notdual.

Our time

In the twentieth century three teachers in India spoke of who we are with almost no scripture, no ritual and no system. Each in his own way handed the question straight back to the listener.

A boy in Madurai lies on the floor and asks what dies. A shopkeeper in Bombay sits with the plain sense “I am”. A young man raised to be a world teacher dissolves his own organisation in front of three thousand followers. Our time's voices began like this.

Ramana Maharshi (1879 to 1950) taught from one question: who am I? Ask whose thought this is, he said, and trace the “I” back to its source. He taught mostly in silence, from the hill of Arunachala.

Nisargadatta Maharaj (1897 to 1981) taught from a small loft in Mumbai. Stay with “I am”, he said, and add nothing; it will show you what is before it.

J. Krishnamurti (1895 to 1986) refused to be anyone's teacher. He asked people to look at their own minds without the observer, the part of thought that sets itself up as judge.

What they share is a refusal to let the answer stay in a book. None asks for belief; each asks you to look, now. Ramana and Nisargadatta use Advaita's terms. Krishnamurti does not, and would reject the label; the Meetings show where his words and Advaita's meet and where they part.

Think of three people pointing at the moon from three windows. Their fingers point in different directions, but they are all pointing at the moon from where they stand.

> “Thou couldst not see the (true) seer of sight … This is thy Self, who is within all.” > (Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.4.2, tr. Max Müller, 1884)

The old question, asked with nothing in the way.

Our time

Ramana Maharshi

Who am I?

Trace the I back to its source; it falls, and what remains is the Self.

Nisargadatta Maharaj

I am

Stay with the bare sense of being until it shows what is before it.

J. Krishnamurti

The observer is the observed

See without the watcher that thought sets up.

The site's reading: three teachers hand the question back; each points to what is present before any answer.

Next on your path

Sources

  • Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.4.2, in The Upanishads, Part II, tr. F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East vol. 15 (Oxford, 1884). Public domain.
  • The 1929 dissolution of the Order of the Star took place at Ommen, Netherlands, on 3 August 1929; the audience is usually reported as about three thousand.
  • Further sources on each thinker page.