notdual.

The West's long argument with the One

From a riverbank in Ephesus to a cabin by Walden Pond, Western philosophers kept returning to one question: are the many things many in fact, or one?

Stand by a river and watch it. The water you see now is already gone, yet you call it the same river. That small puzzle started an argument in Greece that has never stopped.

The Greeks. Heraclitus said everything flows, yet one Word (Logos) runs through it all. Parmenides said the opposite: only what is, is, and change is how it looks to the senses. Plotinus, in Rome in the third century, spoke of the One beyond all things, from which everything flows like light from the sun, and to which the soul can return.

The moderns. Spinoza, in seventeenth-century Holland, proved in the manner of geometry that there is one substance, God or Nature, and that every thing is a way it shows itself. Schopenhauer, a century and a half later, read the Upanishads in a Latin translation and called them the consolation of his life; he saw one blind will behind the world of appearances.

The Americans. Emerson and Thoreau, in Concord, Massachusetts, read the Bhagavad Gita and translations from the Upanishads. Emerson wrote of the Over-Soul, “the eternal ONE”; Thoreau took the Gita into his cabin at Walden. William James, the psychologist, whose family knew Emerson, later studied the varieties of mystical experience; he appears on The Science of Being page.

These thinkers argue, prove and doubt. Most were not trying to be mystics, and we read them first as philosophers, each in their own terms. Where they reach the edge of “not two”, we say so, as our reading.

Take a wave. It cannot exist without the ocean, yet the ocean is not a heap of waves. Almost every thinker on this page has tried to say exactly what that relation is.

> “We live in succession, in division, in parts, in particles. Meantime within man is the soul of the whole” > (Emerson, “The Over-Soul”, 1841)

The argument is old. The river is still flowing.

The West's long argument with the One

Heraclitus

The river

Everything flows, yet one Word runs through it.

Parmenides

What is, is

Only being is; change is how it looks to the senses.

Plotinus

The overflowing One

All things flow from the One and long to return.

Spinoza

Substance

One substance, and every thing a way it is expressed.

The site's reading: the argument keeps returning to one reality; the site reads the knower of the argument as that reality.

Next on your path

Sources

  • Emerson, “The Over-Soul”, in Essays: First Series (Boston, 1841). Public domain.
  • Schopenhauer on the Upanishads as “the consolation of my life”: Parerga and Paralipomena (1851), vol. 2, §185; paraphrased here.
  • Details and sources are on each thinker page.