèi ruò tài shān, yì ruò chuí tiān zhī yún, tuán fú yáo yáng jiǎo ér shàng zhě jiǔ wàn lǐ, jué yún qì, fù qīng tiān, rán hòu tú nán, qiě shì nán míng yě. chì yàn xiào zhī yuē: “bǐ qiě xī shì yě? wǒ téng yuè ér shàng, bù guò shù rèn ér xià, áo xiáng péng hāo zhī jiān, cǐ yì fēi zhī zhì yě. ér bǐ qiě xī shì yě?” cǐ xiǎo dà zhī biàn yě. gù fú zhī xiào yī guān, xíng bǐ yī xiāng, dé hé yī jūn, ér zhēng yī guó zhě, qí zì shì yě, yì ruò cǐ yǐ, ér sòng róng zi yóu rán xiào zhī. qiě jǔ shì ér yù zhī, ér bù jiā quàn, jǔ shì ér fēi zhī, ér bù jiā jǔ, dìng hū nèi wài zhī fēn, biàn hū róng rǔ zhī jìng, sī yǐ yǐ. bǐ qí yú shì, wèi shuò shuò rán yě, suī rán, yóu yǒu wèi shù yě. fú liè zi yù fēng ér xíng, líng rán shàn yě, xún yǒu wǔ rì ér hòu fǎn. bǐ yú zhì fú zhě, wèi shuò shuò rán yě. cǐ suī miǎn hū xíng, yóu yǒu suǒ dài zhě yě. ruò fú chéng tiān dì zhī zhèng, ér yù liù qì zhī biàn, yǐ yóu wú qióng zhě, bǐ qiě wū hū dài zāi? gù yuē: “zhì rén wú jǐ, shén rén wú gōng, shèng rén wú míng.”
It was the same in Tang's questions to Ji. 'In the bare north there is a dark sea, the Pool of . In it lives a fish several thousand li broad, and no one knows how long; it is called Kun. There is a bird called Peng, with a back like Mount Tai and wings like clouds hanging from the sky. It rides a whirlwind in a spiral ninety thousand li up, beyond the clouds and the air, with the blue sky on its back, and then sets its course south, for the southern sea. A quail laughed at it: "Where does it think it's going? I leap up and come down after a few yards, flitting about among the weeds; that is the best of flying too. Where does it think it's going?"' This is the difference between small and great. So there are those whose knowing is enough for one office, whose conduct suits one village, whose pleases one ruler and wins the trust of one state. They see themselves just like that quail. Song Rongzi would laugh at them. If the whole world praised him he would not be spurred on; if the whole world blamed him he would not be put off. He was settled about what is inside and what is outside, clear about the line between honour and disgrace, and that was all. He did not chase after the world. Still, there was something he had not planted. Liezi rode the wind and went about, light and easy, and came back after fifteen days. He did not chase after good fortune. Yet although he was spared walking, he still depended on something. But one who rides the true course of and earth, drives the changes of the six breaths and wanders in the boundless: what would he depend on? So it is said: 'The utmost person has no self; the spirit person has no merit; the sage has no name.'
Note //
The ladder climbs from the person content with one office, to Song Rongzi who is unmoved by praise and blame, to Liezi who rides the wind, to one who depends on nothing at all. 'No self' (無己) is the Daoist sense: no fixed self set against the changes. In the site's reading this is close to the I-claim falling away while life goes on (position 6).
堯讓天下於許由,曰:「日月出矣,而爝火不息,其於光也,不亦難乎?時雨降矣,而猶浸灌,其於澤也,不亦勞乎?夫子立而天下治,而我猶尸之,吾自視缺然,請致天下。」許由曰:「子治天下,天下旣已治也,而我猶代子,吾將爲名乎?名者,實之賓也,吾將爲賓乎?鷦鷯巢於深林,不過一枝;偃鼠飲河,不過滿腹。歸休乎君,予无所用天下爲!庖人雖不治庖,尸祝不越樽俎而代之矣。」
yáo ràng tiān xià yú xǔ yóu, yuē: “rì yuè chū yǐ, ér jué huǒ bù xī, qí yú guāng yě, bù yì nán hū? shí yǔ jiàng yǐ, ér yóu jìn guàn, qí yú zé yě, bù yì láo hū? fū zǐ lì ér tiān xià zhì, ér wǒ yóu shī zhī, wú zì shì quē rán, qǐng zhì tiān xià.” xǔ yóu yuē: “zi zhì tiān xià, tiān xià jì yǐ zhì yě, ér wǒ yóu dài zi, wú jiāng wéi míng hū? míng zhě, shí zhī bīn yě, wú jiāng wéi bīn hū? jiāo liáo cháo yú shēn lín, bù guò yī zhī; yǎn shǔ yǐn hé, bù guò mǎn fù. guī xiū hū jūn, yǔ wú suǒ yòng tiān xià wéi! páo rén suī bù zhì páo, shī zhù bù yuè zūn zǔ ér dài zhī yǐ.”
Yao wanted to hand the empire over to Xu You. He said: 'When the sun and moon have come out, to keep a torch burning, isn't that hard on its light? When the timely rain has fallen, to go on watering, isn't that wasted labour? If you, sir, took your place, the empire would be in order, yet I am still standing in for it. I see that I fall short. Let me hand you the empire.' Xu You said: 'You govern the empire, and the empire is already in order. If I took your place, would I be doing it for the name? The name is a guest of the reality; should I be a guest? The wren nests in the deep forest, but only on one branch. The mole drinks from the river, but only enough to fill its belly. Go home and rest, my king. I have no use for the empire. Even if the cook does not tend his kitchen, the priest at the altar does not jump over the wine jars and offering stands to take his place.'
Note //
'The name is a guest of the reality' (名者,實之賓也): names and roles are visitors; Xu You will not trade what he is for a title.
肩吾問於連叔曰:「吾聞言於接輿,大而无當,往而不反。吾驚怖其言,猶河漢而无極也,大有逕庭,不近人情焉。」連叔曰:「其言謂何哉?」「曰:『藐姑射之山,有神人居焉,肌膚若冰雪,淖約若處子,不食五穀,吸風飲露,乘雲氣,御飛龍,而遊乎四海之外。其神凝,使物不疵癘,而年穀熟。』吾以是狂,而不信也。」連叔曰:「然。瞽者无以與乎文章之觀,聾者无以與乎鍾鼓之聲。豈唯形骸有聾盲哉?夫知亦有之。是其言也,猶時女也。之人也,(之德也,)將旁礴萬物,以爲一世蘄乎亂,孰弊弊焉以天下爲事?之人也,物莫之傷,大浸稽天而不溺,大旱金石流、土山焦而不熱,是其塵垢秕穅,將猶陶鑄堯、舜者也,孰肯以物爲事?」宋人資章甫而適諸越,越人斷髮文身,无所用之。堯治天下之民,平海內之政,往見四子藐姑射之山,汾水之陽,窅然喪其天下焉。
jiān wú wèn yú lián shū yuē: “wú wén yán yú jiē yú, dà ér wú dāng, wǎng ér bù fǎn. wú jīng bù qí yán, yóu hé hàn ér wú jí yě, dà yǒu jìng tíng, bù jìn rén qíng yān.” lián shū yuē: “qí yán wèi hé zāi?” “yuē: ‘miǎo gū shè zhī shān, yǒu shén rén jū yān, jī fū ruò bīng xuě, nào yuē ruò chù zi, bù shí wǔ gǔ, xī fēng yǐn lù, chéng yún qì, yù fēi lóng, ér yóu hū sì hǎi zhī wài. qí shén níng, shǐ wù bù cī lì, ér nián gǔ shú.’ wú yǐ shì kuáng, ér bù xìn yě.” lián shū yuē: “rán. gǔ zhě wú yǐ yǔ hū wén zhāng zhī guān, lóng zhě wú yǐ yǔ hū zhōng gǔ zhī shēng. qǐ wéi xíng hái yǒu lóng máng zāi? fú zhī yì yǒu zhī. shì qí yán yě, yóu shí nǚ yě. zhī rén yě, ( zhī dé yě, ) jiāng páng bó wàn wù, yǐ wéi yī shì qí hū luàn, shú bì bì yān yǐ tiān xià wéi shì? zhī rén yě, wù mò zhī shāng, dà jìn jī tiān ér bù nì, dà hàn jīn shí liú, tǔ shān jiāo ér bù rè, shì qí chén gòu bǐ kāng, jiāng yóu táo zhù yáo, shùn zhě yě, shú kěn yǐ wù wéi shì?” sòng rén zī zhāng fǔ ér shì zhū yuè, yuè rén duàn fà wén shēn, wú suǒ yòng zhī. yáo zhì tiān xià zhī mín, píng hǎi nèi zhī zhèng, wǎng jiàn sì zi miǎo gū shè zhī shān, fén shuǐ zhī yáng, yǎo rán sàng qí tiān xià yān.
Jian Wu said to Lian Shu: 'I heard Jie Yu talk, and it was big and went nowhere, off and away with no coming back. I was alarmed by his words, endless as the Milky Way, wide of the mark and far from what people feel.' Lian Shu said: 'What did he say?' 'He said: "On the far Gushe mountain lives a spirit person, with skin like ice and snow, gentle as a young girl. He does not eat the five grains but breathes the wind and drinks the dew. He rides the clouds, drives flying dragons, and wanders beyond the four seas. His spirit is concentrated, so that things are kept from sickness and the harvest ripens." I thought this was mad and did not believe it.' Lian Shu said: 'Of course. The blind have no share in the sight of patterns and colours; the deaf have no share in the sound of bells and drums. Is it only the body that can be blind and deaf? Knowing can be too. These words fit you like a girl in her season. This person, with this , would embrace the ten thousand things and make them one; the age may cry out for order, but why would he wear himself out making the empire his business? Nothing can hurt this person. A flood that reaches the sky would not drown him; a drought that melts metal and stone and scorches the earth and hills would not burn him. From his dust and chaff you could mould a Yao or a Shun. Why would he make things his business?' A man of Song took ceremonial caps to sell in Yue, but the people of Yue cut their hair short and tattoo their bodies; they had no use for them. Yao governed the people of the empire and brought order to all within the seas. He went to see the four masters on the far Gushe mountain, on the north bank of the Fen, and in a daze he forgot his empire.
Note //
The spirit person does nothing, yet things are kept well around him; this is the book's picture of non-action (wu wei). Yao 'loses' his empire not by giving it up but by seeing past it.
惠子謂莊子曰:「魏王貽我大瓠之種,我樹之成,而實五石。以盛水漿,其堅不能自舉也。剖之以爲瓢,則瓠落无所容。非不呺然大也,吾爲其无用而掊之。」莊子曰:「夫子固拙於用大矣。宋人有善爲不龜手之藥者,世世以洴澼絖爲事。客聞之,請買其方百金。聚族而謀曰:『我世世爲洴澼絖,不過數金。今一朝而鬻技百金,請與之。』客得之,以說吳王。越有難,吳王使之將。冬,與越人水戰,大敗越人,裂地而封之。能不龜手,一也;或以封,或不免於洴澼絖,則所用之異也。今子有五石之瓠,何不慮以爲大樽,而浮乎江湖?而憂其瓠落无所容,則夫子猶有蓬之心也夫!」
huì zi wèi zhuāng zi yuē: “wèi wáng yí wǒ dà hù zhī zhǒng, wǒ shù zhī chéng, ér shí wǔ shí. yǐ shèng shuǐ jiāng, qí jiān bù néng zì jǔ yě. pōu zhī yǐ wéi piáo, zé hù luò wú suǒ róng. fēi bù xiāo rán dà yě, wú wéi qí wú yòng ér póu zhī.” zhuāng zi yuē: “fū zǐ gù zhuō yú yòng dà yǐ. sòng rén yǒu shàn wéi bù guī shǒu zhī yào zhě, shì shì yǐ píng pì kuàng wéi shì. kè wén zhī, qǐng mǎi qí fāng bǎi jīn. jù zú ér móu yuē: ‘wǒ shì shì wéi píng pì kuàng, bù guò shù jīn. jīn yī zhāo ér yù jì bǎi jīn, qǐng yǔ zhī.’ kè dé zhī, yǐ shuì wú wáng. yuè yǒu nán, wú wáng shǐ zhī jiāng. dōng, yǔ yuè rén shuǐ zhàn, dà bài yuè rén, liè dì ér fēng zhī. néng bù guī shǒu, yī yě; huò yǐ fēng, huò bù miǎn yú píng pì kuàng, zé suǒ yòng zhī yì yě. jīn zi yǒu wǔ shí zhī hù, hé bù lǜ yǐ wéi dà zūn, ér fú hū jiāng hú? ér yōu qí hù luò wú suǒ róng, zé fū zǐ yóu yǒu péng zhī xīn yě fú!”
Huizi said to Zhuangzi: 'The king of Wei gave me the seeds of a big gourd. I planted them and they grew a gourd that held five bushels. I filled it with water, but it was too heavy to lift. I cut it in half to make ladles, but they were too wide and shallow to hold anything. It was big, no doubt, but I smashed it because it was useless.' Zhuangzi said: 'You really are clumsy at using big things, sir. There was a man of Song who had a fine salve for keeping hands from chapping, and for generations his family made their living bleaching silk in water. A traveller heard of it and offered a hundred pieces of gold for the recipe. The family met and said: "For generations we have bleached silk and never made more than a few pieces of gold. Now in one morning we can sell the skill for a hundred. Let's give it to him." The traveller took it and used it to win over the king of Wu. When Yue made trouble, the king of Wu made him a general. In winter he fought a battle on the water with Yue and beat them badly, and he was given land and a fief. The power to keep hands from chapping was the same; one man got a fief with it, the other never got beyond bleaching silk, because of how it was used. 'Now you had a gourd that held five bushels. Why didn't you think of making it into a great float and drifting on the rivers and lakes, instead of worrying that it was too wide to hold anything? You still have a tangled mind, sir.'
Note //
Huizi, the logician and Zhuangzi's friend and sparring partner, judges by ordinary use. 'A tangled mind' (蓬之心): literally a mind full of weeds, unable to see a use beyond the expected one.
惠子謂莊子曰:「吾有大樹,人謂之樗,其大本擁腫而不中繩墨,其小枝卷曲而不中規矩,立之塗,匠者不顧。今子之言,大而无用,衆所同去也。」莊子曰:「子獨不見狸狌乎?卑身而伏,以候敖者,東西跳梁,不避高下,中於機辟,死於罔罟。今夫犛牛,其大若垂天之雲,此能爲大矣,而不能執鼠。今子有大樹,患其无用,何不樹之於无何有之鄉,廣莫之野,彷徨乎无爲其側,逍遙乎寢臥其下?不夭斤斧,物无害者,无所可用,安所困苦哉?」
huì zi wèi zhuāng zi yuē: “wú yǒu dà shù, rén wèi zhī chū, qí dà běn yōng zhǒng ér bù zhōng shéng mò, qí xiǎo zhī juǎn qū ér bù zhōng guī jǔ, lì zhī tú, jiàng zhě bù gù. jīn zi zhī yán, dà ér wú yòng, zhòng suǒ tóng qù yě.” zhuāng zi yuē: “zi dú bù jiàn lí shēng hū? bēi shēn ér fú, yǐ hòu áo zhě, dōng xī tiào liáng, bù bì gāo xià, zhōng yú jī pì, sǐ yú wǎng gǔ. jīn fú máo niú, qí dà ruò chuí tiān zhī yún, cǐ néng wéi dà yǐ, ér bù néng zhí shǔ. jīn zi yǒu dà shù, huàn qí wú yòng, hé bù shù zhī yú wú hé yǒu zhī xiāng, guǎng mò zhī yě, páng huáng hū wú wéi qí cè, xiāo yáo hū qǐn wò qí xià? bù yāo jīn fǔ, wù wú hài zhě, wú suǒ kě yòng, ān suǒ kùn kǔ zāi?”
Huizi said to Zhuangzi: 'I have a big tree that people call the stink-tree. Its trunk is so gnarled and knotted that no chalk line can be laid on it; its branches are so twisted that no square or compass can be used on them. It stands by the road and no carpenter looks at it twice. Your words are like that: big and useless, and everyone turns away from them.' Zhuangzi said: 'Haven't you seen the wildcat or the weasel? It crouches low and waits for something to come by; it leaps east and west, high and low, until it lands in a trap and dies in a net. Then there is the yak, big as a cloud hanging from the sky. It can certainly be big, but it cannot catch a mouse. Now you have a big tree and worry that it is useless. Why not plant it in the village of Nothing-at-All, in the wide and empty wilds, and wander idly beside it doing nothing, and lie down to sleep beneath it, free and easy? No axe will cut it short, nothing will harm it. Where there is no use, how can there be trouble?'
Note //
The 'usefulness of the useless' returns in chapter 4. 'The village of Nothing-at-All' (無何有之鄉) is a place that is no particular place: wandering there is the free and easy wandering of the chapter's title.
Touch an underlined word to see the Chinese behind it. The lighter lines are how the tradition read the verse; the rest is the verse.
The renderings on this page are shared under CC BY-NC 4.0, in the words of Pranav Ashar.