Daniel Dennett

28 March 1942 to 19 April 2024 · Born in Boston, Massachusetts; taught at Tufts University; died in Portland, Maine
Life
Daniel Clement Dennett III was born in Boston in 1942 and spent part of his childhood in Beirut. He studied at Harvard and then at Oxford under Gilbert Ryle. From 1971 he taught at Tufts University, where he directed the Center for Cognitive Studies. His books include Brainstorms (1978), The Mind's I (1981, edited with Douglas Hofstadter), Consciousness Explained (1991), Darwin's Dangerous Idea (1995) and From Bacteria to Bach and Back (2017). His memoir, I've Been Thinking, appeared in 2023. He died in 2024.
What they saw
Dennett attacked what he called the Cartesian theatre: the picture of a little self sitting in the brain, watching experience on a screen. There is no such place, he said. No such viewer. The brain runs many processes at once, drafts and redrafts, and no single one of them is where it all comes together.
The self, in his phrase, is a “center of narrative gravity”: a useful point the story of a life is told around, real the way a centre of gravity is real, and no more.
The site's reading. On the watcher, Advaita agrees with him: the observer is thought posing as a watcher. It parts from him on the witness, which is not a someone at all, and is not made of processes. Dennett would call that last step unnecessary.
In their words
In paraphrase: there is no central place in the brain where it all comes together for a viewer; the self is the centre a life's story is told around.
After Daniel Dennett, Consciousness Explained (1991) and “The Self as a Center of Narrative Gravity” (1992); paraphrase, with one short phrase quoted
Where this path meets the others
Dennett and the witness sets his case beside the Upanishads. Douglas Hofstadter was his co-editor, Thomas Metzinger his near neighbour. See The witness and The I-claim.
No one in the theatre. Something still lit.
Works
- Brainstorms1978
- The Mind's I (with Douglas Hofstadter)1981
- Consciousness Explained1991
- Darwin's Dangerous Idea1995
- From Bacteria to Bach and Back2017
Further reading
- Daniel Dennett, Consciousness Explained (1991; in copyright)
- Daniel C. Dennett and Douglas R. Hofstadter, eds., The Mind's I (1981; in copyright)
Next on your path
Sources
- Daniel Dennett, “Where Am I?”, in Brainstorms (1978; in copyright), paraphrased.
- Dennett, Consciousness Explained (1991) and “The Self as a Center of Narrative Gravity” (1992; in copyright); one short phrase quoted.
- Obituaries of 19 April 2024 (Tufts University; The New York Times), for dates.