Diamond Sutra

In the words of Pranav Ashar
How we renderThe heart of the Diamond Sutra
In brief
The Diamond Sutra (Vajracchedika, 'the diamond-cutter') is a Perfection of Wisdom sutra of Mahayana Buddhism, from the first centuries CE. After the alms round one ordinary day, the elder Subhuti asks the Buddha how one who has vowed to free all beings should hold the mind. The answer: free all beings, and see that no being is freed; give without resting on anything; do not take the Buddha to be his marks. Again and again a thing is named, denied as a fixed thing, and named again. Rendered from the Sanskrit, in its own sense first.
वज्रच्छेदिका नाम त्रिशतिका प्रज्ञापारमिता। ॥नमो भगवत्या आर्यप्रज्ञापारमितायै॥
vajracchedikā nāma triśatikā prajñāpāramitā| |namo bhagavatyā āryaprajñāpāramitāyai||
The Diamond-Cutter, the Perfection of Wisdom in Three Hundred Lines. Homage to the noble Perfection of Wisdom.
Note //
The title compares this wisdom to a diamond (vajra) that cuts through every fixed view. 'Three hundred' is the traditional length in slokas.
The setting
एवं मया श्रुतम्। एकस्मिन् समये भगवान् श्रावस्त्यां विहरति स्म जेतवनेऽनाथपिण्डदस्यारामे महता भिक्षुसंघेन सार्थं त्रयोदशभिर्भिक्षुशतैः संबहुलैश्च बोधिसत्त्वैर्महासत्त्वैः। अथ खलु भगवान् पूर्वाह्णकालसमये निवास्य पात्रचीवरमादाय श्रावस्तीं महानगरीं पिण्डाय प्राविक्षत्। अथ खलु भगवान् श्रावस्तीं महानगरीं पिण्डाय चरित्वा कृतभक्तकृत्यः पश्चाद्भक्तपिण्डपातप्रतिक्रान्तः पात्रचीवरं प्रतिशाम्य पादौ प्रक्षाल्य न्यषीदत्प्रज्ञप्त एवासने पर्यङ्कमाभुज्य ऋजुं कायं प्रणिधाय प्रतिमुखीं स्मृतिमुपस्थाप्य। अथ खलु संबहुला भिक्षवो येन भगवांस्तेनोपसंक्रामन्। उपसंक्रम्य भगवतः पादौ शिरोभिरभिवन्द्य भगवन्तं त्रिष्प्रदक्षिणीकृत्य एकान्ते न्यषीदन्
evaṃ mayā śrutam| ekasmin samaye bhagavān śrāvastyāṃ viharati sma jetavane'nāthapiṇḍadasyārāme mahatā bhikṣusaṃghena sārthaṃ trayodaśabhirbhikṣuśataiḥ saṃbahulaiśca bodhisattvairmahāsattvaiḥ| atha khalu bhagavān pūrvāhṇakālasamaye nivāsya pātracīvaramādāya śrāvastīṃ mahānagarīṃ piṇḍāya prāvikṣat| atha khalu bhagavān śrāvastīṃ mahānagarīṃ piṇḍāya caritvā kṛtabhaktakṛtyaḥ paścādbhaktapiṇḍapātapratikrāntaḥ pātracīvaraṃ pratiśāmya pādau prakṣālya nyaṣīdatprajñapta evāsane paryaṅkamābhujya ṛjuṃ kāyaṃ praṇidhāya pratimukhīṃ smṛtimupasthāpya| atha khalu saṃbahulā bhikṣavo yena bhagavāṃstenopasaṃkrāman| upasaṃkramya bhagavataḥ pādau śirobhirabhivandya bhagavantaṃ triṣpradakṣiṇīkṛtya ekānte nyaṣīdan
Thus have I heard. At one time the Buddha was staying at Shravasti, in the Jeta Grove, in the park of Anathapindada, with a large community of monks, thirteen hundred of them, and many bodhisattvas, great beings. In the early morning the Buddha dressed, took his bowl and robe, and went into the great city of Shravasti for alms. When he had gone for alms and eaten, and come back from his round after the meal, he put away his bowl and robe, washed his feet, and sat down on the seat set out for him. He crossed his legs, held his body straight, and set his attention before him. Then many monks came to where the Buddha was. They bowed their heads at his feet, walked round him three times keeping him on their right, and sat down to one side.
Note //
The sutra opens in the most ordinary way: begging, eating, washing the feet, sitting down. Everything that follows is said from inside this plain day. The Sanskrit printed here says thirteen hundred; Muller's 1250 reads it as 'half-thirteen hundred', as most versions do.
Subhuti's question
तेन खलु पुनः समयेनायुष्मान् सुभूतिस्तस्यामेव पर्षदि संनिपतितोऽभूत्संनिषण्णः। अथ खल्वायुष्मान् सुभूतिरुत्थायासनादेकांसमुत्तरासङ्गं कृत्वा दक्षिणं जानुमण्डलं पृथिव्यां प्रतिष्ठाप्य येन भगवांस्तेनाञ्जलिं प्रणम्य भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्- आश्चर्यं भगवन्, परमाश्चर्यं सुगत, यावदेव तथागतेनार्हता सम्यक्संबुद्धेन बोधिसत्त्वा महासत्त्वा अनुपरिगृहीताः परमेणानुग्रहेण। आश्चर्यं भगवन् यावदेव तथागतेनार्हता सम्यक्संबुद्धेन बोधिसत्त्वा महासत्त्वाः परीन्दिताः परमया परीन्दनया। तत्कथं भगवन् बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन कुलपुत्रेण वा कुलदुहित्रा वा स्थातव्यं कथं प्रतिपत्तव्यं कथं चित्तं प्रग्रहीतव्यम् ? एवमुक्ते भगवानायुष्मन्तं सुभूतिमेतदवोचत्- साधु साधु सुभूते, एवमेतत्सुभूते, एवमेतद्यथा वदसि। अनुपरिगृहीतास्तथागतेन बोधिसत्त्वा महासत्त्वाः परमेणानुग्रहेण। परीन्दितास्तथागतेन बोधिसत्त्वा महासत्त्वाः परमया परीन्दनया। तेन हि सुभूते शृणु, साधु च सुष्ठु च मनसि कुरु, भाषिष्येऽहं ते-यथा बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन स्थातव्यं यथा प्रतिपत्तव्यं यथा चित्तं प्रग्रहीतव्यम्। एवं भगवन् इत्यायुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवतः प्रत्यश्रौषीत्
tena khalu punaḥ samayenāyuṣmān subhūtistasyāmeva parṣadi saṃnipatito'bhūtsaṃniṣaṇṇaḥ| atha khalvāyuṣmān subhūtirutthāyāsanādekāṃsamuttarāsaṅgaṃ kṛtvā dakṣiṇaṃ jānumaṇḍalaṃ pṛthivyāṃ pratiṣṭhāpya yena bhagavāṃstenāñjaliṃ praṇamya bhagavantametadavocat- āścaryaṃ bhagavan, paramāścaryaṃ sugata, yāvadeva tathāgatenārhatā samyaksaṃbuddhena bodhisattvā mahāsattvā anuparigṛhītāḥ parameṇānugraheṇa| āścaryaṃ bhagavan yāvadeva tathāgatenārhatā samyaksaṃbuddhena bodhisattvā mahāsattvāḥ parīnditāḥ paramayā parīndanayā| tatkathaṃ bhagavan bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitena kulaputreṇa vā kuladuhitrā vā sthātavyaṃ kathaṃ pratipattavyaṃ kathaṃ cittaṃ pragrahītavyam ? evamukte bhagavānāyuṣmantaṃ subhūtimetadavocat- sādhu sādhu subhūte, evametatsubhūte, evametadyathā vadasi| anuparigṛhītāstathāgatena bodhisattvā mahāsattvāḥ parameṇānugraheṇa| parīnditāstathāgatena bodhisattvā mahāsattvāḥ paramayā parīndanayā| tena hi subhūte śṛṇu, sādhu ca suṣṭhu ca manasi kuru, bhāṣiṣye'haṃ te-yathā bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitena sthātavyaṃ yathā pratipattavyaṃ yathā cittaṃ pragrahītavyam| evaṃ bhagavan ityāyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavataḥ pratyaśrauṣīt
At that time Subhuti was sitting in that assembly. He rose from his seat, put his upper robe over one shoulder, set his right knee on the ground, joined his palms toward the Buddha, and said: 'It is wonderful, Teacher, most wonderful, Well-Gone One, how much the bodhisattvas, the great beings, have been helped by the Tathagata, the worthy one, the fully awakened one, with the highest help; how much they have been entrusted by him with the highest trust. How then, Teacher, should a son or daughter of good family who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas stand, how should they go on, how should they hold the mind?' The Buddha said to Subhuti: 'Good, good, Subhuti. It is as you say. The bodhisattvas have been helped by the Tathagata with the highest help, entrusted with the highest trust. So listen, Subhuti, and attend well and carefully. I will tell you how one who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas should stand, how they should go on, how they should hold the mind.' 'Yes, Teacher,' said Subhuti, and listened.
Note //
The three questions, how to stand, how to go on, how to hold the mind, are the questions of anyone who has decided to live for the awakening of all. The whole sutra answers them, and the answers keep removing the ground the questions stand on.
Freeing all beings, and no being freed
भगवानस्यैतदवोचत्-इह सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेनैव चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्-यावन्तः सुभूते सत्त्वाः सत्त्वधातौ सत्त्वसंग्रहेण संगृहीता अण्डजा वा जरायुजा वा संस्वेदजा वा औपपादुका वा रूपिणो वा अरूपिणो वा संज्ञिनो वा असंज्ञिनो वा नैवसंज्ञिनो नासंज्ञिनो वा, यावान् कश्चित्सत्त्वधातुः प्रज्ञप्यमानः प्रज्ञप्यते, ते च मया सर्वेऽनुपधिशेषे निर्वाणधातौ परिनिर्वापयितव्याः। एवमपरिमाणानपि सत्त्वान् परिनिर्वाप्य न कश्चित्सत्त्वः परिनिर्वापितो भवति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सचेत्सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वस्य सत्त्वसंज्ञा प्रवर्तेत, न स बोधिसत्त्व इति वक्तव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न स सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वो वक्तव्यो यस्य सत्त्वसंज्ञा प्रवर्तेत, जीवसंज्ञा वा पुद्गलसंज्ञा वा प्रवर्तेत
bhagavānasyaitadavocat-iha subhūte bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitenaiva cittamutpādayitavyam-yāvantaḥ subhūte sattvāḥ sattvadhātau sattvasaṃgraheṇa saṃgṛhītā aṇḍajā vā jarāyujā vā saṃsvedajā vā aupapādukā vā rūpiṇo vā arūpiṇo vā saṃjñino vā asaṃjñino vā naivasaṃjñino nāsaṃjñino vā, yāvān kaścitsattvadhātuḥ prajñapyamānaḥ prajñapyate, te ca mayā sarve'nupadhiśeṣe nirvāṇadhātau parinirvāpayitavyāḥ| evamaparimāṇānapi sattvān parinirvāpya na kaścitsattvaḥ parinirvāpito bhavati| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sacetsubhūte bodhisattvasya sattvasaṃjñā pravarteta, na sa bodhisattva iti vaktavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na sa subhūte bodhisattvo vaktavyo yasya sattvasaṃjñā pravarteta, jīvasaṃjñā vā pudgalasaṃjñā vā pravarteta
The Buddha said: 'Here, Subhuti, one who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas should produce this thought: "However many beings there are in the realm of beings, gathered under the name 'beings', born from eggs, from a womb, from moisture, or spontaneously, with form or without form, with perception, without perception, or neither with nor without perception, however far the realm of beings is conceived, all of them I must lead to , in the realm of nirvana ." And yet, after leading countless beings to in this way, no being at all has been led to nirvana. 'Why is that? If arose in a bodhisattva, Subhuti, he should not be called a bodhisattva. Why? One in whom arises, or the of a , or the of a person, is not to be called a bodhisattva.'
Note //
The vow and its emptiness are given in one breath: free all beings, and know that there is no being to free. In the tradition's sense, 'no being' means no being with a fixed self of its own, not that beings do not appear. In the site's reading this matches the Advaita claim that the person is real as appearance and never on its own (position 4).
Giving without resting on anything
अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते न बोधिसत्त्वेन वस्तुप्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्, न क्वचित्प्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्। न रूपप्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्। न शब्दगन्धरसस्प्रष्टव्यधर्मेषु प्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्। एवं हि सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वेन महासत्त्वेन दानं दातव्यं यथा न निमित्तसंज्ञायामपि प्रतितिष्ठेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वोऽप्रतिष्ठितो दानं ददाति, तस्य सुभूते पुण्यस्कन्धस्य न सुकरं प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम्। तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते सुकरं पूर्वस्यां दिशि आकाशस्य प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम् ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। भगवानाह- एवं दक्षिणपश्चिमोत्तरासु अध ऊर्ध्वं दिग्विदिक्षु समन्ताद्दशसु दिक्षु सुकरमाकाशस्य प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम् ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। भगवानाह-एवमेव सुभूते यो बोधिसत्त्वोऽप्रतिष्ठितो दानं ददाति, तस्य सुभूते पुण्यस्कन्धस्य न सुकरं प्रमाणमुद्ग्रहीतुम्। एवं हि सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन दानं दातव्यं यथा न निमित्तसंज्ञायामपि प्रतितिष्ठेत्
api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte na bodhisattvena vastupratiṣṭhitena dānaṃ dātavyam, na kvacitpratiṣṭhitena dānaṃ dātavyam| na rūpapratiṣṭhitena dānaṃ dātavyam| na śabdagandharasaspraṣṭavyadharmeṣu pratiṣṭhitena dānaṃ dātavyam| evaṃ hi subhūte bodhisattvena mahāsattvena dānaṃ dātavyaṃ yathā na nimittasaṃjñāyāmapi pratitiṣṭhet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yaḥ subhūte bodhisattvo'pratiṣṭhito dānaṃ dadāti, tasya subhūte puṇyaskandhasya na sukaraṃ pramāṇamudgrahītum| tatkiṃ manyase subhūte sukaraṃ pūrvasyāṃ diśi ākāśasya pramāṇamudgrahītum ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| bhagavānāha- evaṃ dakṣiṇapaścimottarāsu adha ūrdhvaṃ digvidikṣu samantāddaśasu dikṣu sukaramākāśasya pramāṇamudgrahītum ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| bhagavānāha-evameva subhūte yo bodhisattvo'pratiṣṭhito dānaṃ dadāti, tasya subhūte puṇyaskandhasya na sukaraṃ pramāṇamudgrahītum| evaṃ hi subhūte bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitena dānaṃ dātavyaṃ yathā na nimittasaṃjñāyāmapi pratitiṣṭhet
'Moreover, Subhuti, a bodhisattva should not give a gift while a thing; he should not give a gift while anything at all. He should not give a gift form, nor sounds, smells, tastes, touches or mental objects. A bodhisattva, a great being, should give a gift in such a way that he does not rest even on the of a sign. Why? The heap of merit of a bodhisattva who gives a gift without anything is not easy to measure. 'What do you think, Subhuti, is it easy to measure the space to the east?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher.' The Buddha said: 'Is it easy to measure the space to the south, the west, the north, below and above, in the intermediate directions, in all ten directions?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher.' The Buddha said: 'Just so, Subhuti, the heap of merit of a bodhisattva who gives without anything is not easy to measure. That is how one who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas should give a gift, so that he does not rest even on the of a sign.'
Note //
'Resting on' (pratishthita) means taking a stand on something as fixed: the gift, the giver, the receiver. Giving that rests on nothing is boundless, like space. Muller renders the word 'believing in'.
The Tathagata is not seen by marks
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। न लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? या सा भगवन् लक्षणसंपत्तथागतेन भाषिता सैवालक्षणसंपत्। एवमुक्ते भगवानायुष्मन्तं सुभूतिमेतदवोचत् यावत्सुभूते लक्षणसंपत् तावन्मृषा, यावदलक्षणसंपत् तावन्न मृषेति हि लक्षणालक्षणतस्तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| na lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yā sā bhagavan lakṣaṇasaṃpattathāgatena bhāṣitā saivālakṣaṇasaṃpat| evamukte bhagavānāyuṣmantaṃ subhūtimetadavocat yāvatsubhūte lakṣaṇasaṃpat tāvanmṛṣā, yāvadalakṣaṇasaṃpat tāvanna mṛṣeti hi lakṣaṇālakṣaṇatastathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ
'What do you think, Subhuti, is the Tathagata to be seen by the possession of marks?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, the Tathagata is not to be seen by the possession of marks. Why? What the Tathagata has called the possession of marks is itself no possession of marks.' The Buddha said to Subhuti: 'Wherever there is possession of marks, Subhuti, there is falsehood; wherever there is no possession of marks, there is no falsehood. So the Tathagata is to be seen through marks as no marks.'
Note //
The 'marks' are the thirty-two bodily signs of a great person, but also any feature by which a thing is fixed and grasped. The last line does not throw the marks away: the Tathagata is seen in them when they are seen as not marks of a fixed thing.
The raft
एवमुक्ते आयुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्- अस्ति भगवन्। केचित्सत्त्वा भविष्यन्त्यनागतेऽध्वनि पश्चिमे काले पश्चिमे समये पश्चिमायां पञ्चशत्यां सद्धर्मविप्रलोपकाले वर्तमाने, ये इमेष्वेवंरूपेषु सूत्रान्तपदेषु भाष्यमाणेषु भूतसंज्ञामुत्पादयिष्यन्ति। अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते भविष्यन्त्यनागतेऽध्वनि बोधिसत्त्वा महासत्त्वाः पश्चिमे काले पश्चिमे समये पश्चिमायां पञ्चशत्यां सद्धर्मविप्रलोपे वर्तमाने गुणवन्तः शीलवन्तः प्रज्ञावन्तश्च भविष्यन्ति, ये इमेष्वेवंरूपेषु सूत्रान्तपदेषु भाष्यमाणेषु भूतसंज्ञामुत्पादयिष्यन्ति। न खलु पुनस्ते सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वा महासत्त्वा एकबुद्धपर्युपासिता भविष्यन्ति, नैकबुद्धावरोपितकुशलमूला भविष्यन्ति। अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते अनेकबुद्धशतसहस्रपर्युपासिता अनेकबुद्धशतसहस्रावरोपितकुशलमूलास्ते बोधिसत्त्वा महासत्त्वा भविष्यन्ति, ये इमेष्वेवंरूपेषु सूत्रान्तपदेषु भाष्यमाणेषु एकचित्तप्रसादमपि प्रतिलप्स्यन्ते। ज्ञातास्ते सुभूते तथागतेन बुद्धज्ञानेन, दृष्टास्ते सुभूते तथागतेन बुद्धचक्षुषा, बुद्धास्ते सुभूते तथागतेन। सर्वे ते सुभूते अप्रमेयमसंख्येयं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसविष्यन्ति प्रतिग्रहीष्यन्ति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न हि सुभूते तेषां बोधिसत्त्वानां महासत्त्वानामात्मसंज्ञा प्रवर्तते, न सत्त्वसंज्ञा, न जीवसंज्ञा, न पुद्गलसंज्ञा प्रवर्तते। नापि तेषां सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वानां महासत्त्वानां धर्मसंज्ञा प्रवर्तते। एवं नाधर्मसंज्ञा। नापि तेषां सुभूते संज्ञा नासंज्ञा प्रवर्तते। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सचेत्सुभूते तेषां बोधिसत्त्वानां महासत्त्वानां धर्मसंज्ञा प्रवर्तेत, स एव तेषामात्मग्राहो भवेत्, सत्त्वग्राहो जीवग्राहः पुद्गलग्राहो भवेत्। सचेदधर्मसंज्ञा प्रवर्तेत, स एव तेषामात्मग्राहो भवेत्, सत्त्वग्राहो जीवग्राहः पुद्गलग्राह इति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न खलु पुनः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वेन महासत्त्वेन धर्म उद्ग्रहीतव्यो नाधर्मः। तस्मादियं तथागतेन संधाय वाग्भाषिता-कोलोपमं धर्मपर्यायमाजानद्भिधर्मा एव प्रहातव्याः प्रागेवाधर्मा इति
evamukte āyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavantametadavocat- asti bhagavan| kecitsattvā bhaviṣyantyanāgate'dhvani paścime kāle paścime samaye paścimāyāṃ pañcaśatyāṃ saddharmavipralopakāle vartamāne, ye imeṣvevaṃrūpeṣu sūtrāntapadeṣu bhāṣyamāṇeṣu bhūtasaṃjñāmutpādayiṣyanti| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte bhaviṣyantyanāgate'dhvani bodhisattvā mahāsattvāḥ paścime kāle paścime samaye paścimāyāṃ pañcaśatyāṃ saddharmavipralope vartamāne guṇavantaḥ śīlavantaḥ prajñāvantaśca bhaviṣyanti, ye imeṣvevaṃrūpeṣu sūtrāntapadeṣu bhāṣyamāṇeṣu bhūtasaṃjñāmutpādayiṣyanti| na khalu punaste subhūte bodhisattvā mahāsattvā ekabuddhaparyupāsitā bhaviṣyanti, naikabuddhāvaropitakuśalamūlā bhaviṣyanti| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte anekabuddhaśatasahasraparyupāsitā anekabuddhaśatasahasrāvaropitakuśalamūlāste bodhisattvā mahāsattvā bhaviṣyanti, ye imeṣvevaṃrūpeṣu sūtrāntapadeṣu bhāṣyamāṇeṣu ekacittaprasādamapi pratilapsyante| jñātāste subhūte tathāgatena buddhajñānena, dṛṣṭāste subhūte tathāgatena buddhacakṣuṣā, buddhāste subhūte tathāgatena| sarve te subhūte aprameyamasaṃkhyeyaṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasaviṣyanti pratigrahīṣyanti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na hi subhūte teṣāṃ bodhisattvānāṃ mahāsattvānāmātmasaṃjñā pravartate, na sattvasaṃjñā, na jīvasaṃjñā, na pudgalasaṃjñā pravartate| nāpi teṣāṃ subhūte bodhisattvānāṃ mahāsattvānāṃ dharmasaṃjñā pravartate| evaṃ nādharmasaṃjñā| nāpi teṣāṃ subhūte saṃjñā nāsaṃjñā pravartate| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sacetsubhūte teṣāṃ bodhisattvānāṃ mahāsattvānāṃ dharmasaṃjñā pravarteta, sa eva teṣāmātmagrāho bhavet, sattvagrāho jīvagrāhaḥ pudgalagrāho bhavet| sacedadharmasaṃjñā pravarteta, sa eva teṣāmātmagrāho bhavet, sattvagrāho jīvagrāhaḥ pudgalagrāha iti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na khalu punaḥ subhūte bodhisattvena mahāsattvena dharma udgrahītavyo nādharmaḥ| tasmādiyaṃ tathāgatena saṃdhāya vāgbhāṣitā-kolopamaṃ dharmaparyāyamājānadbhidharmā eva prahātavyāḥ prāgevādharmā iti
Then Subhuti said to the Buddha: 'Teacher, will there be any beings in the future, in the last time, the last age, the last five hundred years, when the true teaching is in decline, who will produce a true when words of a sutra like these are taught?' The Buddha said: 'Do not speak like that, Subhuti. There will be bodhisattvas, great beings, in the future, in the last time, the last age, the last five hundred years, when the true teaching is in decline, who have virtue, good conduct and wisdom, and who will produce a true when words of a sutra like these are taught. And these bodhisattvas will not have honoured only one buddha, nor planted roots of good under only one buddha; they will have honoured many hundreds of thousands of buddhas and planted roots of good under many hundreds of thousands of buddhas, and when words like these are taught they will find even a single moment of clear trust. They are known to the Tathagata, Subhuti, with his buddha-knowledge; they are seen by the Tathagata with his buddha-eye; they are fully known by the Tathagata. All of them will bring forth and take up a heap of merit beyond measure and beyond count. 'Why is that? Because in these bodhisattvas the of a self does not arise, nor the of a being, of a , or of a person. Nor does the of a dharma arise in them, Subhuti, nor the of no dharma. Neither nor no arises in them. Why? If the of a dharma arose in them, that would be grasping at a self, a being, a , a person; and if the of no dharma arose, that too would be grasping at a self, a being, a , a person. Why? A bodhisattva, a great being, should not grasp a dharma, nor what is not a dharma. That is why the Tathagata spoke with this hidden meaning: "Those who know the teaching of the dharma as like a raft should let go even of dharmas, how much more of what is not dharma."'
Nothing attained, nothing taught
पुनरपरं भगवानायुष्मन्तं सुभूतिमेतदवोचत्- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते, अस्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेनानुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिरित्यभिसंबुद्धः, कश्चिद्वा धर्मस्तथागतेन देशितः ? एवमुक्ते आयुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्-यथाहं भगवन् भगवतो भाषितस्यार्थमाजानामि, नास्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन अनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिरित्यभिसंबुद्धः, नास्ति धर्मो यस्तथागतेन देशितः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? योऽसौ तथागतेन धर्मोऽभिसंबुद्धो देशितो वा, अग्राह्यः सोऽनभिलप्यः। न स धर्मो नाधर्मः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? असंस्कृतप्रभाविता ह्यार्यपुद्गलाः
punaraparaṃ bhagavānāyuṣmantaṃ subhūtimetadavocat- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte, asti sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatenānuttarā samyaksaṃbodhirityabhisaṃbuddhaḥ, kaścidvā dharmastathāgatena deśitaḥ ? evamukte āyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavantametadavocat-yathāhaṃ bhagavan bhagavato bhāṣitasyārthamājānāmi, nāsti sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena anuttarā samyaksaṃbodhirityabhisaṃbuddhaḥ, nāsti dharmo yastathāgatena deśitaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yo'sau tathāgatena dharmo'bhisaṃbuddho deśito vā, agrāhyaḥ so'nabhilapyaḥ| na sa dharmo nādharmaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? asaṃskṛtaprabhāvitā hyāryapudgalāḥ
Again the Buddha said to Subhuti: 'What do you think, Subhuti, is there any dharma that the Tathagata fully awakened to as "unsurpassed full awakening", or any dharma that the Tathagata has taught?' Subhuti said: 'As I understand the meaning of what you have said, Teacher, there is no dharma that the Tathagata fully awakened to as unsurpassed full awakening, and no dharma that the Tathagata has taught. Why? The dharma that the Tathagata awakened to and taught cannot be grasped and cannot be spoken; it is neither a dharma nor no dharma. Why? Because the noble ones are marked by the unconditioned.'
Note //
Awakening is not the gaining of an object. The last line says the noble ones are distinguished by the unconditioned (asamskrita); Muller read it as 'of imperfect power', a sense most later readers do not follow.
The merit of one verse
भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते यः कश्चित्कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा इमं त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रं लोकधातुं सप्तरत्नपरिपूर्णं कृत्वा तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, अपि नु स कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा ततोनिदानं बहु पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयात्। सुभूतिराह-बहु भगवन्, बहु सुगत स कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा ततोनिदानं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयात्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? योऽसौ भगवन् पुण्यस्कन्धस्तथागतेन भाषितः, अस्कन्धः स तथागतेन भाषितः। तस्मात्तथागतो भाषते- पुण्यस्कन्धः पुण्यस्कन्ध इति। भगवानाह-यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता व इमं त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रं लोकधातुं सप्तरत्नपरिपूर्णं कृत्वा तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, यश्च इतो धर्मपर्यायादन्तशश्चतुष्पादिकामपि गाथामुद्गृह्य परेभ्यो विस्तरेण देशयेत् संप्रकाशयेत्, अयमेव ततोनिदानं बहुतरं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयादप्रमेयसंख्येयम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? अतोनिर्जाता हि सुभूते तथागतानामर्हतां सम्यक्संबुद्धानामनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिः, अतोनिर्जाताश्च बुद्धा भगवन्तः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? बुद्धधर्मा बुद्धधर्मा इति सुभूते अबुद्धधर्माश्चैव ते तथागतेन भाषिताः। तेनोच्यन्ते बुद्धधर्मा इति
bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte yaḥ kaścitkulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā imaṃ trisāhasramahāsāhasraṃ lokadhātuṃ saptaratnaparipūrṇaṃ kṛtvā tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, api nu sa kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā tatonidānaṃ bahu puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyāt| subhūtirāha-bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata sa kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā tatonidānaṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyāt| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yo'sau bhagavan puṇyaskandhastathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ, askandhaḥ sa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tasmāttathāgato bhāṣate- puṇyaskandhaḥ puṇyaskandha iti| bhagavānāha-yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte kulaputro vā kuladuhitā va imaṃ trisāhasramahāsāhasraṃ lokadhātuṃ saptaratnaparipūrṇaṃ kṛtvā tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, yaśca ito dharmaparyāyādantaśaścatuṣpādikāmapi gāthāmudgṛhya parebhyo vistareṇa deśayet saṃprakāśayet, ayameva tatonidānaṃ bahutaraṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyādaprameyasaṃkhyeyam| tatkasya hetoḥ ? atonirjātā hi subhūte tathāgatānāmarhatāṃ samyaksaṃbuddhānāmanuttarā samyaksaṃbodhiḥ, atonirjātāśca buddhā bhagavantaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? buddhadharmā buddhadharmā iti subhūte abuddhadharmāścaiva te tathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ| tenocyante buddhadharmā iti
The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, if a son or daughter of good family filled this world-system of a thousand million worlds with the seven treasures and gave it as a gift to the Tathagatas, the worthy ones, the fully awakened ones, would that son or daughter of good family bring forth a great heap of merit on that account?' Subhuti said: 'Great, Teacher, great, Well-Gone One, would be the heap of merit that son or daughter of good family would bring forth on that account. Why? What the Tathagata has called a heap of merit he has called no heap. That is why the Tathagata says "a heap of merit, a heap of merit".' The Buddha said: 'And if, Subhuti, a son or daughter of good family filled this world-system of a thousand million worlds with the seven treasures and gave it as a gift to the Tathagatas, and if someone else took from this teaching even one verse of four lines and taught it and explained it fully to others, the second would on that account bring forth a greater heap of merit, beyond measure and beyond count. Why? From this has come forth the unsurpassed full awakening of the Tathagatas, the worthy ones, the fully awakened ones; from this have come forth the buddhas. Why? "Dharmas of a buddha, dharmas of a buddha": these, Subhuti, the Tathagata has called no dharmas of a buddha. That is why they are called dharmas of a buddha.'
Note //
Here begins the sutra's typical pattern: 'X is called no-X; therefore it is called X.' Words are used fully, and at the same time their objects are not taken as things in themselves. In the site's reading this is how Advaita speaks of names and forms: used, never mistaken for something standing alone (position 2).
No one attains the fruits
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते अपि नु स्रोतआपन्नस्यैवं भवति-मया स्रोतआपत्तिफलं प्राप्तमिति? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। न स्रोतआपन्नस्यैवं भवति-मया स्रोतआपत्तिफलं प्राप्तमिति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न हि स भगवन् कंचिद्धर्ममापन्नः, तेनोच्यते स्रोतआपन्न इति। न रूपमापन्नो न शब्दान् न गन्धान् न रसान् न स्प्रष्टव्यान् धर्मानापन्नः। तेनोच्यते स्रोतआपन्न इति। सचेद्भगवन् स्रोतआपन्नस्यैवं भवेत्- मया स्रोतआपत्तिफलं प्राप्तमिति, स एव तस्यात्मग्राहो भवेत्, सत्त्वग्राहो जीवग्राहः पुद्गलग्राहो भवेदिति॥ भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते अपि नु सकृदागामिन एवं भवति-मया सकृदागामिफलं प्राप्तमिति ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। न सकृदागामिन एवं भवति-मया सकृदागामिफलं प्राप्तमिति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न हि स कश्चिद्धर्मो यः सकृदागामित्वमापन्नः। तेनोच्यते सकृदागामीति॥ भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते अपि नु अनागामिन एवं भवति-मयानागामिफलं प्राप्तमिति ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। न अनागामिन एवं भवति-मया अनागामिफलं प्राप्तमिति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न हि स भगवन् कश्चिद्धर्मो योऽनागामित्वमापन्नः। तेनोच्यते अनागामीति॥ भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते अपि नु अर्हत एवं भवति-मया अर्हत्त्वं प्राप्तमिति ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। नार्हत एवं भवति-मया अर्हत्त्वं प्राप्तमिति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न हि स भगवन् कश्चिद्धर्मो योऽर्हन्नाम। तेनोच्यते-अर्हन्निति। सचेद्भगवन् अर्हत एवं भवेत्-मया अर्हत्त्वं प्राप्तमिति, स एव तस्यात्मग्राहो भवेत्, सत्त्वग्राहो जीवग्राहः पुद्गलग्राहो भवेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? अहमस्मि भगवंस्तथागतेनार्हता सम्यक्संबुद्धेन अरणाविहारिणामग्र्यो निर्दिष्टः। अहमस्मि भगवन् अर्हन् वीतरागः। न च मे भगवन्नेवं भवति- अर्हन्नस्म्यहं वीतराग इति। सचेन्मम भगवन्नेवं भवेत्-मया अर्हत्त्वं प्राप्तमिति, न मां तथागतो व्याकरिष्यदरणाविहारिणामग्र्यः सुभूतिः कुलपुत्रो न क्वचिद्विहरति, तेनोच्यते अरणाविहारी अरणाविहारीति
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte api nu srotaāpannasyaivaṃ bhavati-mayā srotaāpattiphalaṃ prāptamiti? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| na srotaāpannasyaivaṃ bhavati-mayā srotaāpattiphalaṃ prāptamiti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na hi sa bhagavan kaṃciddharmamāpannaḥ, tenocyate srotaāpanna iti| na rūpamāpanno na śabdān na gandhān na rasān na spraṣṭavyān dharmānāpannaḥ| tenocyate srotaāpanna iti| sacedbhagavan srotaāpannasyaivaṃ bhavet- mayā srotaāpattiphalaṃ prāptamiti, sa eva tasyātmagrāho bhavet, sattvagrāho jīvagrāhaḥ pudgalagrāho bhavediti|| bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte api nu sakṛdāgāmina evaṃ bhavati-mayā sakṛdāgāmiphalaṃ prāptamiti ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| na sakṛdāgāmina evaṃ bhavati-mayā sakṛdāgāmiphalaṃ prāptamiti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na hi sa kaściddharmo yaḥ sakṛdāgāmitvamāpannaḥ| tenocyate sakṛdāgāmīti|| bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte api nu anāgāmina evaṃ bhavati-mayānāgāmiphalaṃ prāptamiti ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| na anāgāmina evaṃ bhavati-mayā anāgāmiphalaṃ prāptamiti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na hi sa bhagavan kaściddharmo yo'nāgāmitvamāpannaḥ| tenocyate anāgāmīti|| bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte api nu arhata evaṃ bhavati-mayā arhattvaṃ prāptamiti ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| nārhata evaṃ bhavati-mayā arhattvaṃ prāptamiti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na hi sa bhagavan kaściddharmo yo'rhannāma| tenocyate-arhanniti| sacedbhagavan arhata evaṃ bhavet-mayā arhattvaṃ prāptamiti, sa eva tasyātmagrāho bhavet, sattvagrāho jīvagrāhaḥ pudgalagrāho bhavet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? ahamasmi bhagavaṃstathāgatenārhatā samyaksaṃbuddhena araṇāvihāriṇāmagryo nirdiṣṭaḥ| ahamasmi bhagavan arhan vītarāgaḥ| na ca me bhagavannevaṃ bhavati- arhannasmyahaṃ vītarāga iti| sacenmama bhagavannevaṃ bhavet-mayā arhattvaṃ prāptamiti, na māṃ tathāgato vyākariṣyadaraṇāvihāriṇāmagryaḥ subhūtiḥ kulaputro na kvacidviharati, tenocyate araṇāvihārī araṇāvihārīti
'What do you think, Subhuti, does a stream-enterer think, "I have attained the fruit of stream-entry"?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, a stream-enterer does not think, "I have attained the fruit of stream-entry." Why? Because he has not entered any dharma at all; that is why he is called a stream-enterer. He has not entered form, nor sounds, smells, tastes, touches or mental objects; that is why he is called a stream-enterer. If a stream-enterer thought, "I have attained the fruit of stream-entry", that would be grasping at a self, a being, a , a person.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, does a once-returner think, "I have attained the fruit of once-returning"?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher. Why? There is no dharma that has entered once-returning; that is why he is called a once-returner.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, does a non-returner think, "I have attained the fruit of non-returning"?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher. Why? There is no dharma that has entered non-returning; that is why he is called a non-returner.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, does an arhat think, "I have attained arhatship"?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher. Why? There is no dharma called an arhat; that is why he is called an arhat. If an arhat thought, "I have attained arhatship", that would be grasping at a self, a being, a , a person. And why? I have been named by the Tathagata, the worthy one, the fully awakened one, as foremost of those who dwell in peace. I am an arhat, Teacher, free of passion. Yet I do not think, "I am an arhat, free of passion." If I thought, "I have attained arhatship", the Tathagata would not have declared of me: "Subhuti, son of good family, foremost of those who dwell in peace, dwells nowhere; that is why he is called one who dwells in peace, one who dwells in peace."'
Note //
The four fruits are the stages of the early path. Each is real as a name and as a change in a life, but there is no someone who owns it. 'Dwelling in peace' (arana) means without strife; Muller renders it 'dwelling in virtue'.
An unsupported mind
भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-अस्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन दीपंकरस्य तथागतस्यार्हत-सम्यक्संबुद्धस्यान्तिकादुद्गृहीतः? सुभूतिराह- नो हीदं भगवन्। नास्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन दीपंकरस्य तथागतस्यार्हतः सम्यक्संबुद्धस्यान्तिकादुद्गृहीतः॥ भगवानाह-यः कश्चित्सुभूते बोधिसत्त्व एवं वदेत्-अहं क्षेत्रव्यूहान् निष्पादयिष्यामीति, स वितथं वदेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? क्षेत्रव्यूहाः क्षेत्रव्यूहा इति सुभूते अव्यूहास्ते तथागतेन भाषिताः। तेनोच्यन्ते क्षेत्रव्यूहा इति। तस्मात्तर्हि सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वेन महासत्त्वेन एवमप्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यं यन्न क्वचित्प्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्। न रूपप्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यं न शब्दगन्धरसस्प्रष्टव्यधर्मप्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्। तद्यथापि नाम सुभूते पुरुषो भवेदुपेतकायो महाकायो यत्तस्यैवं रूप आत्मभावः स्यात् तद्यथापि नाम सुमेरुः पर्वतराजः। तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते अपि नु महान् स आत्मभावो भवेत् ? सुभूतिराह-महान् स भगवन्, महान् सुगत स आत्मभावो भवेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? आत्मभाव आत्मभाव इति भगवन् न भावः स तथागतेन भाषितः। तेनोच्यत आत्मभाव इति। न हि भगवन् स भावो नाभावः। तेनोच्यते आत्मभाव इति
bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-asti sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena dīpaṃkarasya tathāgatasyārhata-samyaksaṃbuddhasyāntikādudgṛhītaḥ ? subhūtirāha- no hīdaṃ bhagavan| nāsti sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena dīpaṃkarasya tathāgatasyārhataḥ samyaksaṃbuddhasyāntikādudgṛhītaḥ|| bhagavānāha-yaḥ kaścitsubhūte bodhisattva evaṃ vadet-ahaṃ kṣetravyūhān niṣpādayiṣyāmīti, sa vitathaṃ vadet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? kṣetravyūhāḥ kṣetravyūhā iti subhūte avyūhāste tathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ| tenocyante kṣetravyūhā iti| tasmāttarhi subhūte bodhisattvena mahāsattvena evamapratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyaṃ yanna kvacitpratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam| na rūpapratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyaṃ na śabdagandharasaspraṣṭavyadharmapratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam| tadyathāpi nāma subhūte puruṣo bhavedupetakāyo mahākāyo yattasyaivaṃ rūpa ātmabhāvaḥ syāt tadyathāpi nāma sumeruḥ parvatarājaḥ| tatkiṃ manyase subhūte api nu mahān sa ātmabhāvo bhavet ? subhūtirāha-mahān sa bhagavan, mahān sugata sa ātmabhāvo bhavet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? ātmabhāva ātmabhāva iti bhagavan na bhāvaḥ sa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tenocyata ātmabhāva iti| na hi bhagavan sa bhāvo nābhāvaḥ| tenocyate ātmabhāva iti
The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, is there any dharma that the Tathagata took up from the Tathagata Dipankara, the worthy one, the fully awakened one?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, there is no dharma that the Tathagata took up from the Tathagata Dipankara.' The Buddha said: 'If a bodhisattva said, "I will create harmonious buddha-fields", he would be speaking falsely. Why? "Harmonious fields, harmonious fields": these, Subhuti, the Tathagata has called not harmonious; that is why they are called harmonious fields. So, Subhuti, a bodhisattva, a great being, should produce , a mind not anything; he should produce a mind not form, not sounds, smells, tastes, touches or mental objects. 'Suppose, Subhuti, a man had a body so great that his frame was like Sumeru, king of mountains. What do you think, would that frame be great?' Subhuti said: 'Great, Teacher, great, Well-Gone One, would that frame be. Why? "A frame, a frame": the Tathagata has called it no frame; that is why it is called a frame. For it is neither a thing nor not a thing; that is why it is called a frame.'
Note //
'A mind that rests nowhere' is the line that, in the Chinese tradition, is said to have awakened Huineng. Dipankara is the buddha of long ago who foretold Shakyamuni's awakening (see section 17). In the site's reading, a mind that rests nowhere is close to Advaita's witness, which takes no object as its own (position 8), though the sutra posits no witness.
Sands of the Ganges
भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-यावत्यो गङ्गायां महानद्यां वालुकास्तावत्य एव गङ्गानद्यो भवेयुः ? तासु या वालुकाः, अपि नु ता बह्व्यो भवेयुः ? सुभूतिराह-ता एव तावद्भगवन् बह्व्यो गङ्गानद्यो भवेयुः, प्रागेव यास्तासु गङ्गानदीषु वालुकाः। भगवानाह- आरोचयामि ते सुभूते, प्रतिवेदयामि ते। यावत्यस्तासु गङ्गानदीषु वालुका भवेयुस्तावतो लोकधातून् कश्चिदेव स्त्री वा पुरुषो वा सप्तरत्नपरिपूर्णं कृत्वा तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, तत् किं मन्यसे सुभूते-अपि नु सा स्त्री वा पुरुषो वा ततोनिदानं बहु पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयात् ? सुभूतिराह-बहु भगवन्, बहु सुगत स्त्री वा पुरुषो वा ततोनिदानं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयादप्रमेयमसंख्येयम्। भगवानाह- यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते स्त्री वा पुरुषो वा तावतो लोकधातून् सप्तरत्नपरिपूर्णं कृत्वा तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, यश्च कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा इतो धर्मपर्यायादन्तशश्चतुष्पादिकामपि गाथामुद्गृह्य परेभ्यो देशयेत् संप्रकाशयेत्, अयमेव ततोनिदानं बहुतरं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयादप्रमेयमसंख्येयम्
bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-yāvatyo gaṅgāyāṃ mahānadyāṃ vālukāstāvatya eva gaṅgānadyo bhaveyuḥ ? tāsu yā vālukāḥ, api nu tā bahvyo bhaveyuḥ ? subhūtirāha-tā eva tāvadbhagavan bahvyo gaṅgānadyo bhaveyuḥ, prāgeva yāstāsu gaṅgānadīṣu vālukāḥ| bhagavānāha- ārocayāmi te subhūte, prativedayāmi te| yāvatyastāsu gaṅgānadīṣu vālukā bhaveyustāvato lokadhātūn kaścideva strī vā puruṣo vā saptaratnaparipūrṇaṃ kṛtvā tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, tat kiṃ manyase subhūte-api nu sā strī vā puruṣo vā tatonidānaṃ bahu puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyāt ? subhūtirāha-bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata strī vā puruṣo vā tatonidānaṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyādaprameyamasaṃkhyeyam| bhagavānāha- yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte strī vā puruṣo vā tāvato lokadhātūn saptaratnaparipūrṇaṃ kṛtvā tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, yaśca kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā ito dharmaparyāyādantaśaścatuṣpādikāmapi gāthāmudgṛhya parebhyo deśayet saṃprakāśayet, ayameva tatonidānaṃ bahutaraṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyādaprameyamasaṃkhyeyam
The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, if there were as many Ganges rivers as there are grains of sand in the great river Ganges, would the grains of sand in them be many?' Subhuti said: 'Those Ganges rivers alone would be many, Teacher, how much more the grains of sand in them.' The Buddha said: 'I tell you, Subhuti, I make it known to you: if a woman or man filled as many world-systems as there would be grains of sand in those Ganges rivers with the seven treasures and gave them as a gift to the Tathagatas, the worthy ones, the fully awakened ones, what do you think, would that woman or man bring forth a great heap of merit on that account?' Subhuti said: 'Great, Teacher, great, Well-Gone One, beyond measure and beyond count.' The Buddha said: 'And if a woman or man filled so many world-systems with the seven treasures and gave them as a gift, and if a son or daughter of good family took from this teaching even one verse of four lines and taught it and made it known to others, the second would on that account bring forth a greater heap of merit, beyond measure and beyond count.'
Where the teaching is
अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते यस्मिन् पृथिवीप्रदेशे इतो धर्मपर्यायादन्तशश्चतुष्पादिकामपि गाथामुद्गृह्य भाष्येत वा संप्रकाश्येत वा, स पृथिवीप्रदेशश्चैत्यभूतो भवेत् सदेवमानुषासुरस्य लोकस्य, कः पुनर्वादो ये इमं धर्मपर्यायं सकलसमाप्तं धारयिष्यन्ति वाचयिष्यन्ति पर्यवाप्स्यन्ति, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयिष्यन्ति। परमेण ते सुभूते आश्चर्येण समन्वागता भविष्यन्ति। तस्मिंश्च सुभूते पृथिवीप्रदेशे शास्ता विहरत्यन्यतरान्यतरो वा विज्ञगुरुस्थानीयः
api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte yasmin pṛthivīpradeśe ito dharmaparyāyādantaśaścatuṣpādikāmapi gāthāmudgṛhya bhāṣyeta vā saṃprakāśyeta vā, sa pṛthivīpradeśaścaityabhūto bhavet sadevamānuṣāsurasya lokasya, kaḥ punarvādo ye imaṃ dharmaparyāyaṃ sakalasamāptaṃ dhārayiṣyanti vācayiṣyanti paryavāpsyanti, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayiṣyanti| parameṇa te subhūte āścaryeṇa samanvāgatā bhaviṣyanti| tasmiṃśca subhūte pṛthivīpradeśe śāstā viharatyanyatarānyataro vā vijñagurusthānīyaḥ
'Moreover, Subhuti, any spot of earth where even one verse of four lines taken from this teaching is spoken or made known becomes a shrine for the world with its gods, humans and asuras. How much more those who will keep this whole teaching to the end, recite it, master it and make it known to others in full. They will be endowed with the highest wonder. And in that spot of earth, Subhuti, the Teacher dwells, or one of the wise who stand in the place of a teacher.'
The name of the teaching
एवमुक्ते आयुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्-को नाम अयं भगवन् धर्मपर्यायः, कथं चैनं धारयामि ? एवमुक्ते भगवानायुष्मन्तं सुभूतिमेतदवोचत्- प्रज्ञापारमिता नामायं सुभूते धर्मपर्यायः। एवं चैनं धारय। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यैव सुभूते प्रज्ञापारमिता तथागतेन भाषिता, सैव अपारमिता तथागतेन भाषिता। तेनोच्यते प्रज्ञापारमितेति॥ तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-अपि नु अस्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन भाषितः ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। नास्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन भाषितः॥ भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-यावत् त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रे लोकधातौ पृथिवीरजः कच्चित्, तद्बहु भवेत् ? सुभूतिराह-बहु भगवन्, बहु सुगत पृथिवीरजो भवेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यत्तद्भगवन् पृथिवीरजस्तथागतेन भाषितम्, अरजस्तद्भगवंस्तथागतेन भाषितम्। तेनोच्यते पृथिवीरज इति। योऽप्यसौ लोकधातुस्तथागतेन भाषितः, अधातुः स तथागतेन भाषितः। तेनोच्यते लोकधातुरिति॥ भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते द्वात्रिंशन्महापुरुषलक्षणैस्तथागतोऽर्हन् सम्यक्संबुद्धो द्रष्टव्यः ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। द्वात्रिंशन्महापुरुषलक्षणैस्तथागतोऽर्हन् सम्यक्संबुद्धो द्रष्टव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यानि हि तानि भगवन् द्वात्रिंशन्महापुरुषलक्षणानि तथागतेन भाषितानि, अलक्षणानि तानि भगवंस्तथागतेन भाषितानि। तेनोच्यन्ते द्वात्रिंशन्महापुरुषलक्षणानीति॥ भगवानाह-यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते स्त्री वा पुरुषो वा दिने दिने गङ्गानदीवालुकासमानात्मभावान् परित्यजेत्, एवं परित्यजन् गङ्गानदीवालुकासमान् कल्पांस्तानात्मभावान् परित्यजेत्, यश्च इतो धर्मपर्यायादन्तशश्चतुष्पादिकामपि गाथामुद्गृह्य परेभ्यो देशयेत् संप्रकाशयेत्, अयमेव ततोनिदानं बहुतरं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयादप्रमेयमसंख्येयम्
evamukte āyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavantametadavocat-ko nāma ayaṃ bhagavan dharmaparyāyaḥ, kathaṃ cainaṃ dhārayāmi ? evamukte bhagavānāyuṣmantaṃ subhūtimetadavocat- prajñāpāramitā nāmāyaṃ subhūte dharmaparyāyaḥ| evaṃ cainaṃ dhāraya| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yaiva subhūte prajñāpāramitā tathāgatena bhāṣitā, saiva apāramitā tathāgatena bhāṣitā| tenocyate prajñāpāramiteti|| tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-api nu asti sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| nāsti sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ|| bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-yāvat trisāhasramahāsāhasre lokadhātau pṛthivīrajaḥ kaccit, tadbahu bhavet ? subhūtirāha-bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata pṛthivīrajo bhavet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yattadbhagavan pṛthivīrajastathāgatena bhāṣitam, arajastadbhagavaṃstathāgatena bhāṣitam| tenocyate pṛthivīraja iti| yo'pyasau lokadhātustathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ, adhātuḥ sa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tenocyate lokadhāturiti|| bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte dvātriṃśanmahāpuruṣalakṣaṇaistathāgato'rhan samyaksaṃbuddho draṣṭavyaḥ ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| dvātriṃśanmahāpuruṣalakṣaṇaistathāgato'rhan samyaksaṃbuddho draṣṭavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yāni hi tāni bhagavan dvātriṃśanmahāpuruṣalakṣaṇāni tathāgatena bhāṣitāni, alakṣaṇāni tāni bhagavaṃstathāgatena bhāṣitāni| tenocyante dvātriṃśanmahāpuruṣalakṣaṇānīti|| bhagavānāha-yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte strī vā puruṣo vā dine dine gaṅgānadīvālukāsamānātmabhāvān parityajet, evaṃ parityajan gaṅgānadīvālukāsamān kalpāṃstānātmabhāvān parityajet, yaśca ito dharmaparyāyādantaśaścatuṣpādikāmapi gāthāmudgṛhya parebhyo deśayet saṃprakāśayet, ayameva tatonidānaṃ bahutaraṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyādaprameyamasaṃkhyeyam
Then Subhuti said to the Buddha: 'What is this teaching called, Teacher, and how should I keep it?' The Buddha said: 'This teaching, Subhuti, is called the Perfection of Wisdom, and so you should keep it. Why? What the Tathagata has called the perfection of wisdom he has called no perfection; that is why it is called the perfection of wisdom. 'What do you think, Subhuti, is there any dharma that the Tathagata has taught?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, there is no dharma that the Tathagata has taught.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, the dust of the earth in this world-system of a thousand million worlds, would that be much?' Subhuti said: 'Much, Teacher, much, Well-Gone One. Why? What the Tathagata has called dust of the earth he has called no dust; that is why it is called dust of the earth. And what the Tathagata has called a world-system he has called no system; that is why it is called a world-system.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, is the Tathagata to be seen by the thirty-two marks of a great person?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher. Why? The thirty-two marks of a great person that the Tathagata has spoken of he has called no marks; that is why they are called the thirty-two marks of a great person.' The Buddha said: 'And if a woman or man gave up bodies as many as the sands of the Ganges day after day, and went on giving up bodies in this way for as many ages as there are sands in the Ganges, and if someone else took from this teaching even one verse of four lines and taught it and made it known to others, the second would on that account bring forth a greater heap of merit, beyond measure and beyond count.'
Note //
Even the name of the teaching is used in the sutra's own way: called the perfection of wisdom because it is not a perfection one could hold.
Subhuti weeps; the patience of the sage
अथ खल्वायुष्मान् सुभूतिर्धर्मवेगेनाश्रूणि प्रामुञ्चत्। सोऽश्रूणि प्रमृज्य भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्-आश्चर्यं भगवन्, परमाश्चर्यं सुगत, यावदयं धर्मपर्यायस्तथागतेन भाषितोऽग्रयानसंप्रस्थितानां सत्त्वानामर्थाय, श्रेष्ठयानसंप्रस्थितानामर्थाय, यतो मे भगवन् ज्ञानमुत्पन्नम्। न मया भगवन् जात्वेवंरूपो धर्मपर्यायः श्रुतपूर्वः। परमेण ते भगवन् आश्चर्येण समन्वागता बोधिसत्त्वा भविष्यन्ति, ये इह सूत्रे भाष्यमाणे श्रुत्वा भूतसंज्ञामुत्पादयिष्यन्ति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? या चैषा भगवन् भूतसंज्ञा, सैव अभूतसंज्ञा। तस्मात्तथागतो भाषते भूतसंज्ञा भूतसंज्ञेति॥ न मम भगवन् आश्चर्यं यदहमिमं धर्मपर्यायं भाष्यमाणमवकल्पयामि अधिमुच्ये। येऽपि ते भगवन् सत्त्वा भविष्यन्त्यनागतेऽध्वनि पश्चिमे काले पश्चिमे समये पश्चिमायां पञ्चशत्यां सद्धर्मविप्रलोपे वर्तमाने, ये इमं भगवन् धर्मपर्यायमुद्ग्रहीष्यन्ति धारयिष्यन्ति वाचयिष्यन्ति पर्यवाप्स्यन्ति, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयिष्यन्ति, ते परमाश्चर्येण समन्वागता भविष्यन्ति। अपि तु खलु पुनर्भगवन् न तेषामात्मसंज्ञा प्रवर्तिष्यते, न सत्त्वसंज्ञा न जीवसंज्ञा न पुद्गलसंज्ञा प्रवर्तिष्यते, नापि तेषां काचित्संज्ञा नासंज्ञा प्रवर्तते। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? या सा भगवन् आत्मसंज्ञा, सैवासंज्ञा। या सत्त्वसंज्ञा जीवसंज्ञा पुद्गलसंज्ञा, सैवासंज्ञा। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सर्वसंज्ञापगता हि बुद्धा भगवन्तः॥ एवमुक्ते भगवानायुष्मन्तं सुभूतिमेतदवोचत्-एवमेतत् सुभूते, एवमेतत्। परमाश्चर्यसमन्वागतास्ते सत्त्वा भविष्यन्ति, ये इह सुभूते सूत्रे भाष्यमाणे नोत्रसिष्यन्ति न संत्रसिष्यन्ति न संत्रासमापत्स्यन्ते। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? परमपारमितेयं सुभूते तथागतेन भाषिता यदुतापारमिता। यां च सुभूते तथागतः परमपारमितां भाषते, तामपरिमाणा अपि बुद्धा भगवन्तो भाषन्ते। तेनोच्यन्ते परमपारमितेति॥ अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते या तथागतस्य क्षान्तिपारमिता, सैव अपारमिता। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यदा मे सुभूते कलिराजा अङ्गप्रत्यङ्गमांसान्यच्छैत्सीत्, नासीन्मे तस्मिन् समये आत्मसंज्ञा वा सत्त्वसंज्ञा वा जीवसंज्ञा वा पुद्गलसंज्ञा वा, नापि मे काचित्संज्ञा वा असंज्ञा वा बभूव। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सचेन्मे सुभूते तस्मिन् समये आत्मसंज्ञा अभविष्यत्, व्यापादसंज्ञापि मे तस्मिन् समयेऽभविष्यत्। सचेत्सत्त्वसंज्ञा जीवसंज्ञा पुद्गलसंज्ञाभविष्यत्, व्यापादसंज्ञापि मे तस्मिन् समयेऽभविष्यत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? अभिजानाम्यहं सुभूते अतीतेऽध्वनि पञ्च जातिशतानि यदहं क्षान्तिवादी ऋषिरभूवम्। तत्रापि मे नात्मसंज्ञा बभूव, न सत्त्वसंज्ञा, न जीवसंज्ञा, न पुद्गलसंज्ञा बभूव। तस्मात्तर्हि सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वेन महासत्त्वेन सर्वसंज्ञा विवर्जयित्वा अनुत्तरायां सम्यक्संबोधौ चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्। न रूपप्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्, न शब्दगन्धरसस्प्रष्टव्यधर्मप्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्, न धर्मप्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्, नाधर्मप्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्, न क्वचित्प्रतिष्ठितं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यत्प्रतिष्ठितं तदेवाप्रतिष्ठितम्। तस्मादेव तथागतो भाषते-अप्रतिष्ठितेन बोधिसत्त्वेन दानं दातव्यम्। न रूपशब्दगन्धरसस्पर्शधर्मप्रतिष्ठितेन दानं दातव्यम्॥ अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वेन एवंरूपो दानपरित्यागः कर्तव्यः सर्वसत्त्वानामर्थाय। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? या चैषा सुभूते सत्त्वसंज्ञा, सैव असंज्ञा। य एवं ते सर्वसत्त्वास्तथागतेन भाषितास्त एव असत्त्वाः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? भूतवादी सुभूते तथागतः, सत्यवादी तथावादी अनन्यथावादी तथागतः, न वितथवादी तथागतः॥ अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते यस्तथागतेन धर्मोऽभिसंबुद्धो देशितो निध्यातः, न तत्र सत्यं न मृषा। तद्यथापि नाम सुभूते पुरुषोऽन्धकारप्रविष्टो न किंचिदपि पश्येत्, एवं वस्तुपतितो बोधिसत्त्वो द्रष्टव्यो यो वस्तुपतितो दानं परित्यजति। तद्यथापि नाम सुभूते चक्षुष्मान् पुरुषः प्रभातायां रात्रौ सूर्येऽभ्युद्गते नानाविधानि रूपाणि पश्येत्, एवमवस्तुपतितो बोधिसत्त्वो द्रष्टव्यो योऽवस्तुपतितो दानं परित्यजति॥ अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते ये कुलपुत्रा वा कुलदुहितरो वा इमं धर्मपर्यायमुद्ग्रहीष्यन्ति धारयिष्यन्ति वाचयिष्यन्ति पर्यवाप्स्यन्ति, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयिष्यन्ति, ज्ञातास्ते सुभूते तथागतेन बुद्धज्ञानेन, दृष्टास्ते सुभूते तथागतेन बुद्धचक्षुषा, बुद्धास्ते तथागतेन। सर्वे ते सुभूते सत्त्वा अप्रमेयमसंख्येयं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसविष्यन्ति प्रतिग्रहीष्यन्ति
atha khalvāyuṣmān subhūtirdharmavegenāśrūṇi prāmuñcat| so'śrūṇi pramṛjya bhagavantametadavocat-āścaryaṃ bhagavan, paramāścaryaṃ sugata, yāvadayaṃ dharmaparyāyastathāgatena bhāṣito'grayānasaṃprasthitānāṃ sattvānāmarthāya, śreṣṭhayānasaṃprasthitānāmarthāya, yato me bhagavan jñānamutpannam| na mayā bhagavan jātvevaṃrūpo dharmaparyāyaḥ śrutapūrvaḥ| parameṇa te bhagavan āścaryeṇa samanvāgatā bodhisattvā bhaviṣyanti, ye iha sūtre bhāṣyamāṇe śrutvā bhūtasaṃjñāmutpādayiṣyanti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yā caiṣā bhagavan bhūtasaṃjñā, saiva abhūtasaṃjñā| tasmāttathāgato bhāṣate bhūtasaṃjñā bhūtasaṃjñeti|| na mama bhagavan āścaryaṃ yadahamimaṃ dharmaparyāyaṃ bhāṣyamāṇamavakalpayāmi adhimucye| ye'pi te bhagavan sattvā bhaviṣyantyanāgate'dhvani paścime kāle paścime samaye paścimāyāṃ pañcaśatyāṃ saddharmavipralope vartamāne, ye imaṃ bhagavan dharmaparyāyamudgrahīṣyanti dhārayiṣyanti vācayiṣyanti paryavāpsyanti, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayiṣyanti, te paramāścaryeṇa samanvāgatā bhaviṣyanti| api tu khalu punarbhagavan na teṣāmātmasaṃjñā pravartiṣyate, na sattvasaṃjñā na jīvasaṃjñā na pudgalasaṃjñā pravartiṣyate, nāpi teṣāṃ kācitsaṃjñā nāsaṃjñā pravartate| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yā sā bhagavan ātmasaṃjñā, saivāsaṃjñā| yā sattvasaṃjñā jīvasaṃjñā pudgalasaṃjñā, saivāsaṃjñā| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sarvasaṃjñāpagatā hi buddhā bhagavantaḥ|| evamukte bhagavānāyuṣmantaṃ subhūtimetadavocat-evametat subhūte, evametat| paramāścaryasamanvāgatāste sattvā bhaviṣyanti, ye iha subhūte sūtre bhāṣyamāṇe notrasiṣyanti na saṃtrasiṣyanti na saṃtrāsamāpatsyante| tatkasya hetoḥ ? paramapāramiteyaṃ subhūte tathāgatena bhāṣitā yadutāpāramitā| yāṃ ca subhūte tathāgataḥ paramapāramitāṃ bhāṣate, tāmaparimāṇā api buddhā bhagavanto bhāṣante| tenocyante paramapāramiteti|| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte yā tathāgatasya kṣāntipāramitā, saiva apāramitā| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yadā me subhūte kalirājā aṅgapratyaṅgamāṃsānyacchaitsīt, nāsīnme tasmin samaye ātmasaṃjñā vā sattvasaṃjñā vā jīvasaṃjñā vā pudgalasaṃjñā vā, nāpi me kācitsaṃjñā vā asaṃjñā vā babhūva| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sacenme subhūte tasmin samaye ātmasaṃjñā abhaviṣyat, vyāpādasaṃjñāpi me tasmin samaye'bhaviṣyat| sacetsattvasaṃjñā jīvasaṃjñā pudgalasaṃjñābhaviṣyat, vyāpādasaṃjñāpi me tasmin samaye'bhaviṣyat| tatkasya hetoḥ ? abhijānāmyahaṃ subhūte atīte'dhvani pañca jātiśatāni yadahaṃ kṣāntivādī ṛṣirabhūvam| tatrāpi me nātmasaṃjñā babhūva, na sattvasaṃjñā, na jīvasaṃjñā, na pudgalasaṃjñā babhūva| tasmāttarhi subhūte bodhisattvena mahāsattvena sarvasaṃjñā vivarjayitvā anuttarāyāṃ samyaksaṃbodhau cittamutpādayitavyam| na rūpapratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam, na śabdagandharasaspraṣṭavyadharmapratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam, na dharmapratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam, nādharmapratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam, na kvacitpratiṣṭhitaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yatpratiṣṭhitaṃ tadevāpratiṣṭhitam| tasmādeva tathāgato bhāṣate-apratiṣṭhitena bodhisattvena dānaṃ dātavyam| na rūpaśabdagandharasasparśadharmapratiṣṭhitena dānaṃ dātavyam|| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte bodhisattvena evaṃrūpo dānaparityāgaḥ kartavyaḥ sarvasattvānāmarthāya| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yā caiṣā subhūte sattvasaṃjñā, saiva asaṃjñā| ya evaṃ te sarvasattvāstathāgatena bhāṣitāsta eva asattvāḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? bhūtavādī subhūte tathāgataḥ, satyavādī tathāvādī ananyathāvādī tathāgataḥ, na vitathavādī tathāgataḥ|| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte yastathāgatena dharmo'bhisaṃbuddho deśito nidhyātaḥ, na tatra satyaṃ na mṛṣā| tadyathāpi nāma subhūte puruṣo'ndhakārapraviṣṭo na kiṃcidapi paśyet, evaṃ vastupatito bodhisattvo draṣṭavyo yo vastupatito dānaṃ parityajati| tadyathāpi nāma subhūte cakṣuṣmān puruṣaḥ prabhātāyāṃ rātrau sūrye'bhyudgate nānāvidhāni rūpāṇi paśyet, evamavastupatito bodhisattvo draṣṭavyo yo'vastupatito dānaṃ parityajati|| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte ye kulaputrā vā kuladuhitaro vā imaṃ dharmaparyāyamudgrahīṣyanti dhārayiṣyanti vācayiṣyanti paryavāpsyanti, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayiṣyanti, jñātāste subhūte tathāgatena buddhajñānena, dṛṣṭāste subhūte tathāgatena buddhacakṣuṣā, buddhāste tathāgatena| sarve te subhūte sattvā aprameyamasaṃkhyeyaṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasaviṣyanti pratigrahīṣyanti
Then Subhuti, moved by the force of the dharma, shed tears. Wiping them away, he said to the Buddha: 'It is wonderful, Teacher, most wonderful, Well-Gone One, how this teaching has been spoken by the Tathagata for the sake of beings who have set out in the highest vehicle, in the best vehicle, and from which knowledge has arisen in me. Never before, Teacher, have I heard a teaching like this. Bodhisattvas who hear this sutra being spoken and produce a true will be endowed with the highest wonder. Why? What is a true is no ; that is why the Tathagata speaks of a true . 'It is no wonder for me, Teacher, that I trust and accept this teaching as it is spoken. But those beings who in the future, in the last time, the last age, the last five hundred years, when the true teaching is in decline, will take up this teaching, keep it, recite it, master it and make it known to others in full, they will be endowed with the highest wonder. In them no of a self will arise, no of a being, a or a person; nor will any or no arise in them. Why? The of a self is no ; the of a being, a or a person is no . Why? Because the buddhas are free of all notions.' The Buddha said to Subhuti: 'So it is, Subhuti, so it is. Beings who are not startled, not frightened, not terrified when this sutra is spoken will be endowed with the highest wonder. Why? This highest perfection, Subhuti, the Tathagata has called no perfection; and what the Tathagata calls the highest perfection, countless buddhas also call so. That is why it is called the highest perfection. 'Moreover, Subhuti, the Tathagata's perfection of patience is no perfection. Why? When the king of Kalinga cut the flesh from my limbs, Subhuti, I had no of a self, a being, a or a person; I had neither nor no . Why? If I had had a of a self at that time, I would also have had a of ill will. If I had had a of a being, a or a person, I would also have had a of ill will. I remember, Subhuti, that for five hundred births in the past I was the sage Kshantivadin, the Preacher of Patience, and then too I had no of a self, a being, a or a person. 'So, Subhuti, a bodhisattva, a great being, should put aside all notions and produce the thought of unsurpassed full awakening. He should produce a mind not form, not sounds, smells, tastes, touches or mental objects, not dharma, not no dharma, not anything. Why? What rests is not resting. That is why the Tathagata says: a gift should be given by a bodhisattva who rests on nothing; it should not be given form, sound, smell, taste, touch or mental objects. 'Moreover, Subhuti, a bodhisattva should give up a gift in this way for the sake of all beings. Why? The of a being is no , and those whom the Tathagata has called all beings are no beings. Why? The Tathagata speaks what is real, speaks what is true, speaks what is so and not otherwise; the Tathagata does not speak falsely. 'Moreover, Subhuti, in the dharma that the Tathagata awakened to, taught and pondered, there is neither truth nor falsehood. A bodhisattva who has fallen into things and gives a gift as one fallen into things is like a man who has gone into darkness and sees nothing. A bodhisattva who has not fallen into things and gives a gift is like a man with eyes who, when night has turned to dawn and the sun has risen, sees forms of many kinds. 'Moreover, Subhuti, sons or daughters of good family who take up this teaching, keep it, recite it, master it and make it known to others in full are known to the Tathagata with his buddha-knowledge, seen by the Tathagata with his buddha-eye, fully known by the Tathagata. All these beings will bring forth and take up a heap of merit beyond measure and beyond count.'
Note //
The story of the sage cut to pieces by the king of Kalinga shows what the teaching means in a body: where there is no notion of a self to defend, there is no ground for ill will. 'Neither truth nor falsehood' does not make the teaching arbitrary; it means the awakened dharma is not a proposition to be held.
Beyond thought and compare
यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते स्त्री वा पुरुषो वा पूर्वाह्णकालसमये गङ्गानदीवालुकासमानात्मभावान् परित्यजेत्, एवं मध्याह्नकालसमये गङ्गानदीवालुकासमानात्मभावान् परित्यजेत्, सायाह्नकालसमये गङ्गानदीवालुकासमानात्मभावान् परित्यजेत्, अनेन पर्यायेण बहूनि कल्पकोटिनियुतशतसहस्राण्यात्मभावान् परित्यजेत्, यश्चेमं धर्मपर्यायं श्रुत्वा न प्रतिक्षिपेत्, अयमेव ततोनिदानं बहुतरं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयादप्रमेयमसंख्येयम्, कः पुनर्वादो यो लिखित्वा उद्गृह्णीयाद्धारयेद्वाचयेत्पर्यवाप्नुयात्, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयेत्॥ अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते अचिन्त्योऽतुल्योऽयं धर्मपर्यायः। अयं च सुभूते धर्मपर्यायस्तथागतेन भाषितोऽग्रयानसंप्रस्थितानां सत्त्वानामर्थाय, श्रेष्ठयानसंप्रस्थितानां सत्त्वानामर्थाय। ये इमं धर्मपर्यायमुद्ग्रहीष्यन्ति धारयिष्यन्ति वाचयिष्यन्ति पर्यवाप्स्यन्ति, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयिष्यन्ति, ज्ञातास्ते सुभूते तथागतेन बुद्धज्ञानेन, दृष्टास्ते सुभूते तथागतेन बुद्धचक्षुषा, बुद्धास्ते तथागतेन। सर्वे ते सुभूते सत्त्वा अप्रमेयेण पुण्यस्कन्धेन समन्वागता भविष्यन्ति। अचिन्त्येनातुल्येनामाप्येनापरिमाणेन पुण्यस्कन्धेन समन्वागता भविष्यन्ति। सर्वे ते सुभूते सत्त्वाः समांशेन बोधिं धारयिष्यन्ति वाचयिष्यन्ति पर्यवाप्स्यन्ति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न हि शक्यं सुभूते अयं धर्मपर्यायो हीनाधिमुक्तिकैः सत्त्वैः श्रोतुम्, नात्मदृष्टिकैर्न सत्त्वदृष्टिकैर्न जीवदृष्टिकैर्न पुद्गलदृष्टिकैः। नाबोधिसत्त्वप्रतिज्ञैः सत्त्वैः शक्यमयं धर्मपर्यायः श्रोतुं वा उद्ग्रहीतुं वा धारयितुं वा वाचयितुं वा पर्यवाप्तुं वा। नेदं स्थानं विद्यते॥ अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते यत्र पृथिवीप्रदेशे इदं सूत्रं प्रकाशयिष्यते, पूजनीयः स पृथिवीप्रदेशो भविष्यति सदेवमानुषासुरस्य लोकस्य। वन्दनीयः प्रदक्षिणीयश्च स पृथिवीप्रदेशो भविष्यति, चैत्यभूतः स पृथिवीप्रदेशो भविष्यति
yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte strī vā puruṣo vā pūrvāhṇakālasamaye gaṅgānadīvālukāsamānātmabhāvān parityajet, evaṃ madhyāhnakālasamaye gaṅgānadīvālukāsamānātmabhāvān parityajet, sāyāhnakālasamaye gaṅgānadīvālukāsamānātmabhāvān parityajet, anena paryāyeṇa bahūni kalpakoṭiniyutaśatasahasrāṇyātmabhāvān parityajet, yaścemaṃ dharmaparyāyaṃ śrutvā na pratikṣipet, ayameva tatonidānaṃ bahutaraṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyādaprameyamasaṃkhyeyam, kaḥ punarvādo yo likhitvā udgṛhṇīyāddhārayedvācayetparyavāpnuyāt, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayet|| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte acintyo'tulyo'yaṃ dharmaparyāyaḥ| ayaṃ ca subhūte dharmaparyāyastathāgatena bhāṣito'grayānasaṃprasthitānāṃ sattvānāmarthāya, śreṣṭhayānasaṃprasthitānāṃ sattvānāmarthāya| ye imaṃ dharmaparyāyamudgrahīṣyanti dhārayiṣyanti vācayiṣyanti paryavāpsyanti, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayiṣyanti, jñātāste subhūte tathāgatena buddhajñānena, dṛṣṭāste subhūte tathāgatena buddhacakṣuṣā, buddhāste tathāgatena| sarve te subhūte sattvā aprameyeṇa puṇyaskandhena samanvāgatā bhaviṣyanti| acintyenātulyenāmāpyenāparimāṇena puṇyaskandhena samanvāgatā bhaviṣyanti| sarve te subhūte sattvāḥ samāṃśena bodhiṃ dhārayiṣyanti vācayiṣyanti paryavāpsyanti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na hi śakyaṃ subhūte ayaṃ dharmaparyāyo hīnādhimuktikaiḥ sattvaiḥ śrotum, nātmadṛṣṭikairna sattvadṛṣṭikairna jīvadṛṣṭikairna pudgaladṛṣṭikaiḥ| nābodhisattvapratijñaiḥ sattvaiḥ śakyamayaṃ dharmaparyāyaḥ śrotuṃ vā udgrahītuṃ vā dhārayituṃ vā vācayituṃ vā paryavāptuṃ vā| nedaṃ sthānaṃ vidyate|| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte yatra pṛthivīpradeśe idaṃ sūtraṃ prakāśayiṣyate, pūjanīyaḥ sa pṛthivīpradeśo bhaviṣyati sadevamānuṣāsurasya lokasya| vandanīyaḥ pradakṣiṇīyaśca sa pṛthivīpradeśo bhaviṣyati, caityabhūtaḥ sa pṛthivīpradeśo bhaviṣyati
'And if, Subhuti, a woman or man gave up bodies as many as the sands of the Ganges in the morning, gave up as many again at noon, and as many again in the evening, and went on giving up bodies in this way for many hundreds of thousands of millions of ages, and if someone else heard this teaching and did not reject it, the second would on that account bring forth a greater heap of merit, beyond measure and beyond count. How much more one who writes it down, takes it up, keeps it, recites it, masters it and makes it known to others in full. 'Moreover, Subhuti, this teaching is beyond thought and beyond compare. It has been spoken by the Tathagata for the sake of beings who have set out in the highest vehicle, in the best vehicle. Those who take up this teaching, keep it, recite it, master it and make it known to others in full are known to the Tathagata with his buddha-knowledge, seen with his buddha-eye, fully known by him. All these beings will be endowed with a heap of merit beyond measure, beyond thought, beyond compare, beyond reckoning, beyond limit. All of them will carry awakening on their shoulders equally. Why? Because this teaching cannot be heard by beings of low resolve, nor by those who hold the view of a self, of a being, of a , or of a person. It cannot be heard, taken up, kept, recited or mastered by beings who have not made the bodhisattva vow. That is not possible. 'Moreover, Subhuti, any spot of earth where this sutra is made known will be worthy of honour by the world with its gods, humans and asuras, worthy of homage and of being walked round; that spot of earth will become a shrine.'
Note //
'Carry awakening on their shoulders' (samamsena dharayishyanti) is a common reading of the Sanskrit; Muller has 'equally remember'.
Despised, and freed by it
अपि तु ये ते सुभूते कुलपुत्रा वा कुलदुहितरो वा इमानेवंरूपान् सूत्रान्तानुद्ग्रहीष्यन्ति धारयिष्यन्ति वाचयिष्यन्ति पर्यवाप्स्यन्ति, योनिशश्च मनसिकरिष्यन्ति, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयिष्यन्ति, ते परिभूता भविष्यन्ति, सुपरिभूताश्च भविष्यन्ति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यानि च तेषां सुभूते सत्त्वानां पौर्वजन्मिकान्यशुभानि कर्माणि कृतान्यपायसंवर्तनीयानि, दृष्ट एव धर्मे परिभूततया तानि पौर्वजन्मिकान्यशुभानि कर्माणि क्षपयिष्यन्ति, बुद्धबोधिं चानुप्राप्स्यन्ति॥ अभिजानाम्यहं सुभूते अतीतेऽध्वन्यसंख्येयैः कल्पैरसंख्येयतरैर्दीपंकरस्य तथागतस्यार्हतः सम्यक्संबुद्धस्य परेण परतरेण चतुरशीतिबुद्धकोटिनियुतशतसहस्राण्यभूवन् ये मयारागिताः, आराग्य न विरागिताः। यच्च मया सुभूते ते बुद्धा भगवन्त आरागिताः, आराग्य न विरागिताः, यच्च पश्चिमे काले पश्चिमे समये पश्चिमायां पञ्चशत्यां सद्धर्मविप्रलोपकाले वर्तमाने इमानेवंरूपान् सूत्रान्तानुद्ग्रहीष्यन्ति धारयिष्यन्ति वाचयिष्यन्ति पर्यवाप्स्यन्ति, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयिष्यन्ति, अस्य खलु पुनः सुभूते पुण्यस्कन्धस्यान्तिकादसौ पौर्वकः पुण्यस्कन्धः शततमीमपि कलां नोपैति, सहस्रतमीमपि शतसहस्रतमीमपि कोटितमीमपि कोटिशततमीमपि कोटिशतसहस्रतमीमपि कोटिनियुतशतसहस्रतमीमपि। संख्यामपि कलामपि गणनामपि उपमामपि उपनिषदमपि यावदौपम्यमपि न क्षमते॥ सचेत्पुनः सुभूते तेषां कुलपुत्राणां कुलदुहितॄणां वा अहं पुण्यस्कन्धं भाषेयम्, यावत्ते कुलपुत्रा वा कुलदुहितरो वा तस्मिन् समये पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसविष्यन्ति, प्रतिग्रहीष्यन्ति, उन्मादं सत्त्वा अनुप्राप्नुयुश्चित्तविक्षेपं वा गच्छेयुः। अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते अचिन्त्योऽतुल्योऽयं धर्मपर्यायस्तथागतेन भाषितः। अस्य अचिन्त्य एव विपाकः प्रतिकाङ्क्षितव्यः
api tu ye te subhūte kulaputrā vā kuladuhitaro vā imānevaṃrūpān sūtrāntānudgrahīṣyanti dhārayiṣyanti vācayiṣyanti paryavāpsyanti, yoniśaśca manasikariṣyanti, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayiṣyanti, te paribhūtā bhaviṣyanti, suparibhūtāśca bhaviṣyanti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yāni ca teṣāṃ subhūte sattvānāṃ paurvajanmikānyaśubhāni karmāṇi kṛtānyapāyasaṃvartanīyāni, dṛṣṭa eva dharme paribhūtatayā tāni paurvajanmikānyaśubhāni karmāṇi kṣapayiṣyanti, buddhabodhiṃ cānuprāpsyanti|| abhijānāmyahaṃ subhūte atīte'dhvanyasaṃkhyeyaiḥ kalpairasaṃkhyeyatarairdīpaṃkarasya tathāgatasyārhataḥ samyaksaṃbuddhasya pareṇa paratareṇa caturaśītibuddhakoṭiniyutaśatasahasrāṇyabhūvan ye mayārāgitāḥ, ārāgya na virāgitāḥ| yacca mayā subhūte te buddhā bhagavanta ārāgitāḥ, ārāgya na virāgitāḥ, yacca paścime kāle paścime samaye paścimāyāṃ pañcaśatyāṃ saddharmavipralopakāle vartamāne imānevaṃrūpān sūtrāntānudgrahīṣyanti dhārayiṣyanti vācayiṣyanti paryavāpsyanti, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayiṣyanti, asya khalu punaḥ subhūte puṇyaskandhasyāntikādasau paurvakaḥ puṇyaskandhaḥ śatatamīmapi kalāṃ nopaiti, sahasratamīmapi śatasahasratamīmapi koṭitamīmapi koṭiśatatamīmapi koṭiśatasahasratamīmapi koṭiniyutaśatasahasratamīmapi| saṃkhyāmapi kalāmapi gaṇanāmapi upamāmapi upaniṣadamapi yāvadaupamyamapi na kṣamate|| sacetpunaḥ subhūte teṣāṃ kulaputrāṇāṃ kuladuhitṝṇāṃ vā ahaṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ bhāṣeyam, yāvatte kulaputrā vā kuladuhitaro vā tasmin samaye puṇyaskandhaṃ prasaviṣyanti, pratigrahīṣyanti, unmādaṃ sattvā anuprāpnuyuścittavikṣepaṃ vā gaccheyuḥ| api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte acintyo'tulyo'yaṃ dharmaparyāyastathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| asya acintya eva vipākaḥ pratikāṅkṣitavyaḥ
'Yet, Subhuti, sons or daughters of good family who take up sutras like these, keep them, recite them, master them, attend to them wisely and make them known to others in full may be despised, thoroughly despised. Why? Whatever unwholesome deeds those beings did in former lives, deeds leading to the lower realms, by being despised in this very life they will wear away those unwholesome deeds of former lives, and they will reach the awakening of a buddha. 'I remember, Subhuti, that in the past, countless and more than countless ages ago, long before the Tathagata Dipankara, the worthy one, the fully awakened one, there were eighty-four hundred thousand millions of buddhas whom I pleased and, having pleased, did not displease. And yet, Subhuti, compared with the heap of merit of those who in the last time, the last age, the last five hundred years, when the true teaching is in decline, take up sutras like these, keep them, recite them, master them and make them known to others in full, that earlier heap of merit does not come to a hundredth part, nor a thousandth, nor a hundred-thousandth, nor a ten-millionth, nor any fraction, number, count, likeness or comparison. 'If I were to tell you, Subhuti, how great a heap of merit those sons or daughters of good family will bring forth and take up at that time, beings would go mad or their minds would be thrown into confusion. Moreover, Subhuti, this teaching spoken by the Tathagata is beyond thought and beyond compare, and its fruit too is to be expected as beyond thought.'
Note //
Muller translates paribhuta as 'overcome'; it means scorned or despised. The point is that contempt suffered for holding this teaching wears away old harm.
No one sets out; the meaning of Tathagata
अथ खल्वायुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्-कथं भगवन् बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन स्थातव्यम्, कथं प्रतिपत्तव्यम्, कथं चित्तं प्रग्रहीतव्यम् ? भगवानाह-इह सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन एवं चित्तमुत्पादयितव्यम्-सर्वे सत्त्वा मया अनुपधिशेषे निर्वाणधातौ परिनिर्वापयितव्याः। एवं स सत्त्वान् परिनिर्वाप्य न कश्चित्सत्त्वः परिनिर्वापितो भवति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सचेत्सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वस्य सत्त्वसंज्ञा प्रवर्तेत, न स बोधिसत्त्व इति वक्तव्यः। जीवसंज्ञा वा यावत्पुद्गलसंज्ञा वा प्रवर्तेत, न स बोधिसत्त्व इति वक्तव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? नास्ति सुभूते स कश्चिद्धर्मो यो बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितो नाम॥ तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते अस्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन दीपंकरस्य तथागतस्यान्तिकादनुत्तरां सम्यक्संबोधिमभिसंबुद्धः ? एवमुक्ते आयुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्- यथाहं भगवतो भाषितस्यार्थमाजानामि, नास्ति स भगवन् कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन दीपंकरस्य तथागतस्यार्हतः सम्यक्संबुद्धस्यान्तिकादनुत्तरां सम्यक्संबोधिमभिसंबुद्धः। एवमुक्ते भगवानायुष्मन्तं सुभूतिमेतदवोचत्-एवमेतत्सुभूते, एवमेतत्। नास्ति सुभूते स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन दीपंकरस्य तथागतस्यार्हतः सम्यक्संबुद्धस्यान्तिकादनुत्तरां सम्यक्संबोधिमभिसंबुद्धः। सचेत्पुनः सुभूते कश्चिद्धर्मस्तथागतेनाभिसंबुद्धोऽभविष्यत्, न मां दीपंकरस्तथागतो व्याकरिष्यत्-भविष्यसि त्वं माणव अनागतेऽध्वनि शाक्यमुनिर्नाम तथागतोऽर्हन् सम्यक्संबुद्ध इति। यस्मात्तर्हि सुभूते तथागतेनार्हता सम्यक्संबुद्धेन नास्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो योऽनुत्तरां सम्यक्संबोधिमभिसंबुद्धः, तस्मादहं दीपंकरेण तथागतेन व्याकृत- भविष्यसि त्वं माणव अनागतेऽध्वनि शाक्यमुनिर्नाम तथागतोऽर्हन् सम्यक्संबुद्ध। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? तथागत इति सुभूते भूततथताया एतदधिवचनम्। तथागत इति सुभूते अनुत्पादधर्मताया एतदधिवचनम्। तथागत इति सुभूते धर्मोच्छेदस्यैतदधिवचनम्। तथागत इति सुभूते अत्यन्तानुत्पन्नस्यैतदधिवचनम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? एष सुभूते अनुत्पादो यः परमार्थः। यः कश्चित्सुभूते एवं वदेत्-तथागतेनार्हता सम्यक्संबुद्धेन अनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिरभिसंबुद्धेति, स वितथं वदेत्। अभ्याचक्षीत मां स सुभूते असतोद्गृहीतेन। तत्कस्य हेतोः- ? नास्ति सुभूते स कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेन अनुत्तरां सम्यक्संबोधिमभिसंबुद्धः। यश्च सुभूते तथागतेन धर्मोऽभिसंबुद्धो देशितो वा तत्र न सत्यं न मृषा। तस्मात्तथागतो भाषते-सर्वधर्मा बुद्धधर्मा इति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सर्वधर्मा इति सुभूते अधर्मास्तथागतेन भाषिताः। तस्मादुच्यन्ते सर्वधर्मा बुद्धधर्मा इति॥ तद्यथापि नाम सुभूते पुरुषो भवेदुपेतकायो महाकायः ? आयुष्मान् सुभूतिराह- योऽसौ भगवंस्तथागतेन पुरुषो भाषित उपेतकायो महाकाय इति, अकायः स भगवंस्तथागतेन भाषितः। तेनोच्यते उपेतकायो महाकाय इति॥ भगवानाह -एवमेतत्सुभूते। यो बोधिसत्त्व एवं वदेत्-अहं सत्त्वान् परिनिर्वापयिष्यामिति, न स बोधिसत्त्व इति वक्तव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? अस्ति सुभूते स कश्चिद्धर्मो यो बोधिसत्त्वो नाम ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। नास्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यो बोधिसत्त्वो नाम। भगवानाह- सत्त्वाः सत्त्वा इति सुभूते असत्त्वास्ते तथागतेन भाषिताः, तेनोच्यन्ते सत्त्वा इति। तस्मात्तथागतो भाषते-निरात्मानः सर्वधर्मा निर्जीवा निष्पोषा निष्पुद्गलाः सर्वधर्मा इति॥ यः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्व एवं वदेत्- अहं क्षेत्रव्यूहान्निष्पादयिष्यामीति, स वितथं वदेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? क्षेत्रव्यूहाः क्षेत्रव्यूहा इति सुभूते अव्यूहास्ते तथागतेन भाषिताः। तेनोच्यन्ते क्षेत्रव्यूहा इति॥ यः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वो निरात्मानो धर्मा निरात्मानो धर्मा इत्यधिमुच्यते, तथागतेनार्हता सम्यक्संबुद्धेन बोधिसत्त्वो महासत्त्व इत्याख्यातः
atha khalvāyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavantametadavocat-kathaṃ bhagavan bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitena sthātavyam, kathaṃ pratipattavyam, kathaṃ cittaṃ pragrahītavyam ? bhagavānāha-iha subhūte bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitena evaṃ cittamutpādayitavyam-sarve sattvā mayā anupadhiśeṣe nirvāṇadhātau parinirvāpayitavyāḥ| evaṃ sa sattvān parinirvāpya na kaścitsattvaḥ parinirvāpito bhavati| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sacetsubhūte bodhisattvasya sattvasaṃjñā pravarteta, na sa bodhisattva iti vaktavyaḥ| jīvasaṃjñā vā yāvatpudgalasaṃjñā vā pravarteta, na sa bodhisattva iti vaktavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? nāsti subhūte sa kaściddharmo yo bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthito nāma|| tatkiṃ manyase subhūte asti sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena dīpaṃkarasya tathāgatasyāntikādanuttarāṃ samyaksaṃbodhimabhisaṃbuddhaḥ ? evamukte āyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavantametadavocat- yathāhaṃ bhagavato bhāṣitasyārthamājānāmi, nāsti sa bhagavan kaściddharmo yastathāgatena dīpaṃkarasya tathāgatasyārhataḥ samyaksaṃbuddhasyāntikādanuttarāṃ samyaksaṃbodhimabhisaṃbuddhaḥ| evamukte bhagavānāyuṣmantaṃ subhūtimetadavocat-evametatsubhūte, evametat| nāsti subhūte sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena dīpaṃkarasya tathāgatasyārhataḥ samyaksaṃbuddhasyāntikādanuttarāṃ samyaksaṃbodhimabhisaṃbuddhaḥ| sacetpunaḥ subhūte kaściddharmastathāgatenābhisaṃbuddho'bhaviṣyat, na māṃ dīpaṃkarastathāgato vyākariṣyat-bhaviṣyasi tvaṃ māṇava anāgate'dhvani śākyamunirnāma tathāgato'rhan samyaksaṃbuddha iti| yasmāttarhi subhūte tathāgatenārhatā samyaksaṃbuddhena nāsti sa kaściddharmo yo'nuttarāṃ samyaksaṃbodhimabhisaṃbuddhaḥ, tasmādahaṃ dīpaṃkareṇa tathāgatena vyākṛta- bhaviṣyasi tvaṃ māṇava anāgate'dhvani śākyamunirnāma tathāgato'rhan samyaksaṃbuddha| tatkasya hetoḥ ? tathāgata iti subhūte bhūtatathatāyā etadadhivacanam| tathāgata iti subhūte anutpādadharmatāyā etadadhivacanam| tathāgata iti subhūte dharmocchedasyaitadadhivacanam| tathāgata iti subhūte atyantānutpannasyaitadadhivacanam| tatkasya hetoḥ ? eṣa subhūte anutpādo yaḥ paramārthaḥ| yaḥ kaścitsubhūte evaṃ vadet-tathāgatenārhatā samyaksaṃbuddhena anuttarā samyaksaṃbodhirabhisaṃbuddheti, sa vitathaṃ vadet| abhyācakṣīta māṃ sa subhūte asatodgṛhītena| tatkasya hetoḥ- ? nāsti subhūte sa kaściddharmo yastathāgatena anuttarāṃ samyaksaṃbodhimabhisaṃbuddhaḥ| yaśca subhūte tathāgatena dharmo'bhisaṃbuddho deśito vā tatra na satyaṃ na mṛṣā| tasmāttathāgato bhāṣate-sarvadharmā buddhadharmā iti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sarvadharmā iti subhūte adharmāstathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ| tasmāducyante sarvadharmā buddhadharmā iti|| tadyathāpi nāma subhūte puruṣo bhavedupetakāyo mahākāyaḥ ? āyuṣmān subhūtirāha- yo'sau bhagavaṃstathāgatena puruṣo bhāṣita upetakāyo mahākāya iti, akāyaḥ sa bhagavaṃstathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tenocyate upetakāyo mahākāya iti|| bhagavānāha -evametatsubhūte| yo bodhisattva evaṃ vadet-ahaṃ sattvān parinirvāpayiṣyāmiti, na sa bodhisattva iti vaktavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? asti subhūte sa kaściddharmo yo bodhisattvo nāma ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| nāsti sa kaściddharmo yo bodhisattvo nāma| bhagavānāha- sattvāḥ sattvā iti subhūte asattvāste tathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ, tenocyante sattvā iti| tasmāttathāgato bhāṣate-nirātmānaḥ sarvadharmā nirjīvā niṣpoṣā niṣpudgalāḥ sarvadharmā iti|| yaḥ subhūte bodhisattva evaṃ vadet- ahaṃ kṣetravyūhānniṣpādayiṣyāmīti, sa vitathaṃ vadet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? kṣetravyūhāḥ kṣetravyūhā iti subhūte avyūhāste tathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ| tenocyante kṣetravyūhā iti|| yaḥ subhūte bodhisattvo nirātmāno dharmā nirātmāno dharmā ityadhimucyate, tathāgatenārhatā samyaksaṃbuddhena bodhisattvo mahāsattva ityākhyātaḥ
Then Subhuti said to the Buddha: 'How, Teacher, should one who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas stand, how should they go on, how should they hold the mind?' The Buddha said: 'Here, Subhuti, one who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas should produce this thought: "All beings must be led by me to final nirvana, in the realm of nirvana that leaves nothing behind." And after leading beings to nirvana in this way, no being at all has been led to nirvana. Why? If the of a being arose in a bodhisattva, he should not be called a bodhisattva; if the of a , or any up to that of a person, arose, he should not be called a bodhisattva. Why? There is no dharma, Subhuti, called "one who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas". 'What do you think, Subhuti, is there any dharma by which the Tathagata, in the presence of the Tathagata Dipankara, fully awakened to unsurpassed full awakening?' Subhuti said: 'As I understand the meaning of what you have said, there is no such dharma, Teacher.' The Buddha said: 'So it is, Subhuti, so it is. There is no dharma by which the Tathagata, in the presence of Dipankara, fully awakened to unsurpassed full awakening. If there had been any dharma that the Tathagata awakened to, Dipankara would not have foretold of me: "Young man, in a future time you will be the Tathagata named Shakyamuni, the worthy one, the fully awakened one." Because there is no dharma that the Tathagata awakened to as unsurpassed full awakening, Dipankara foretold of me: "Young man, in a future time you will be the Tathagata named Shakyamuni." 'Why? "Tathagata", Subhuti, is a name for true suchness. "Tathagata" is a name for the nature of things that do not arise. "Tathagata" is a name for the cutting off of dharmas. "Tathagata" is a name for what has never arisen at all. Why? This non-arising is the highest truth. 'Whoever says, Subhuti, that the Tathagata, the worthy one, the fully awakened one, fully awakened to unsurpassed full awakening, speaks falsely and slanders me by grasping what is not there. Why? There is no dharma that the Tathagata awakened to as unsurpassed full awakening. And in the dharma that the Tathagata awakened to and taught there is neither truth nor falsehood. That is why the Tathagata says: "All dharmas are the Buddha's dharmas." Why? "All dharmas", Subhuti, the Tathagata has called no dharmas; that is why all dharmas are called the Buddha's dharmas. 'Suppose, Subhuti, a man had a full body, a great body.' Subhuti said: 'The man the Tathagata spoke of as having a full body, a great body, the Tathagata has called no body; that is why he is called one with a full body, a great body.' The Buddha said: 'So it is, Subhuti. A bodhisattva who says, "I will lead beings to nirvana", should not be called a bodhisattva. Why? Is there any dharma called a bodhisattva, Subhuti?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, there is no dharma called a bodhisattva.' The Buddha said: '"Beings, beings": the Tathagata has called them no beings; that is why they are called beings. That is why the Tathagata says: "All dharmas are without self, without life, without nourisher, without person." 'A bodhisattva who says, "I will create harmonious buddha-fields", speaks falsely. Why? "Harmonious fields, harmonious fields": the Tathagata has called them not harmonious; that is why they are called harmonious fields. A bodhisattva who is resolved that dharmas are without self, dharmas are without self, is called by the Tathagata, the worthy one, the fully awakened one, a bodhisattva, a great being.'
Note //
The second half of the sutra opens by repeating Subhuti's first question; the answer goes further: not only are beings empty, the one who sets out is empty too. 'Tathagata' is read as a name for suchness (tathata). In the site's reading, 'true suchness' and 'what has never arisen' come close to what Advaita calls the whole, unborn and unchanging (position 1); the sutra does not call it a self.
The five eyes and the stream of thought
भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-संविद्यते तथागतस्य मांसचक्षुः ? सुभूतिराह- एवमेतद्भगवन्, संविद्यते तथागतस्य मांसचक्षुः। भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते संविद्यते तथागतस्य दिव्यं चक्षुः ? सुभूतिराह-एवमेतद्भगवन्, संविद्यते तथागतस्य दिव्यं चक्षुः। भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते संविद्यते तथागतस्य प्रज्ञाचक्षुः ? सुभूतिराह-एवमेतद्भगवन्, संविद्यते तथागतस्य प्रज्ञाचक्षुः। भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते संविद्यते तथागतस्य धर्मचक्षुः ? सुभूतिराह-एवमेतद्भगवन्, संविद्यते तथागतस्य धर्मचक्षुः। भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते संविद्यते तथागतस्य बुद्धचक्षुः ? सुभूतिराह-एवमेतद्भगवन्, संविद्यते तथागतस्य बुद्धचक्षुः। भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते यावन्त्यो गङ्गायां महानद्यां वालुकाः, अपि नु ता वालुकास्तथागतेन भाषिताः ? सुभूतिराह-एवमेतद्भगवन्, एवमेतत् सुगत। भाषितास्तथागतेन वालुकाः। भगवानाह-तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते यावत्यो गङ्गायां महानद्यां वालुकाः, तावत्य एव गङ्गानद्यो भवेयुः, तासु वा वालुकाः, तावन्तश्च लोकधातवो भवेयुः, कच्चिद्बहवस्ते लोकधातवो भवेयुः ? सुभूतिराह-एवमेतद्भगवन्, एवमेतत् सुगत। बहवस्ते लोकधातवो भवेयुः। भगवानाह-यावन्तः सुभूते तेषु लोकधातुषु सत्त्वाः, तेषामहं नानाभावां चित्तधारां प्रजानामि। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? चित्तधारा चित्तधारेति सुभूते अधारैषा तथागतेन भाषिता, तेनोच्यते चित्तधारेति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? अतीतं सुभूते चित्तं नोपलभ्यते। अनागतं चित्तं नोपलभ्यते। प्रत्युत्पन्नं चित्तं नोपलभ्यते
bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-saṃvidyate tathāgatasya māṃsacakṣuḥ ? subhūtirāha- evametadbhagavan, saṃvidyate tathāgatasya māṃsacakṣuḥ| bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte saṃvidyate tathāgatasya divyaṃ cakṣuḥ ? subhūtirāha-evametadbhagavan, saṃvidyate tathāgatasya divyaṃ cakṣuḥ| bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte saṃvidyate tathāgatasya prajñācakṣuḥ ? subhūtirāha-evametadbhagavan, saṃvidyate tathāgatasya prajñācakṣuḥ| bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte saṃvidyate tathāgatasya dharmacakṣuḥ ? subhūtirāha-evametadbhagavan, saṃvidyate tathāgatasya dharmacakṣuḥ| bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte saṃvidyate tathāgatasya buddhacakṣuḥ ? subhūtirāha-evametadbhagavan, saṃvidyate tathāgatasya buddhacakṣuḥ| bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte yāvantyo gaṅgāyāṃ mahānadyāṃ vālukāḥ, api nu tā vālukāstathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ ? subhūtirāha-evametadbhagavan, evametat sugata| bhāṣitāstathāgatena vālukāḥ| bhagavānāha-tatkiṃ manyase subhūte yāvatyo gaṅgāyāṃ mahānadyāṃ vālukāḥ, tāvatya eva gaṅgānadyo bhaveyuḥ, tāsu vā vālukāḥ, tāvantaśca lokadhātavo bhaveyuḥ, kaccidbahavaste lokadhātavo bhaveyuḥ ? subhūtirāha-evametadbhagavan, evametat sugata| bahavaste lokadhātavo bhaveyuḥ| bhagavānāha-yāvantaḥ subhūte teṣu lokadhātuṣu sattvāḥ, teṣāmahaṃ nānābhāvāṃ cittadhārāṃ prajānāmi| tatkasya hetoḥ ? cittadhārā cittadhāreti subhūte adhāraiṣā tathāgatena bhāṣitā, tenocyate cittadhāreti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? atītaṃ subhūte cittaṃ nopalabhyate| anāgataṃ cittaṃ nopalabhyate| pratyutpannaṃ cittaṃ nopalabhyate
The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, does the Tathagata have the fleshly eye?' Subhuti said: 'So it is, Teacher, the Tathagata has the fleshly eye.' 'Does the Tathagata have the eye of the gods?' 'So it is, Teacher.' 'Does the Tathagata have the eye of wisdom?' 'So it is, Teacher.' 'Does the Tathagata have the eye of dharma?' 'So it is, Teacher.' 'Does the Tathagata have the eye of a buddha?' 'So it is, Teacher, the Tathagata has the eye of a buddha.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, the grains of sand in the great river Ganges, has the Tathagata spoken of them as grains of sand?' Subhuti said: 'So it is, Teacher, so it is, Well-Gone One; the Tathagata has spoken of them as grains of sand.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, if there were as many Ganges rivers as there are grains of sand in the great river Ganges, and as many world-systems as there are grains of sand in them, would those world-systems be many?' Subhuti said: 'So it is, Teacher, so it is, Well-Gone One; those world-systems would be many.' The Buddha said: 'However many beings there are in those world-systems, I know the many streams of their thought. Why? "A stream of thought, a stream of thought": the Tathagata has called it ; that is why it is called a stream of thought. Why? Past thought , Subhuti; future thought ; present thought .'
Note //
The five eyes run from ordinary sight to a buddha's sight; the Tathagata has them all, the sutra does not deny ordinary seeing. 'Thought cannot be found' (nopalabhyate) in any of the three times is one of the sutra's most quoted lines: the mind is not a thing that could be located.
If there were a heap of merit
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते यः कश्चित्कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा इमं त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रं लोकधातुं सप्तरत्नपरिपूर्णं कृत्वा तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, अपि नु स कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा ततोनिदानं बहु पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयात् ? सुभूतिराह- बहु भगवन्, बहु सुगत। भगवानाह-एवमेतत्सुभूते, एवमेतत्। बहु स कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा ततोनिदानं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयादप्रमेयमसंख्येयम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? पुण्यस्कन्धः पुण्यस्कन्ध इति सुभूते अस्कन्धः स तथागतेन भाषितः। तेनोच्यते पुण्यस्कन्ध इति। सचेत् पुनः सुभूते पुण्यस्कन्धोऽभविष्यत्, न तथागतोऽभाषिष्यत् पुण्यस्कन्धः पुण्यस्कन्ध इति
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte yaḥ kaścitkulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā imaṃ trisāhasramahāsāhasraṃ lokadhātuṃ saptaratnaparipūrṇaṃ kṛtvā tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, api nu sa kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā tatonidānaṃ bahu puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyāt ? subhūtirāha- bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata| bhagavānāha-evametatsubhūte, evametat| bahu sa kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā tatonidānaṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyādaprameyamasaṃkhyeyam| tatkasya hetoḥ ? puṇyaskandhaḥ puṇyaskandha iti subhūte askandhaḥ sa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tenocyate puṇyaskandha iti| sacet punaḥ subhūte puṇyaskandho'bhaviṣyat, na tathāgato'bhāṣiṣyat puṇyaskandhaḥ puṇyaskandha iti
'What do you think, Subhuti, if a son or daughter of good family filled this world-system of a thousand million worlds with the seven treasures and gave it as a gift to the Tathagatas, the worthy ones, the fully awakened ones, would that son or daughter of good family bring forth a great heap of merit on that account?' Subhuti said: 'Great, Teacher, great, Well-Gone One.' The Buddha said: 'So it is, Subhuti, so it is. That son or daughter of good family would on that account bring forth a great heap of merit, beyond measure and beyond count. Why? "A heap of merit, a heap of merit": the Tathagata has called it no heap; that is why it is called a heap of merit. If there were a heap of merit, Subhuti, the Tathagata would not have spoken of "a heap of merit, a heap of merit".'
Not seen by the perfect body
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते रूपकायपरिनिष्पत्त्या तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। न रूपकायपरिनिष्पत्त्या तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? रूपकायपरिनिष्पत्ती रूपकायपरिनिष्पत्तिरिति भगवन् अपरिनिष्पत्तिरेषा तथागतेन भाषिता। तेनोच्यते रूपकायपरिनिष्पत्तिरिति॥ भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। न लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यैषा भगवन् लक्षणसंपत्तथागतेन भाषिता, अलक्षणसंपदेषा तथागतेन भाषिता। तेनोच्यते लक्षणसंपदिति
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte rūpakāyapariniṣpattyā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| na rūpakāyapariniṣpattyā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? rūpakāyapariniṣpattī rūpakāyapariniṣpattiriti bhagavan apariniṣpattireṣā tathāgatena bhāṣitā| tenocyate rūpakāyapariniṣpattiriti|| bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| na lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yaiṣā bhagavan lakṣaṇasaṃpattathāgatena bhāṣitā, alakṣaṇasaṃpadeṣā tathāgatena bhāṣitā| tenocyate lakṣaṇasaṃpaditi
'What do you think, Subhuti, is the Tathagata to be seen by the perfection of his form-body?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, the Tathagata is not to be seen by the perfection of his form-body. Why? "The perfection of the form-body, the perfection of the form-body": the Tathagata has called it no perfection; that is why it is called the perfection of the form-body.' The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, is the Tathagata to be seen by the possession of marks?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher. Why? What the Tathagata has called the possession of marks he has called no possession of marks; that is why it is called the possession of marks.'
No dharma taught
भगवानाह- तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते अपि नु तथागतस्यैवं भवति-मया धर्मो देशित इति ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन् तथागतस्यैवं भवति-मया धर्मो देशित इति। भगवानाह-यः सुभूते एवं वदेत्- तथागतेन धर्मो देशित इति, स वितथं वदेत्। अभ्याचक्षीत मां स सुभूते असतोद्गृहीतेन। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? धर्मदेशना धर्मदेशनेति सुभूते नास्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मो यो धर्मदेशना नामोपलभ्यते॥ एवमुक्ते आयुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्-अस्ति भगवन् केचित्सत्त्वा भविष्यन्त्यनागतेऽध्वनि पश्चिमे काले पश्चिमे समये पश्चिमायां पञ्चशत्यां सद्धर्मविप्रलोपे वर्तमाने, य इमानेवंरूपान् धर्मान् श्रुत्वा अभिश्रद्धास्यन्ति। भगवानाह- न ते सुभूते सत्त्वा नासत्त्वाः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सत्त्वाः सत्त्वा इति सुभूते सर्वे ते सुभूते असत्त्वास्तथागतेन भाषिताः। तेनोच्यन्ते सत्त्वा इति
bhagavānāha- tatkiṃ manyase subhūte api nu tathāgatasyaivaṃ bhavati-mayā dharmo deśita iti ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan tathāgatasyaivaṃ bhavati-mayā dharmo deśita iti| bhagavānāha-yaḥ subhūte evaṃ vadet- tathāgatena dharmo deśita iti, sa vitathaṃ vadet| abhyācakṣīta māṃ sa subhūte asatodgṛhītena| tatkasya hetoḥ ? dharmadeśanā dharmadeśaneti subhūte nāsti sa kaściddharmo yo dharmadeśanā nāmopalabhyate|| evamukte āyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavantametadavocat-asti bhagavan kecitsattvā bhaviṣyantyanāgate'dhvani paścime kāle paścime samaye paścimāyāṃ pañcaśatyāṃ saddharmavipralope vartamāne, ya imānevaṃrūpān dharmān śrutvā abhiśraddhāsyanti| bhagavānāha- na te subhūte sattvā nāsattvāḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sattvāḥ sattvā iti subhūte sarve te subhūte asattvāstathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ| tenocyante sattvā iti
The Buddha said: 'What do you think, Subhuti, does the Tathagata think, "I have taught the dharma"?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, the Tathagata does not think, "I have taught the dharma."' The Buddha said: 'Whoever says that the Tathagata has taught the dharma speaks falsely, Subhuti, and slanders me by grasping what is not there. Why? "Teaching the dharma, teaching the dharma": there is no dharma, Subhuti, that can be found called teaching the dharma.' Then Subhuti said to the Buddha: 'Teacher, will there be any beings in the future, in the last time, the last age, the last five hundred years, when the true teaching is in decline, who will hear teachings like these and trust them?' The Buddha said: 'They are neither beings nor not beings, Subhuti. Why? "Beings, beings": all of them the Tathagata has called no beings; that is why they are called beings.'
Note //
The question about future listeners is answered by undoing the notion of 'beings' who would or would not trust: they are neither beings with a fixed nature nor nothing at all.
Not even the least thing
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-अपि नु अस्ति स कश्चिद्धर्मः, यस्तथागतेनानुत्तरां सम्यक्संबोधिमभिसंबुद्धः ? आयुष्मान् सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। नास्ति स भगवन् कश्चिद्धर्मो यस्तथागतेनानुत्तरां सम्यक्संबोधिमभिसंबुद्धः। भगवानाह-एवमेतत्सुभूते, एवमेतत्। अणुरपि तत्र धर्मो न संविद्यते नोपलभ्यते। तेनोच्यते अनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिरिति
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-api nu asti sa kaściddharmaḥ, yastathāgatenānuttarāṃ samyaksaṃbodhimabhisaṃbuddhaḥ ? āyuṣmān subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| nāsti sa bhagavan kaściddharmo yastathāgatenānuttarāṃ samyaksaṃbodhimabhisaṃbuddhaḥ| bhagavānāha-evametatsubhūte, evametat| aṇurapi tatra dharmo na saṃvidyate nopalabhyate| tenocyate anuttarā samyaksaṃbodhiriti
'What do you think, Subhuti, is there any dharma by which the Tathagata fully awakened to unsurpassed full awakening?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, there is no dharma by which the Tathagata fully awakened to unsurpassed full awakening.' The Buddha said: 'So it is, Subhuti, so it is. Not even the least dharma is there, or can be found; that is why it is called unsurpassed full awakening.'
Even, with no high or low
अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते समः स धर्मो न तत्र कश्चिद्विषमः। तेनोच्यते अनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिरिति। निरात्मत्वेन निःसत्त्वत्वेन निर्जीवत्वेन निष्पुद्गलत्वेन समा सा अनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिः सर्वैः कुशलैर्धर्मैरभिसंबुध्यते। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? कुशला धर्माः कुशला धर्मा इति सुभूते अधर्माश्चैव ते तथागतेन भाषिताः। तेनोच्यन्ते कुशला धर्मा इति
api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte samaḥ sa dharmo na tatra kaścidviṣamaḥ| tenocyate anuttarā samyaksaṃbodhiriti| nirātmatvena niḥsattvatvena nirjīvatvena niṣpudgalatvena samā sā anuttarā samyaksaṃbodhiḥ sarvaiḥ kuśalairdharmairabhisaṃbudhyate| tatkasya hetoḥ ? kuśalā dharmāḥ kuśalā dharmā iti subhūte adharmāścaiva te tathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ| tenocyante kuśalā dharmā iti
'Moreover, Subhuti, that dharma is even; there is nothing uneven in it. That is why it is called unsurpassed full awakening. Through being without self, without being, without , without person, that unsurpassed full awakening is even, and it is fully awakened to through all wholesome dharmas. Why? "Wholesome dharmas, wholesome dharmas": the Tathagata has called them no dharmas; that is why they are called wholesome dharmas.'
Note //
Awakening is 'even' (sama): no thing in it stands higher or lower than another. Yet it is reached through wholesome conduct; emptiness does not cancel ethics.
Mountains of treasure
यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते स्त्री वा पुरुषो वा यावन्तस्त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रे लोकधातौ सुमेरवः पर्वतराजानः, तावतो राशीन् सप्तानां रत्नानामभिसंहृत्य तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, यश्च कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा इतः प्रज्ञापारमिताया धर्मपर्यायादन्तशश्चतुष्पादिकामपि गाथामुद्गृह्य परेभ्यो देशयेत्, अस्य सुभूते पुण्यस्कन्धस्य असौ पौर्वकः पुण्यस्कन्धः शततमीमपि कलां नोपैति, यावदुपनिषदमपि न क्षमते
yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte strī vā puruṣo vā yāvantastrisāhasramahāsāhasre lokadhātau sumeravaḥ parvatarājānaḥ, tāvato rāśīn saptānāṃ ratnānāmabhisaṃhṛtya tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, yaśca kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā itaḥ prajñāpāramitāyā dharmaparyāyādantaśaścatuṣpādikāmapi gāthāmudgṛhya parebhyo deśayet, asya subhūte puṇyaskandhasya asau paurvakaḥ puṇyaskandhaḥ śatatamīmapi kalāṃ nopaiti, yāvadupaniṣadamapi na kṣamate
'And if, Subhuti, a woman or man heaped up as many piles of the seven treasures as there are Sumerus, kings of mountains, in this world-system of a thousand million worlds, and gave them as a gift to the Tathagatas, the worthy ones, the fully awakened ones, and if a son or daughter of good family took from this teaching of the Perfection of Wisdom even one verse of four lines and taught it to others, then compared with this heap of merit the earlier heap of merit would not come to a hundredth part, nor any fraction, nor bear any comparison.'
No being freed by the Tathagata
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-अपि नु तथागतस्यैवं भवति-मया सत्त्वाः परिमोचिता इति? न खलु पुनः सुभूते एवं द्रष्टव्यम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? नास्ति सुभूते कश्चित्सत्त्वो यस्तथागतेन परिमोचितः। यदि पुनः सुभूते कश्चित्सत्त्वोऽभविष्यद्यस्तथागतेन परिमोचितः स्यात्, स एव तथागतस्यात्मग्राहोऽभविष्यत्, सत्त्वग्राहो जीवग्राहः पुद्गलग्राहोऽभविष्यत्। आत्मग्राह इति सुभूते अग्राह एष तथागतेन भाषितः। स च बालपृथग्जनैरुद्गृहीतः। बालपृथग्जना इति सुभूते अजना एव ते तथागतेन भाषिताः। तेनोच्यन्ते बालपृथग्जना इति
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-api nu tathāgatasyaivaṃ bhavati-mayā sattvāḥ parimocitā iti? na khalu punaḥ subhūte evaṃ draṣṭavyam| tatkasya hetoḥ ? nāsti subhūte kaścitsattvo yastathāgatena parimocitaḥ| yadi punaḥ subhūte kaścitsattvo'bhaviṣyadyastathāgatena parimocitaḥ syāt, sa eva tathāgatasyātmagrāho'bhaviṣyat, sattvagrāho jīvagrāhaḥ pudgalagrāho'bhaviṣyat| ātmagrāha iti subhūte agrāha eṣa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| sa ca bālapṛthagjanairudgṛhītaḥ| bālapṛthagjanā iti subhūte ajanā eva te tathāgatena bhāṣitāḥ| tenocyante bālapṛthagjanā iti
'What do you think, Subhuti, does the Tathagata think, "I have set beings free"? You should not see it so, Subhuti. Why? There is no being, Subhuti, whom the Tathagata has set free. If there were any being whom the Tathagata had set free, that would be the Tathagata's grasping at a self, at a being, a , a person. "Grasping at a self", Subhuti: the Tathagata has called it no grasping, yet it is grasped by foolish ordinary people. "Foolish ordinary people", Subhuti: the Tathagata has called them no people; that is why they are called foolish ordinary people.'
Note //
Even the people who grasp are not fixed things: the grasping is real as a habit, never as an owner. Muller has 'children and ignorant persons'.
The two verses
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्। यथाहं भगवतो भाषितस्यार्थमाजानामि, न लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः। भगवानाह-साधु साधु सुभूते, एवमेतत्सुभूते, एवमेतद्यथा वदसि। न लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सचेत्पुनः सुभूते लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्योऽभविष्यत्, राजापि चक्रवर्ती तथागतोऽभविष्यत्। तस्मान्न लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः। आयुष्मान् सुभूतिर्भगवन्तमेतदवोचत्-यथाहं भगवतो भाषितस्यार्थमाजानामि, न लक्षणसंपदा तथागतो द्रष्टव्यः॥ अथ खलु भगवांस्तस्यां वेलायामिमे गाथे अभाषत- ये मां रूपेण चाद्राक्षुर्ये मां घोषेण चान्वगुः। मिथ्याप्रहाणप्रसृता न मां द्रक्ष्यन्ति ते जनाः॥१॥ धर्मतो बुद्धो द्रष्टव्यो धर्मकाया हि नायकाः। धर्मता च न विज्ञेया न सा शक्या विजानितुम्॥२॥
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan| yathāhaṃ bhagavato bhāṣitasyārthamājānāmi, na lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ| bhagavānāha-sādhu sādhu subhūte, evametatsubhūte, evametadyathā vadasi| na lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sacetpunaḥ subhūte lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyo'bhaviṣyat, rājāpi cakravartī tathāgato'bhaviṣyat| tasmānna lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ| āyuṣmān subhūtirbhagavantametadavocat-yathāhaṃ bhagavato bhāṣitasyārthamājānāmi, na lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgato draṣṭavyaḥ|| atha khalu bhagavāṃstasyāṃ velāyāmime gāthe abhāṣata- ye māṃ rūpeṇa cādrākṣurye māṃ ghoṣeṇa cānvaguḥ| mithyāprahāṇaprasṛtā na māṃ drakṣyanti te janāḥ||1|| dharmato buddho draṣṭavyo dharmakāyā hi nāyakāḥ| dharmatā ca na vijñeyā na sā śakyā vijānitum||2||
'What do you think, Subhuti, is the Tathagata to be seen by the possession of marks?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher. As I understand the meaning of what you have said, the Tathagata is not to be seen by the possession of marks.' The Buddha said: 'Good, good, Subhuti. It is as you say: the Tathagata is not to be seen by the possession of marks. Why? If the Tathagata were to be seen by the possession of marks, a wheel-turning king would also be a Tathagata. So the Tathagata is not to be seen by the possession of marks.' Subhuti said to the Buddha: 'As I understand the meaning of what you have said, the Tathagata is not to be seen by the possession of marks.' Then at that moment the Buddha spoke these verses: 'Those who saw me by form, those who followed me by voice, are set on a wrong path; those people will not see me. A buddha is to be seen through the dharma; the guides have ; but the nature of dharma cannot be known as an object, it cannot be known that way.'
Note //
A wheel-turning king (cakravartin) has the same thirty-two marks, so marks cannot be what makes a buddha. 'Dharma-body' (dharmakaya) means the buddha is found as the truth of things, not as a figure. In the site's reading this is close to Advaita's point that what is real is not an object of knowing (position 8).
Not annihilation
तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते लक्षणसंपदा तथागतेन अनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिरभिसंबुद्धा ? न खलु पुनस्ते सुभूते एवं द्रष्टव्यम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न हि सुभूते लक्षणसंपदा तथागतेन अनुत्तरा सम्यक्संबोधिरभिसंबुद्धा स्यात्। न खलु पुनस्ते सुभूते कश्चिदेवं वदेत्-बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितैः कस्यचिद्धर्मस्य विनाशः प्रज्ञप्तः उच्छेदो वेति। न खलु पुनस्ते सुभूते एवं द्रष्टव्यम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? न बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितैः कस्यचिद्धर्मस्य विनाशः प्रज्ञप्तो नोच्छेदः
tatkiṃ manyase subhūte lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgatena anuttarā samyaksaṃbodhirabhisaṃbuddhā? na khalu punaste subhūte evaṃ draṣṭavyam| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na hi subhūte lakṣaṇasaṃpadā tathāgatena anuttarā samyaksaṃbodhirabhisaṃbuddhā syāt| na khalu punaste subhūte kaścidevaṃ vadet-bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitaiḥ kasyaciddharmasya vināśaḥ prajñaptaḥ ucchedo veti| na khalu punaste subhūte evaṃ draṣṭavyam| tatkasya hetoḥ ? na bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitaiḥ kasyaciddharmasya vināśaḥ prajñapto nocchedaḥ
'What do you think, Subhuti, did the Tathagata fully awaken to unsurpassed full awakening through the possession of marks? You should not see it so, Subhuti. Why? The Tathagata would not have fully awakened to unsurpassed full awakening through the possession of marks. 'Nor, Subhuti, should anyone say to you that those who have set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas have declared the destruction or the cutting off of any dharma. You should not see it so, Subhuti. Why? Those who have set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas have declared neither the destruction nor the cutting off of any dharma.'
Note //
An important guard: emptiness is not nihilism. Nothing is destroyed; what falls away is the grasping. In the site's reading this agrees with position 7: the world goes on appearing to the knower.
Merit not to be appropriated
यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा गङ्गानदीवालुकासमाँल्लोकधातून् सप्तरत्नपरिपूर्णं कृत्वा तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, यश्च बोधिसत्त्वो निरात्मकेष्वनुत्पत्तिकेषु धर्मेषु क्षान्तिं प्रतिलभते, अयमेव ततोनिदानं बहुतरं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसवेदप्रमेयमसंख्येयम्। न खलु पुनः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वेन महासत्त्वेन पुण्यस्कन्धः परिग्रहीतव्यः। आयुष्मान् सुभूतिराह- ननु भगवन् बोधिसत्त्वेन पुण्यस्कन्धः परिग्रहीतव्यः ? भगवानाह-परिग्रहीतव्यः सुभूते नो ग्रहीतव्यः। तेनोच्यते परिग्रहीतव्य इति
yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā gaṅgānadīvālukāsamām̐llokadhātūn saptaratnaparipūrṇaṃ kṛtvā tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, yaśca bodhisattvo nirātmakeṣvanutpattikeṣu dharmeṣu kṣāntiṃ pratilabhate, ayameva tatonidānaṃ bahutaraṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasavedaprameyamasaṃkhyeyam| na khalu punaḥ subhūte bodhisattvena mahāsattvena puṇyaskandhaḥ parigrahītavyaḥ| āyuṣmān subhūtirāha- nanu bhagavan bodhisattvena puṇyaskandhaḥ parigrahītavyaḥ ? bhagavānāha-parigrahītavyaḥ subhūte no grahītavyaḥ| tenocyate parigrahītavya iti
'And if, Subhuti, a son or daughter of good family filled world-systems as many as the sands of the Ganges with the seven treasures and gave them as a gift to the Tathagatas, the worthy ones, the fully awakened ones, and if a bodhisattva gained patient acceptance of dharmas as without self and unarisen, the second would on that account bring forth a greater heap of merit, beyond measure and beyond count. But a heap of merit, Subhuti, should not be taken up as one's own by a bodhisattva, a great being.' Subhuti said: 'Surely, Teacher, a heap of merit should be taken up by a bodhisattva?' The Buddha said: 'It should be taken up, Subhuti, but not grasped. That is why it is said: it should be taken up.'
Note //
'Patient acceptance' (kshanti) of non-arising is the bodhisattva's settled ease with emptiness. Merit is received and used, but not owned.
Neither coming nor going
अपि तु खलु पुनः सुभूते यः कश्चिदेवं वदेत्-तथागतो गच्छति वा आगच्छति वा तिष्ठति वा निषीदति वा, शय्यां वा कल्पयति, न मे सुभूते (स) भाषितस्यार्थमाजानाति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? तथागत इति सुभूते उच्यते न क्वचिद्गतो न कुतश्चिदागतः। तेनोच्यते तथागतोऽर्हन् सम्यक्संबुद्ध इति
api tu khalu punaḥ subhūte yaḥ kaścidevaṃ vadet-tathāgato gacchati vā āgacchati vā tiṣṭhati vā niṣīdati vā, śayyāṃ vā kalpayati, na me subhūte (sa) bhāṣitasyārthamājānāti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? tathāgata iti subhūte ucyate na kvacidgato na kutaścidāgataḥ| tenocyate tathāgato'rhan samyaksaṃbuddha iti
'Moreover, Subhuti, whoever says that the Tathagata goes or comes, stands, sits or lies down, does not understand the meaning of what I have said. Why? "Tathagata" means one who has not gone anywhere and has not come from anywhere. That is why he is called the Tathagata, the worthy one, the fully awakened one.'
Note //
The name is read as tatha-gata, 'thus gone', and tatha-agata, 'thus come'; both are undone here.
Dust and the grasping of a lump
यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा यावन्ति त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रे लोकधातौ पृथिवीरजांसि, तावतां लोकधातूनामेवंरूपं मषिं कुर्यात् यावदेवमसंख्येयेन वीर्येण तद्यथापि नाम परमाणुसंचयः, तत्किं मन्यसे सुभूते-अपि नु बहुः स परमाणुसंचयो भवेत् ? सुभूतिराह-एवमेतद्भगवन्, एवमेतत्सुगत। बहुः स परमाणुसंचयो भवेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सचेद्भगवन् बहुः परमाणुसंचयोऽभविष्यत्, न भगवानवक्ष्यत्-परमाणुसंचय इति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? योऽसौ भगवन् परमाणुसंचयस्तथागतेन भाषितः, असंचयः स तथागतेन भाषितः। तेनोच्यते परमाणुसंचय इति। यश्च तथागतेन भाषितस्त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रो लोकधातुरिति, अधातुः स तथागतेन भाषितः। तेनोच्यते त्रिसाहस्रमहासाहस्रो लोकधातुरिति। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? सचेद्भगवन् लोकधातुरभविष्यत्, स एव पिण्डग्राहोऽभविष्यत्। यश्चैव पिण्डग्राहस्तथागतेन भाषितः, अग्राहः स तथागतेन भाषितः। तेनोच्यते पिण्डग्राह इति। भगवानाह- पिण्डग्राहश्चैव सुभूते अव्यवहारोऽनभिलाप्यः। न स धर्मो नाधर्मः। स च बालपृथग्जनैरुद्गृहीतः
yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā yāvanti trisāhasramahāsāhasre lokadhātau pṛthivīrajāṃsi, tāvatāṃ lokadhātūnāmevaṃrūpaṃ maṣiṃ kuryāt yāvadevamasaṃkhyeyena vīryeṇa tadyathāpi nāma paramāṇusaṃcayaḥ, tatkiṃ manyase subhūte-api nu bahuḥ sa paramāṇusaṃcayo bhavet ? subhūtirāha-evametadbhagavan, evametatsugata| bahuḥ sa paramāṇusaṃcayo bhavet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sacedbhagavan bahuḥ paramāṇusaṃcayo'bhaviṣyat, na bhagavānavakṣyat-paramāṇusaṃcaya iti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yo'sau bhagavan paramāṇusaṃcayastathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ, asaṃcayaḥ sa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tenocyate paramāṇusaṃcaya iti| yaśca tathāgatena bhāṣitastrisāhasramahāsāhasro lokadhāturiti, adhātuḥ sa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tenocyate trisāhasramahāsāhasro lokadhāturiti| tatkasya hetoḥ ? sacedbhagavan lokadhāturabhaviṣyat, sa eva piṇḍagrāho'bhaviṣyat| yaścaiva piṇḍagrāhastathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ, agrāhaḥ sa tathāgatena bhāṣitaḥ| tenocyate piṇḍagrāha iti| bhagavānāha- piṇḍagrāhaścaiva subhūte avyavahāro'nabhilāpyaḥ| na sa dharmo nādharmaḥ| sa ca bālapṛthagjanairudgṛhītaḥ
'And if, Subhuti, a son or daughter of good family took as many world-systems as there are particles of dust in this world-system of a thousand million worlds and ground them, with countless effort, into a powder like a heap of atoms, what do you think, Subhuti, would that be a great heap of atoms?' Subhuti said: 'So it is, Teacher, so it is, Well-Gone One; that would be a great heap of atoms. Why? If there really were a great heap of atoms, you would not have spoken of a heap of atoms. Why? What the Tathagata has called a heap of atoms he has called no heap; that is why it is called a heap of atoms. And what the Tathagata has called a world-system of a thousand million worlds he has called no system; that is why it is called a world-system of a thousand million worlds. Why? If there really were a world-system, that would be the grasping of a lump. And what the Tathagata has called the grasping of a lump he has called no grasping; that is why it is called the grasping of a lump.' The Buddha said: 'The grasping of a lump, Subhuti, is beyond ordinary speech and cannot be expressed; it is neither a dharma nor no dharma. Yet it is grasped by foolish ordinary people.'
Note //
'The grasping of a lump' (pindagraha) is taking a composite as one solid thing. The world is not denied; what is denied is that it is a lump standing on its own. In the site's reading this is position 2: real as appearance, never on its own; Muller has 'belief in matter'.
Not standing on the notion of dharma
तत्कस्य हेतोः ? यो हि कश्चित्सुभूते एवं वदेत्-आत्मदृष्टिस्तथागतेन भाषिता, सत्त्वदृष्टिर्जीवदृष्टिः पुद्गलदृष्टिस्तथागतेन भाषिता, अपि नु स सुभूते सम्यग्वदमानो वदेत् ? सुभूतिराह-नो हीदं भगवन्, नो हीदं सुगत, न सम्यग्वदमानो वदेत्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? या सा भगवन् आत्मदृष्टिस्तथागतेन भाषिता, अदृष्टिः सा तथागतेन भाषिता। तेनोच्यते आत्मदृष्टिरिति॥ भगवानाह-एवं हि सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वयानसंप्रस्थितेन सर्वधर्मा ज्ञातव्या द्रष्टव्या अधिमोक्तव्याः। तथाच ज्ञातव्या द्रष्टव्या अधिमोक्तव्याः, यथा न धर्मसंज्ञायामपि प्रत्युपतिष्ठेन्नाधर्मसंज्ञायाम्। तत्कस्य हेतोः ? धर्मसंज्ञा धर्मसंज्ञेति सुभूते असंज्ञैषा तथागतेन भाषिता। तेनोच्यते धर्मसंज्ञेति
tatkasya hetoḥ ? yo hi kaścitsubhūte evaṃ vadet-ātmadṛṣṭistathāgatena bhāṣitā, sattvadṛṣṭirjīvadṛṣṭiḥ pudgaladṛṣṭistathāgatena bhāṣitā, api nu sa subhūte samyagvadamāno vadet ? subhūtirāha-no hīdaṃ bhagavan, no hīdaṃ sugata, na samyagvadamāno vadet| tatkasya hetoḥ ? yā sā bhagavan ātmadṛṣṭistathāgatena bhāṣitā, adṛṣṭiḥ sā tathāgatena bhāṣitā| tenocyate ātmadṛṣṭiriti|| bhagavānāha-evaṃ hi subhūte bodhisattvayānasaṃprasthitena sarvadharmā jñātavyā draṣṭavyā adhimoktavyāḥ| tathāca jñātavyā draṣṭavyā adhimoktavyāḥ, yathā na dharmasaṃjñāyāmapi pratyupatiṣṭhennādharmasaṃjñāyām| tatkasya hetoḥ ? dharmasaṃjñā dharmasaṃjñeti subhūte asaṃjñaiṣā tathāgatena bhāṣitā| tenocyate dharmasaṃjñeti
'Why is that? If anyone said, Subhuti, that the Tathagata has taught a view of self, a view of a being, a view of a , a view of a person, would he be speaking rightly?' Subhuti said: 'No, Teacher, no, Well-Gone One, he would not be speaking rightly. Why? What the Tathagata has called a view of self he has called no view; that is why it is called a view of self.' The Buddha said: 'This is how one who has set out in the vehicle of the bodhisattvas should know, see and be resolved about all dharmas: they should know, see and be resolved about them in such a way that they do not stand even on the of a dharma, nor on the of no dharma. Why? "The of a dharma, the of a dharma", Subhuti: the Tathagata has called it no ; that is why it is called the of a dharma.'
Note //
The teaching ends where it began: not standing anywhere, not even on its own notions.
How to explain it: the verse of the passing world
यश्च खलु पुनः सुभूते बोधिसत्त्वो महासत्त्वोऽप्रमेयानसंख्येयांल्लोकधातून् सप्तरत्नपरिपूर्णं कृत्वा तथागतेभ्योऽर्हद्भ्यः सम्यक्संबुद्धेभ्यो दानं दद्यात्, यश्च कुलपुत्रो वा कुलदुहिता वा इतः प्रज्ञापारमिताया धर्मपर्यायादन्तशश्चतुष्पादिकामपि गाथामुद्गृह्य धारयेद्देशयेद्वाचयेत् पर्यवाप्नुयात्, परेभ्यश्च विस्तरेण संप्रकाशयेत्, अयमेव ततोनिदानं बहुतरं पुण्यस्कन्धं प्रसुनुयादप्रमेयमसंख्येयम्। कथं च संप्रकाशयेत् ? तद्यथाकाशे- तारका तिमिरं दीपो मायावश्याय बुद्बुदम्। स्वप्नं च विद्युदभ्रं च एवं द्रष्टव्यं संस्कृतम्॥ तथा प्रकाशयेत्, तेनोच्यते संप्रकाशयेदिति॥ इदमवोचद्भगवान् आत्तमनाः। स्थविरसुभूतिस्ते च भिक्षुभिक्षुण्युपासकोपासिकास्ते च बोधिसत्त्वाः सदेवमानुषासुरगन्धर्वश्च लोको भगवतो भाषितमभ्यनन्दन्निति
yaśca khalu punaḥ subhūte bodhisattvo mahāsattvo'prameyānasaṃkhyeyāṃllokadhātūn saptaratnaparipūrṇaṃ kṛtvā tathāgatebhyo'rhadbhyaḥ samyaksaṃbuddhebhyo dānaṃ dadyāt, yaśca kulaputro vā kuladuhitā vā itaḥ prajñāpāramitāyā dharmaparyāyādantaśaścatuṣpādikāmapi gāthāmudgṛhya dhārayeddeśayedvācayet paryavāpnuyāt, parebhyaśca vistareṇa saṃprakāśayet, ayameva tatonidānaṃ bahutaraṃ puṇyaskandhaṃ prasunuyādaprameyamasaṃkhyeyam| kathaṃ ca saṃprakāśayet ? tadyathākāśe- tārakā timiraṃ dīpo māyāvaśyāya budbudam| svapnaṃ ca vidyudabhraṃ ca evaṃ draṣṭavyaṃ saṃskṛtam|| tathā prakāśayet, tenocyate saṃprakāśayediti|| idamavocadbhagavān āttamanāḥ| sthavirasubhūtiste ca bhikṣubhikṣuṇyupāsakopāsikāste ca bodhisattvāḥ sadevamānuṣāsuragandharvaśca loko bhagavato bhāṣitamabhyanandanniti
'And if, Subhuti, a bodhisattva, a great being, filled countless, measureless world-systems with the seven treasures and gave them as a gift to the Tathagatas, the worthy ones, the fully awakened ones, and if a son or daughter of good family took from this teaching of the Perfection of Wisdom even one verse of four lines and kept it, taught it, recited it, mastered it and made it known to others in full, the second would on that account bring forth a greater heap of merit, beyond measure and beyond count. And how should one make it known? As in the sky: A star, darkness, a lamp, a , dew, a bubble, a dream, lightning, a cloud: so should one see . So one should make it known; that is why it is said: one should make it known.' So spoke the Buddha, his mind uplifted. The elder Subhuti, the monks and nuns, the laymen and laywomen, the bodhisattvas, and the world with its gods, humans, asuras and gandharvas rejoiced in what the Buddha had said.
Note //
The closing verse lists nine images of what is conditioned (samskrita): present yet passing, seen yet not solid. Maya here is a conjuror's show, which does appear, and is in fact not what it seems; it is not a claim that nothing appears. 'As in the sky' (tadyathakashe) introduces the verse: the conditioned is to be seen like these, against the open sky.
॥आर्यवज्रच्छेदिका भगवती प्रज्ञापारमिता समाप्ता॥
||āryavajracchedikā bhagavatī prajñāpāramitā samāptā||
Here ends the noble Diamond-Cutter, the Perfection of Wisdom.
Touch an underlined word to see the Sanskrit behind it. The lighter lines are how the tradition read the verse; the rest is the verse.
The renderings on this page are shared under CC BY-NC 4.0, in the words of Pranav Ashar.