notdual.

The China and Japan family

In China the question “who am I?” was asked less in arguments than in jokes and sudden questions. Taoism and Zen are its two great voices.

A cook carves an ox so smoothly that his knife never needs sharpening. A man wakes from dreaming he was a butterfly and cannot tell which is which. A monk asks what the Buddha is and gets a shout. This is how China and Japan teach. They rarely define the Self; they catch you in the act of being it.

Taoism. The Tao Te Ching, traditionally ascribed to Laozi, speaks of a Way that cannot be named, which gives rise to everything and claims nothing. Its sage acts without forcing (wu wei). Zhuangzi, a century or two later, turns this into stories and laughter, loosening every fixed line between me and the world, right and wrong, life and death.

Chan and Zen. Buddhism came to China from India and met Taoism. Out of that meeting came Chan, called Zen in Japan: a school that points directly to your own nature. Huineng, the sixth ancestor, said it is already pure and complete. Linji shouted and struck to wake his students to the “true person” here and now. In Japan, Dogen taught that just sitting is itself awakening, and that to study the self is to forget the self.

Both voices distrust words, and both use them brilliantly. Both bring the heart of the matter back to cooking, carving, walking and sitting.

Think of water. It has no shape of its own, takes the shape of every cup, and wears away stone. Laozi used it as his image of the Way.

> “Clay is fashioned into vessels; but it is on their empty hollowness, that their use depends.” > (Tao Te Ching, chapter 11, tr. James Legge, 1891)

Stop forcing, and see what was already moving.

The China and Japan family

Taoism (Laozi)

The uncarved block

Return to the simple, unshaped state before names.

Zhuangzi

Cook Ding's knife

Follow the grain of things and nothing wears out.

Chan and Zen (Huineng)

No mirror, no stand

Your own nature is complete; see it directly.

Dogen

Study the self

To study the way is to study the self, and to forget the self.

The site's reading: these voices catch you in the act of being what you are; the site reads that as not two.

Next on your path

Sources

  • The Tao Teh King, tr. James Legge, Sacred Books of the East vol. 39 (Oxford, 1891), chapter 11. Public domain. Water as the image of the Way: chapters 8 and 78.
  • The cook and the butterfly: Zhuangzi chapters 3 and 2, tr. Herbert Giles (1889).
  • Dates and attributions: see each thinker page.